Hannah Reece
A Slice of Hamilton’s Heart ♥️
Tucked into the heart of Hamilton is a local gem, serving up more than just great pizza, serving the community for 30 years. Open six days a week, this spot has become a second home for many. The menu is classic, comforting, and consistently delicious, but what really sets this place apart is the man behind it. The owner Mike is the kind of hardworking, dedicated person who puts his soul into every slice, every order, every conversation. I just want to make sure this incredible legacy doesn’t go unnoticed. Hamilton wouldn’t be the same without it.
… moreNicole Cozza
Food is outstanding!! Friendly staff. Vodka riggies. Antipasto. And classic plain pizza was a hit for our family. Don’t forget to grab a bucket of blue cheese dressing. You will thank me later
… moreK S
Not sure what happened. The first few times we went, we loved the food. Everything seemed made with care. This time, the pizza was terrible. There was a ton of unsauced areas, cheese wasn’t evenly applied, the whole thing was dry and awful. The pasta we got was still great. We also noticed that there was maybe a price increase? The prices on the website don’t match even close to what we were charged. We understand costs are going up, but we just wish we knew what the price was before placing the order.
… moreDane
A nice little pizza / sub shop right in the heart of downtown Hamilton. A handful of tables inside, but they do a lot of take out orders. The subs are large and the sausage sub I had was very large and filled with a lot of sausages, it was great. The inside is more interesting than your typical pizza joint, with a lot of sports memorabilia, specifically boxing.
… moreFred Lopsicker
We went to Oliveris for lunch yesterday and I have to be honest this is the best pizza I have ever had. We ordered the stuffed lasagna pizza! It was cooked perfectly and the ingredients were delicious. They even had bottles of mikes hot honey for sale which was delicious on the pizza! Top notch, highly recommend!
… moreShawnta Brantley
I’m not even done eating the food and I had to post my review lol. I’m new to the area for work and this place was suggested to me by a co-worker. Sausage parm sub and fried cauliflower… both outstanding! I can be pretty critical of food and this is sooo good!! Definitely will be back!
… moreHailey Amatuccio
Came expecting a mediocre chicken ceaser salad;
Left with my taste buds having been graced by perfectly balanced spices
… moreAlex Sauter
I’m in town for a month from FL and was looking forward to an authentic NY style pizza durring my stay. After two weeks of searching, we found Oliveri’s and to my surprise, Stuffed Lasagna Pizza, my absolute favorite pizza, was on the menu! This pizza is by far the best pizza I’ve ever had! The sauce to cheese ratio is perfect, the crust is nice and crispy and there is a wonderful surprise in the rolled crust, a soft doughy center like a hidden breadstick! Between 3 of us, only a 1/4 of this pie survived!
The wings here are also to die for, they’re fried nice and crispy, and coated evenly is a great sauce!
I encourage everyone to try their Itallian Wedding soup, it is delicious, home made, all from scratch and will warm you up on these chilly fall/winter days!
Oh, and before I forget the customer service and staff are amazing! Everyone is very friendly, they’re fast, and willing to help with whatever you need! All around a great experience, not once but twice!
… moredecor315
Out of the four pizza places in Hamilton oliveri’s is definitely the best…
Great food, friendly staff and fair prices..
I spend a lot of time out of town on business, but I make it a point to stop here for pizza and wings while I’m home. I’ve had several of their sandwhiche and were happy with them as well…
… moreDiana Edwards
I was introduced to this pizzeria a few years ago and by far it is my favorite. I will take time off of work once or twice a month just to take the ride out to Hamilton (from Utica where there is 100 pizzerias) because their pizza is so good. Our go to- lg pepperoni with a tub of blue cheese. The crust is light, with perfect proportion of sauce and cheese, and they don’t skimp on the pepperoni, the kind that curls up. They have the best homemade blue cheese – I don’t normally like blue cheese, but this stuff broke my hatred of blue cheese, it’s that good. We go during lunch, so at times it can be busy but the staff is very polite and they work their butts off.
… more