Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Step back in time at Sorella Pizzeria, just a mile from the Woodstock Museum in Bethel, NY! Our 50s-style pizzeria offers a nostalgic vibe with vintage décor and classic rock tunes. Our friendly staff welcomes you with warm smiles, making you feel like family. Indulge in our hand-tossed pizzas, from timeless plain pie to the hearty Meat Lovers and our special Sorella Signature, all made with the freshest ingredients. Grab a seat in our cozy booths, perfect for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Sorella Pizzeria blends great food with a fun, retro atmosphere. Join us for a tasty trip down memory lane!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3562 State Rte 55, Kauneonga Lake, NY 12749
Phone: (845) 583-4300
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sorella Pizzeria and Restaurant | White Lake NY – Facebook
Sorella Pizzeria and Restaurant, White Lake. 1313 likes · 33 talking about this · 856 were here. Located just one mile from Bethel Woods We’re open…
Sorella Pizzeria and Restaurant | White Lake NY – Facebook
Sorella Pizzeria and Restaurant, White Lake. 1315 likes · 10 talking about this · 856 were here. Located just one mile from Bethel Woods We’re open…
Sorella Pizzeria and Restaurant – White Lake – MapQuest
Get more information for Sorella Pizzeria and Restaurant in White Lake, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Mary Beth Ray-Simone
We stumbled upon this gem while out on a road trip in the Bethel / Woodstock area across from Kauneonga Lake. Sorella Restaurant is owned & operated by wife & husband team, Crissy & Gerry. There is a pizzeria, as well as, a formal dining room with linen table cloths & napkins which has a retro vibe & is also seasonally decorated for Halloween. A beautiful party room is available with a dance floor for your special events. When we were seated, we requested music by Frank Sinatra & were happily accommodated.
The red sauce is made from scratch. The eggplant parmigiana is made to order & was so flavorful & delicious; no breadcrumbs. The entrees are served with a super fresh side salad & a choice of pasta.
There is an extensive wine list & for those who may prefer their red wine chilled, red & white wines were available chilled or room temperature.
The desserts were very fresh & the cannoli shell was crispy & filled to order.
The only thing missing was the people. We were the only table in the dining room on a dreary Saturday afternoon. It’s a great time of year to get out & enjoy the beautiful foliage, so make Sorella Restaurant part of your road trip!
P.S. We ordered the freshly made lasagna to go & heated it for dinner upon our return to Jersey. It was fabulous! Very lite filled with the perfect balance of ricotta, ground beef & sausage just like my mother-in-law used to make. If you are in the area, order it for Thanksgiving & save yourself the time &:effort. You will not be disappointed. I wish we lived closer …
… moreThe red sauce is made from scratch. The eggplant parmigiana is made to order & was so flavorful & delicious; no breadcrumbs. The entrees are served with a super fresh side salad & a choice of pasta.
There is an extensive wine list & for those who may prefer their red wine chilled, red & white wines were available chilled or room temperature.
The desserts were very fresh & the cannoli shell was crispy & filled to order.
The only thing missing was the people. We were the only table in the dining room on a dreary Saturday afternoon. It’s a great time of year to get out & enjoy the beautiful foliage, so make Sorella Restaurant part of your road trip!
P.S. We ordered the freshly made lasagna to go & heated it for dinner upon our return to Jersey. It was fabulous! Very lite filled with the perfect balance of ricotta, ground beef & sausage just like my mother-in-law used to make. If you are in the area, order it for Thanksgiving & save yourself the time &:effort. You will not be disappointed. I wish we lived closer …
Lance Stevens
It’s been a while since I’ve gone here because the food had gone downhill so I go the extra distance to a different place, but today I didnt feel like driving so far so I decided to give them a try once more… and that was a mistake. I ordered wings and a pizza… there’s almost no cheese on the pizza and the wings are hard and dry, also white which is odd… maybe freezer burnt? They should be ashamed to put this food out.
… moreMLS (MLSGRFX)
I love this place. Theresa and her staff are so kind and welcoming. The atmosphere is that of pure Americana, circa the 1950’s. That means great music and plenty of eye candy. Looking for classic Italian cuisine? Looking to grab a quick chicken parmigiana hero on the go? Maybe you’re looking to sit with friends and family while enjoying great music and a beer then give Sorella a try!
… moreAshlee Sherman
Not only is it great food, but the lady saw i had a carseat in one hand and a toddler holding the other and she offered to carry my pizza out and even put it in the car for me! Above and beyond and so grateful!!
… moreSallie Freed
The ladies were nice and the one who opened the door went out of her way.
Some of the best pizza I’ve had. Including NYC and PHL. That sez a lot.
… moreSome of the best pizza I’ve had. Including NYC and PHL. That sez a lot.
Melancholy Mermaid
Grabbed a quick pizza here while in town doing all things Woodstock. The staff were very friendly and the history was interesting. Sadly the pizza wasn’t the best but it might have just been us because the place was buzzing with locals.
… moreJessica Taft
I’m from NYC and for the last two years, this area was waaaaaay better than John’s or Joes, or any famous NYC slice. This summer? Mediocre school birthday party pizza. Maybe they’re under new management?
… moreAnny
This place is god awful. Tried it once 5 years ago per everyone’s recommendation and did again recently. Damn this place SUCKS!!!!! Dont let the locals convince you its worth checking out. Its not.
… moreJim S
Have previously had take-out and dined in for lunch. Dined in for dinner this evening. The service was excellent. The food was very good as were the portions. The atmosphere is pleasant.
… moreMargaret Desmarais
SPARTAN CARB loaders…this is your spot. Friendly service, not packed, family owned business. My service and food was great!!! ❤❤❤❤❤
… more