Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 92 Windermere Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY 10925
Phone: (845) 595-1966
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
4 Brothers Pizzeria & Restaurant – Greenwood Lake, NY – 92 …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-10:00 PM; Shop address is 92 Windermere Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY 1092592 Windermere Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY 10925; (845) 595-4036.
Four Brothers Pizzeria and Catering – Greenwood Lake NY
92 Windermere Ave. – Greenwood Lake, NY 10925 · 845-595-1966. CONTACT ; TO PLACE AN ORDER OR FOR CATERING INFO PLEASE CALL US. HOURS: Open 7 Days a Week. 11 AM – …
4 Brothers Pizzeria & Restaurant – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
4 Brothers Pizzeria & Restaurant. 92 Windermere Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY 10925. 845-595-4036.
Last Updates
Reviews
Brenda Garcia
I absolutely love the pizza here. I always get half philly cheesesteak half bbq chicken with jalapenos, and it’s delicious. It’s worth the drive for me (which is not super far) but it’s always such a nice treat. Sitting outside during the summer is also nice and the staff is always friendly. I recommend calling your pizza ahead of time as they do make it to order.
… morePaxton Gustavsen
The only thing consistent about the food over the last five years, is that it has consistently gotten worse. Service is friendly enough, drivers have always been nice and the pizza is edible, however – the sandwiches have nothing on them but garbage cheese and minimum meat, appetizers overpriced and bland. They price as though they’re the only joint in town, and do less than deliver. Absolutely not worth the price point. Do better.
… morePatrice George-Seth
Went there on a Saturday night at 7:30pm and Pedro told me there is no pizza. Asked if he would be making new pies he said NO. This is what they had. Don’t go there they can’t handle being busy. Planet Pizza had plenty of fresh pies because yes if SATURDAY NIGHT
… moreChristal Meyer-Bonner
Ordered an XL chicken Parmesan pizza for delivery on New Year’s Eve which also happened to be my birthday… it was absolutely perfect, still hot and fresh when it got to our door, my whole family thought it was delicious, definitely one of the best birthday pizzas I’ve ever had!
… moreCrafting T
The Pizza: Don’t ruin your dinner. It was soft and soggy. The sauce was overly salted and oily, not in a-delicious-drizzle-of-olive oil kind of way; it was someone-tipped-the-drain pan-into-the-sauce greasy. After a long day of travel, I was famished, so I tried each of the 3 different slices I’d bought. Without any being enjoyable, I gave up on the pie and ate the crust. It was crunchy and dry, which I imagine soaked up some of the oil.
Dessert: I’d also purchased cheesecake. It was an abomination: hard, gummy, dry. Not edible.
… moreDessert: I’d also purchased cheesecake. It was an abomination: hard, gummy, dry. Not edible.
Audrey Rodrigues
Pizza looked great! I had a Margarita slice and Sicilian and they were both way to salty and I don’t use salt! I asked several others who were eating that day and they said the same thing. Salty! I had said something to the person making the pizza. The reply I received was its from the cheese we use.
Cute place to sit outside!
If they change cheese this would be an amazing place for pizza!
Unless you love salt then you might like it
… moreCute place to sit outside!
If they change cheese this would be an amazing place for pizza!
Unless you love salt then you might like it
Andrew
Ordered shrimp rigatoni to go get to house and start eating good shrimp size but there were only two in meal. Called and asked how many shrimp normally are in meal and I was told should be eight. So I speak one of owners or manager and explain what happen. HE TALKS TO COOK AND SAYS THE COOK SAID HE PUT EIGHT IN. Further explains impossible that there were not eight in meal. Basically calling me a liar and I confront him phone. He tells me when open it and saw there was only two in to bring it back. I then say what is the difference that I could eat 6 of them and bring it back. Will never go there again. I’ve patronized this pizza place for many years. They have definitely changed how they treat customers. Be careful ordering from here.
… moreGlynn Curtis
I only ordered take out. The orders were correct and the portions were plenty. When I made the pick up thought the location was worthy of dining in if that were the case. Nobody finished their dinner due to the portions so we all had something the next day. 4 Brothers was a quality experience for our dollar.
… moreMike Mineo
See attached photos for examples of recent orders. Just a disappointment. Food is either burnt (pepperoni roll) or undercooked (pizza). Not pictured was a Philly cheesesteak — price recently raised $2 on Doordash — where the toppings (peppers/onions) were left off entirely. DoorDash and the restaurant failed to remedy the issue. Unsure why items like those pictured are even being sent out of the kitchen.
… moreJim Einstman
We get food from this place all the time. Solid and consistent. Something has changed….for the better. Everything was even better tonight, especially the empanadas. Absolutely fantastic.
… more