Dan Laposa
Food and Service were very good. Atmosphere not so much. Very confusing layout and looks like they opened restaurant without really having Palermo’s put their own spin on the layout. Bathroom definitely needs an upgrade as well. Now for the food. Appetizers were delicious. Cheesesticks had a beer batter taste and definitely filling. Sausage Fried Ravioli was the GOAT of the Appetizers. We ordered extra sauce on pizzas so dont be hating on the non burnt pizzas. Lol. Palermos sauce is on the sweeter side too. Deep Dish is not up to Giordano’s or Beggars but their “thin crust” is definitely in my top top 10. I’d call it more of a “double-dough” for the Chicago pizza people that know. Service was very good for only having one manager and one waitress. Have to come back for sandwiches and more apps next visit. 7/10
… moreshealean hubert
Fantastic pizza with great taste and quality ingredients! The crust is perfectly baked, the cheese is deliciously melted, and the toppings are fresh. Orders are prepared quickly and served hot. The staff is friendly and welcoming. A great place to enjoy tasty pizza with family and friends.
… moreRich
Very friendly staff. The food was good. I ordered a stuffed pizza and it was stuffed. Tons of cheese and bread and meat with a very sweet sauce. The thickness of the pizza balanced the sweetness of the sauce well. At the time I went they were out of unsweetened ice tea which would have gone a long way to balancing the flavor of the pizza. The restaurant was out of their homemade mozzarella sticks too which I was disappointed about. Despite these issues the staff was super helpful. If you come to try the deep dish stuffed be prepared for a 40 minute cook time.
… moreMelissa Oseguera
This place is amazing!!!! I have no words to describe how great the food is. The chef really likes his sauce. The ambiance is so cozy and comfortable. I’ve been telling people about it left and right. Can’t wait to go back.
… moreJudy Defrancisco
We just moved to Hobart Indiana and we always went to Palermo’s so we went and tried there period and it was amazing. And very clean the service was great the waitress was awesome. And the food was amazing. I will be back. This was just for starter I had the fried cauliflower oh my God it was so good and my husband had the bread of mushrooms. And then we had our dinner which we could not finish.
… moreDiane Kaskey Cole
We ordered a medium sausage, pepperoni and onion thick crust pizza and 2 small salads. The salads were waterlogged and not good. I only ate a little lettuce and croutons. It made me sick later. Pizza was delicious but slip their salads. Spend a little bit more for an appetizer. It was my first time eating here.
… moreJennifer W
I was celebrating my dad’s first heavenly birthday (the Palermo’s on 63rd) was his favorite. I mentioned it and they gave me a larger pizza and tons of wings! The food was delicious and their kindness will forever me remember!
… moreEmily
i don’t know what’s going on. my family’s favorite takeout place and have the best pizza and caesar salad but the last two times my lettuce is sopping wet. the chicken is gross, my lettuce is not crunchy (mind u i live 2 mins away), my croutons are SOGGY, and you get like 10 pieces of lettuce now.
… moreCJ Kumi
I hate leaving this review as I love Palermos and have been going to Palermos for a long time (since 63rd) but 2 out of 4 orders have been bad one was a stuffed that had little to no cheese and recently a very weird thin crust that was not thin it was puffy and again the cheese was limited and not even on all the outer pieces I am sorry for this review but for your prices (which I am willing to pay for good pizza) it should be more consistent. You may have lost a long time customer.
… moreColleen Maxey
Was hesitant to go just because it’s Sunday, but they weren’t busy! I’m glad we went despite my misgivings. I ordered a small salad as an appetizer….it was a good size and quality. I had a gluten free veggie special pizza and my husband had Italian beef and fries. Both of our meals were huge! The pizza has ruined me for any other pizza…it was fantastic… especially the sauce. My husband’s sandwich was so packed he couldn’t eat his fries (and they gave him so many fries the take out container was packed). It’s nice to see a restaurant give people their money’s worth. The food really is good. We will be back…the menu has plentiful choices from which to choose! Wait staff was very nice!
… more