Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Chain eatery specializing in thick-crust pizzas, also offering sides & desserts.
Hours
| Monday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 7 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 7288 Oak Grove Rd, Newburgh, IN 47630
Phone: (812) 490-7322
Website: https://godfathers.com/
Related Web Results
Godfather’s Pizza: Home
Our pies are piled high with quality ingredients and topped with heaping layers of perfectly melted cheese, so you enjoy a mouthful of flavors in every …
Godfather’s Pizza Express – Newburgh – MapQuest
Godfather’s Pizza Express in Newburgh, IN, offers a unique pizza experience with its commitment to quality and generous toppings.
Menu – Godfather’s Pizza
Tender Boneless Wings baked to perfection and tossed in your favorite Wing Sauce. Served with your choice of Dipper. Menus vary per location. To view the full …
Reviews
Addam Bowlin
My go-to spot for pizza needs some consistency
I’ve been a loyal customer, getting pizza from this location about once a week. I keep coming back because when the pizza is good, it’s really good. Unfortunately, the quality is often inconsistent, making it a gamble.
For example, the dough is frequently undercooked, and the toppings are placed haphazardly. One week, the pepperoni is under the cheese, the next it’s on top. The amount of toppings also varies wildly, with some weeks having barely any at all. This is surprising since the week before, everything was perfect.
I’ve noticed I rarely see the same employees, which suggests a high turnover rate. This could be the reason for the inconsistency. Investing in a good manager who can provide consistent training and ensuring employees are paid well enough to stay could make all the difference.
… moreI’ve been a loyal customer, getting pizza from this location about once a week. I keep coming back because when the pizza is good, it’s really good. Unfortunately, the quality is often inconsistent, making it a gamble.
For example, the dough is frequently undercooked, and the toppings are placed haphazardly. One week, the pepperoni is under the cheese, the next it’s on top. The amount of toppings also varies wildly, with some weeks having barely any at all. This is surprising since the week before, everything was perfect.
I’ve noticed I rarely see the same employees, which suggests a high turnover rate. This could be the reason for the inconsistency. Investing in a good manager who can provide consistent training and ensuring employees are paid well enough to stay could make all the difference.
Liz
Ordered Godfathers pizza over the phone and when I got to the store they had part of the order wrong. It was all good though because Makayla, Jason, the manager and the rest of the staff were amazing. They rectified the situation quickly and were apologetic the whole time. I wasn’t upset about the miscommunication at all but this crew is really on top of things. Great customer service all around. I love coming here and I’ll definitely be back.
… moreJack Knapp
It’s so clean & the chicken smells great as you walk into the store. And don’t forget the PIZZAS…
… moreJames Wornica
Friendly people , never short handed with tellers . Great hot bar with lots of choices for comfort food .
… moreTina Brewer (Tina)
I didn’t get pizza here but google doesn’t realize that this is all one place with other deli food. I looked at their pizza and it looked good!
… morestephanie moore
We discovered delicious, refreshing slushies on an extremely hot day!
… moreGreg Shera
The pizza is ok in a pinch, prices are pretty high for gas station pizza, but the service is good and its quick so thats convenient
… moreCameron Martin
Great place, tons of food and snacks options. Very clean
… moreAiden Folz
Very good pizza had a fun time with friends
… moreDerek Miller
Gas station pizza. Convient and cheap. Better than most grab and go pizzas.
… more