Local chain serving pizzas, sandwiches & appetizers in a casual, low-key setting.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 129 E Reynolds Rd, Lexington, KY 40517
Phone: (859) 272-6671
Website: https://www.sirpizzaky.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Sir Pizza of Kentucky
5 Shoppers Dr Winchester, KY 40391 · (859) 744-0210. Sunday – Thursday 11am to 1am. Friday & Saturday 11am to 2am ; 1076 S Broadway Lexington, KY 40504 · (859) …
Sir Pizza Delivery Menu | Order Online | 463 New Circle Rd Lexington
Order delivery or pickup from Sir Pizza in Lexington! View Sir Pizza’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with Grubhub!
Sir Pizza Near Me – Pickup and Delivery – Order Online
Sir Pizza of Kentucky (S BROADWAY). 1076 South Broadway, Lexington. Order Here. Sir Pizza of Kentucky (NEW CIRCLE RD). 463 West New Circle Road, Lexington.
Reviews
Ross Wilson
I truly mean it when I say, this is THE BEST pizza I have ever had and probably ever will have. Nowhere else have I tasted such a unique and perfect blend of spice and seasonings in a pizza. That goes for the meat, sauce and cheese. And I don’t know what they do to their dough, but it’s just perfection. It’s a great blend of soft and crispy. Even the Mountain Dew seems to taste better than usual. My family has gone here all my life. Certainly one place that has stayed consistently good over the years! Even though we no longer live nearby, we certainly come back for more when we visit the area. We have always had amazing service. Vinnie in particular is amazing! He is always very friendly and seems to make the pizza extra good! He certainly makes you feel welcomed. Because I literally cannot comprehend a better blend of flavor, every other pizza place is pretty much competing for 2nd place in my book. I hope this place stays around for generations to come as a local staple. Much love indeed! God bless!
… moreJoyce Smith
First time having Sir Pizza. It did not disappoint! Very meaty, cheesy, Fresh and Hot! I walked in ordered and waited. The gentleman at the counter was very customer friendly and patient. Great pizza and I will be returning!
… moreWater Scott (WaterScoTT)
A Lexington Classic establishment that serves up a unique style of pizza. The atmosphere is comfortable and the food is great. Years ago they served fennel seed on their pizza, the meat amore specifically i believe. I asked the man working there and he didnt know what i was talking about but this was a long time ago so he probably didn’t work there. Anyway it is something i’d love to see come back.
… moreBob Bays
This guy has been in this location … forever… and makes one heck of a pizza. It’s not a fancy joint, but the pizza is hot, fresh and delicious. Had my 92 year old aunt with me, ordered take out pizza and feasted in Shillito Park. Great time, lol.
… moreKivva Greenlee- Williams
I ordered an extra-large pepperoni pizza, a chef salad, and a 2-liter of Pepsi over the phone. When I arrived, the clerk asked for my information and then claimed I had called to cancel my order. I clarified that I had only made one call to place the order. He told me to take a seat while he prepared it.
After about ten minutes, he said my order was ready. Unfortunately, the pizza was a disappointment—barely any cheese or pepperoni, despite Sir Pizza’s reputation for edge-to-edge toppings. When I pointed this out, he tried to convince me that it was normal for them. I told him I had eaten there countless times and that this was not the standard I expected, especially when it comes to Sir Pizza.
He then made me an 8-inch pepperoni pizza, which looked much better. I remarked, “This is how the pizza should look,” but he dismissed it by saying yeah, yeah, yeah. Then, out of nowhere, he blamed rising prices on Trump, which made no sense since Trump wasn’t the one making the pizza.
In short, this Sir Pizza is under new management, and the quality has declined significantly. The cheese and pepperoni have changed, and the ham in the chef salad was subpar. It doesn’t live up to the Sir Pizza legacy. They really need to reconsider their approach before they drive it into the ground.
… moreAfter about ten minutes, he said my order was ready. Unfortunately, the pizza was a disappointment—barely any cheese or pepperoni, despite Sir Pizza’s reputation for edge-to-edge toppings. When I pointed this out, he tried to convince me that it was normal for them. I told him I had eaten there countless times and that this was not the standard I expected, especially when it comes to Sir Pizza.
He then made me an 8-inch pepperoni pizza, which looked much better. I remarked, “This is how the pizza should look,” but he dismissed it by saying yeah, yeah, yeah. Then, out of nowhere, he blamed rising prices on Trump, which made no sense since Trump wasn’t the one making the pizza.
In short, this Sir Pizza is under new management, and the quality has declined significantly. The cheese and pepperoni have changed, and the ham in the chef salad was subpar. It doesn’t live up to the Sir Pizza legacy. They really need to reconsider their approach before they drive it into the ground.
Joshua Poe
I have been coming here for 25 years and the pizza is always delicious and the same guy has been taking my order with a smile for all of those years. We always get the Royal Feast, and it is always loaded with toppings, smoking hot out of the oven, and delicious. I would always recommend eating your pizza there instead of getting it to go. When you get it to go, it steams in the box taking away the crunch of the crust. Don’t get me wrong, it is still good, but nothing like it is fresh from the oven. We have tried all of the other Sir Pizzas in Lexington and none of them taste the same as this location. I wander if they use different ovens or something at the other locations. The only draw back to eating here, is that nothing has been updated in years. As a matter of fact, I have not seen any changes in the entire 25 years that I have been coming here. This place looks like it is straight from the 70’s. My family always jokes that we are rolling the dice with food poisoning every time that we come here, but in fairness we have never had any issues in all the time we have been coming. If you want a fat unique pizza for a reasonable amount of money and you can look past the decor, I would say definitely give this place a try! Pro tip – they always run an unadvertised special where you can get any extra large pizza for the price of a large. All you have to do is ask for the deal.
… moreSoma Chakraborty
I ordered a chicken pizza & there were only 4 tiny pieces of chicken on the pizza. The salad I ordered was supposed to be blue cheese. To my utter disappointment there were absolutely NO cheese in the salad, just leaves & cabbage. Totally frustrated. Not a patron & not returning!
… moreMaura Fabulous
Just paid $25.99 for 2 lasagnas and a small drink and this is what I get. Before the non american born citizen took over this joint, the lasagna actually touched the lid. It doesn’t even smell right! I miss the world I grew up in. Long live the ’80s…
… moreChad Wells
As someone who has worked in the Food service industry I’m absolutely amazed this place is still in Business. We have been told multiple times after we have already sat down that they were only offering carry out orders. Which after using there restroom I had decided that we were leaving anyways. It was absolutely disgusting which leads me to believe the kitchen would be no better. Strongly suggest going to the one on Broadway to get your Sir Pizza fix.
… moretoby lol
Me and my friend walked here after shopping at the mall. We had gotten a 8 inch pepperoni pizza and it was alright, the pizza was just slap full of pepperonis lol! The worker there gave us free refills on our drinks was so nice and it was very chill and wonderful there! amazing service!
… more