Rich de la Torre
Wyckoff pizza is a place for some great pizza.
I recommend their
– chicken bacon ranch
– chicken tender, hot honey-mustard
Service is nice and the interior is warm and inviting
… moreMelissa Miller
A family favorite for 10+ years. Chicago pan meat lovers NEVER disappoints. They’ll always call with any questions regarding your order customizations to double check it’s made to your liking which is very much appreciated! And the onion rings… always so crispy and perfect. Highly recommend!!
… moreJ Moncada
Our boys entire soccer team and families had a wonderful time here! All food options were fresh and delicious. I’m glad we choose this place to celebrate our end of season. Thanks to all the staff for their patience and great service!
… morejames luski
Stopped in for a plain slice. $3.15. Good flavor, great sauce, crust was a bit flimsy and overall a tad greasy for my taste. There were 18 pizza varieties choose from at the counter. I’d go back.
… moreMia Reid
I went before and the food and the attention was really good, so I went back with my boyfriend, and it was a terrible experience. Not one of the servers knew what they were doing, to ask for a drink I had to explain to 3 different servers what I wanted. Food lasted forever to come to the table, and since we arrived after 8 pm, they were eager for us to leave. One of the guys was nice, took our order and said they were near to close (more than 30 minutes ahead) but we could stay as long as we wanted. Fun thing, the other girl came and gave us our bill before the food was even ready; when we were finally eating, halfway on our food, she came and said… We’re near to close, do you want me to pack your food? So she took it and packed it. She cleaned over us and almost kicked us out. Terrible attitude, no customer service skills at all, how is she working with people? Of course, we left no tip for this disrespectful person. We were out of the restaurant 4 minutes before nine, like ten minutes after the food arrived. Let me tell you, if you want to keep customers, never kick them out, never interrupt their meal just because you want to go home. I am paying for my food, and my money makes your salary, more if your money come from tips. The food is not as good as to make me go back in there to be treated that poorly. No, thanks.
… moreSteve Berger
Someone recommended WP just the other day. So I gave it a shot. Cheese pizza with pepperoni – thin crust and CRISPY.
The crust is doughy and chewy – just the opposite of thin and crispy.
I typically freeze leftover pizza but not bothering with this. It’s horrible and I should have heated up frozen pizza instead of wasting my money on Wyckoff pizza.
Spare yourself the disappointment and call Dominos instead.
… moreA Person
Great Pizza! The dough is light not dense at all and the veggies were super fresh! The pizza was soo delicious! Great service, my first New Jersey Pizza!
… moreKasey Lai
Their pizza is great, but I have a favorite… Artichoke Chicken, with creamy pesto bowties and sundried tomatoes 🙂
YUM !! They had it ready in 15 minutes and portion feeds two easy !
… moreGreg T
Everything was fine, food and very good service. Just extremely overpriced for what you get.
… moreJohn Hornstra
I gave a 2 star review because I have had good pizza from here in the past, otherwise this would be a 1star. The pizza wasn’t edible because it wasn’t cooked. When you picked up a slice it flopped down & the cheese & sauce just slid off. I picked up because you really cannot dine in there during lent because they are busy & the service has never been that great to begin with. So sad that one of the better pizza places has come to this. I wasn’t even able to eat 1 slice. A total waste of time & money. The pie is in the garbage!
… more