Address and Contact Information
Address: 9638 W National Ave, West Allis, WI 53227
Phone: (414) 316-9557
Website: http://www.nicos-pizza.com/west-allis-wi-location.html
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
West Allis, WI Location – Nico’s Authentic Premium Pizza
9638 W. National Ave West Allis, WI 53227 414-316-9557 Picture Welcome to our newest location, drop on in! we have a full menu! Click to open or download our …
Nico’s Pizza and Pub West Allis – Facebook
. 90% recommend (24 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 9638 W National Ave, West Allis, WI, United States, 53227. Links. . nicos-pizza.com. Services. .
Nico’s Authentic Premium Pizza – The Best Pizza is Nico’s Pizza
Nico’s Pizza at Smoke On The Water. N50 W35016 Wisconsin Ave Okauchee, WI 53069. Locations! NICO’S PIZZA AND PUB 9638 W. NATIONAL AVE. WEST ALLIS, WI 53227
Reviews
Christina Morgan
Dive bar atmosphere, pizza was different than any other pizza I’ve ever had. Crust is 100% crispy, thin. But almost to its own demise. It was so crunchy it was almost not enjoyable. We got the cantina. All the flavors were there including the sauce but the crust was so hard it was like eating a pizza cracker.
… moreAllan Schoenauer
Nico’s was great!!! Ordered the mammoth mushroom app and the sharp dressed man pizza. Mushroom app was like a corn dog batter around mushroom cap. Sauce was wonderful! Pizza was fabulous! Sausage and pepperoni went well. Sauce great, extra thin crispy pizza! Service was fantastic!
… moreLuke Steffen
Awesome visit. The garlic bread was buttery and crisp, and the marinara was had a slight tang with some sweet to it. The pizza was thin and crispy with cheese and sauce all the way to the edge. The sausage on the pizza was really good, and I don’t usually like sausage pizza. The staff was some of the friendliest I have ever encountered. This has become one of my top 5 in the area.
… moreHolly Myers
I had a terrible experience here….So it started with a misunderstanding that turned into me being ripped off, treated poorly, lied to and by the time I was finished dealing with all of this the frozen pizza from the grocery store that they served me was ice cold so that was cute… My fiance ordered food…He paid for it on his card ahead of time, so all I had to do was go in and pick it up…Well, there was an honest miscommunication between us, and I thought that I was paying for it… so when I got there the woman behind the bar handed me a receipt and the receipt said the total then it said tip and then underneath that it said, total again, and then I was to sign…. So I was going to tip even though it was a pickup order…because in my opinion, they still make the food for my family and I feel that’s worth something… so the bill was 71.03 I was going to give a 25% tip so that came to 17$ and some odd change so I just rounded it up to 18 $ that brought the bill to about 88$ so instead of asking for like 12$ or what ever back I just hand her 100$…it actually ended up being a different waitress who collected my money entirely…but as I mentioned earlier my fiance PAID IN FULL…So why on earth did this woman accept the money and receipt I signed on a pickup order that was already paid in full…well it isn’t until I get home and talk to my fiance do I realize the mistake I made… I missed him saying he paid already… so I call the restaurant and explain what happened the woman on the phone says no that I did not give her two 50$ bills… so I said another woman that works their collected it than… so she’s on the phone with me and starts asking the other woman about it…and they start going back and fourth about it…and turns out the reason the woman who took my call didn’t know or see the two 50$ bills I handed this other chick is because she pocketed my 100$ and it never made it to the drawer… they start going back and fourth with each other AGAIN as Im still on the phone!! I apologize over and over for my oversight and say that I should have been paying more attention… the woman on the phone says no she should have never took your money to begin with…she knew it was a paid for pick up order… she tells me to come pick up my money and then tells me she’s going to give me a gift card as well…needless to say when I get there Im met with a rude attitude and I’m handed back my money (which I am VERY grateful for tho BTW) and she just turns around and walks away??? But gives no giftcard to me lol…I stood there looking dumb for a few more minutes just in shock of the entire situation and quickly realized she wasn’t giving me any gift card lmao… That’s cool tho because I won’t be coming back to this place again…I can go to pick n save and pay 4 $ and buy a Tombstone pizza that tastes better any way and save 65$ lol what a joke this place is…LETS BRING BACK SHAKEYS PIZZA!!!
… moreMario Dezi
Ordered the new Chicken Mole pizza and I thought it was amazing. Definitely going back before it’s not on the menu. Wish it would be on the menu permanently though
… moreWhitney Zoellick
Our waitress Amber went above and beyond. She was great! The food was amazing! The atmosphere made you feel like family. It was definitely a great first time. We will be back for sure!!! Keep up the great work.
… moreChris Luebke
Excellent pizza place. Garlic bread was good, but the marina was amazingly good (flavorful not salty). Group of 8 no wait on a Saturday night. Pizza, burgers, pasta, buffalo thighs, fries, and marinara were all excellent. No complaints. Server caught an error in the order and fixed it before it became an issue. Thanks!
… moreNicole Krakow
The hostess immediately greeted us and we seated right away. Servers were young and new, friendly and attentive. The garlic bread was really good. There was a little hiccup with our entrees -the Italian sandwich came out long before the pizzas did, but it tasted great. The pizzas were extremely saucy, which isn’t our preference, but other than that it was a good experience.
… moreBritney Moses
I’ve been hesitating to write this review for Nico’s, simply because it’s become one of our new favorite spots, and it seems to be gaining quite the stellar reputation, becoming busier by the day.
Let’s start with the staff – they’re expanding, and each member has been consistently pleasant. However, our preference is always to sit at the bar and be served by Russ. He’s not only knowledgeable but excels in creating a consistently positive experience every visit.
Now, onto the food – it’s simply divine, with the menu continually expanding. Admittedly, we’ve only sampled the cheese garlic bread and the pizza so far, but they’ve become our go-to choices. In fact, our current favorite pizza is the pepperoni and pepperoncini, which we’ve ordered for pickup and dined in with nearly a dozen times since late December. The consistency and quality keep us coming back for more.
The homemade sauce is a standout, generously applied atop a perfectly balanced crust that’s neither too thin nor too thick. The use of large pepperonis adds an extra layer of flavor that’s simply scrumptious.
As for the cheese garlic bread, while it’s not personally my favorite of all time, but it’s still undeniably delicious. Interestingly, we recently introduced it to some friends, and one of them became absolutely obsessed, claiming it’s the best they’ve ever had. They even joked about returning solely for that garlic bread, and have talked about it several times since they had it.
Nico’s continues to impress with its delightful staff, delectable food, and welcoming ambiance. It’s no wonder it’s becoming increasingly popular.
… moreLet’s start with the staff – they’re expanding, and each member has been consistently pleasant. However, our preference is always to sit at the bar and be served by Russ. He’s not only knowledgeable but excels in creating a consistently positive experience every visit.
Now, onto the food – it’s simply divine, with the menu continually expanding. Admittedly, we’ve only sampled the cheese garlic bread and the pizza so far, but they’ve become our go-to choices. In fact, our current favorite pizza is the pepperoni and pepperoncini, which we’ve ordered for pickup and dined in with nearly a dozen times since late December. The consistency and quality keep us coming back for more.
The homemade sauce is a standout, generously applied atop a perfectly balanced crust that’s neither too thin nor too thick. The use of large pepperonis adds an extra layer of flavor that’s simply scrumptious.
As for the cheese garlic bread, while it’s not personally my favorite of all time, but it’s still undeniably delicious. Interestingly, we recently introduced it to some friends, and one of them became absolutely obsessed, claiming it’s the best they’ve ever had. They even joked about returning solely for that garlic bread, and have talked about it several times since they had it.
Nico’s continues to impress with its delightful staff, delectable food, and welcoming ambiance. It’s no wonder it’s becoming increasingly popular.
Sandi Landowski
We started with the garlic bread app, and all 5 of us were able to have a piece from one order. The thin crust pizza was generously covered with toppings of our choice. The crust was crispy with no soggy areas. The staff were charming and friendly, and we will definitely be back.
… more