Sarah W.
We dined outside on a pleasant day, which made for a nice experience as we could also watch the weekend tournament nearby. Service was excellent—our server took the time to answer our questions and explain the menu. However, the food itself didn’t quite live up to expectations. The so-called “dip” turned out to be more like a Philly cheesesteak without the green peppers, and the kid’s fruit cup was disappointing, consisting of nothing more than a store-bought skinless mandarin cup. Overall, while the service and atmosphere were very good, the food left us feeling a bit let down compared to what we anticipated.
… moreAlycia French
We went at lunch and had burgers. Service was friendly and the atmosphere was comfortable the view was gorgeous. The salad bar was a little below par and only one soup selection per day was a little disappointing for an all ypu can eat soup and salad bar but all in all it is worth 5 stars.
… moreLaura Hill
We truly love visiting here, and our family from out of state and even abroad also enjoys McCarty’s. The staff is always friendly and attentive, the food is delicious, and there’s lovely outdoor patio seating with beautiful views of the golf course. We highly recommend it!
… moreJoy Roden
We had a party of 9 in the special room. The server did a great job for a big party. Salad bar was nice and the chicken fried chicken is always a favorite. Will definitely return.
… moreRylee Daniels
Best dining experience I’ve had in a while. The servers are amazing and will go out of their way to make your experience memorable. Prime Rib is fresh Wednesday- Sunday and will melt in your mouth. They also just added Brussel Sprouts as an appetizer!! Will be coming back!
McCarty’s is also open to the public!
… moreAaron Sternberg
Unfortunately missed breakfast by a few minutes but ate lunch and the food was very tasty I definitely recommend the Buffalo Tater Tots and the strawberry cheesecake cake. Service was top notch and plan when in the area again, definitely dine here.
… moreTy Lopez
I still give McCarty’s 5 stars in all 3 classes, even though I had a bad experience in getting my take out order in a timely fashion, and my food portions were not to par. No pun intended. All I can say was they were really busy, and I completely understand that at times things do not go as planned. Deanna, who is the manager, went above and beyond to make my experience this time not as bad as it really was. She is a true professional, and I feel that she needs to be commended for her urgency to make things right. She is definitely worthy of getting credit for being a manager who cares about her clientele. This is the 1st time I have ever been disappointed in visiting McCarty’s, but I will always be a faithful patron. The food is always on point in taste, which definitely counts in being a well established, good restaurant. Thank you, Deanna, for being empathetic to my situation and for being such a professional in your field. GOD bless you.
… moreloretta burman
The take and bake Christmas dinner was amazing! Will definitely do more take and bake!put together so well
Thank you
… moreTom Roberts
A nice place to eat in Eaton, Colorado. Good food at a reasonable price and a Value Pack coupon which saved me $15.00. The dinning room had some pesky flies, though. (Rural Colorado in the fall.)
… moreEric Eggers
We’ve lived in Eaton for over a year know and have been wanting to try this place. We made reservations for father’s day and we were not disappointed at all. Service was very friendly and very fast. Food was so delicious and at super reasonable prices. I highly recommend the Irish egg rolls. So good. We will for sure be back and become regulars. Thank you McCartys!!!! 11 stars
… more