Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
The Tastes You Crave, The Quality You Trust Since 1985! At Cristy’s Pizza, we’re known for doing things the right way — starting with bold, sweet sauce from fresh vine-ripened tomatoes, our signature dough recipe, all-natural premium cheese, fresh-cut vegetables, and old world pepperoni. It’s the quality ingredients and the care our team puts into every order that sets us apart.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1001 S Main St #12, Baltimore, OH 43105
Phone: (740) 862-6611
Website: https://cristyspizza.com/baltimore-ohio/?utm_source=gbp&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=baltimore
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cristy’s Pizza – Baltimore, Ohio
Cristy’s Pizza in Baltimore is proud to be a true part of the community. We offer dine-in seating, easy pickup, and fast delivery—all with fresh, made-to-order …
Cristy’s Pizza: Your Favorite Local Pizza Shop in Southeast Ohio
Order online and see for yourself! Get pizza delivered in Amanda, Baltimore, Lancaster, Circleville, Chillicothe and Logan. You deserve it!
Cristy’s Pizza – Baltimore – Visit Fairfield County
Visit Cristy’s Pizza in Baltimore, Ohio for everything from their amazing pies and calzones to fresh salads, oven-baked subs, and Cristy’s Famous Cheesy …
Reviews
Tim Taylor
Came to Ohio (Dayton) over the weekend to attend a celebration of life service on Saturday and stayed in Baltimore at my sister & brother-in-law’s place and was craving some good Ohio pizza. Pizza in Myrtle Beach (where I live) isn’t the best, so my hopes were high and boy, did y’all knock it out of the park. Great cook, flavor and balance of sauce to toppings. Was quite pleased and will definitely order again when in town! Was a bit pricy for a medium, but would have been less if I drove the mile to pick up than have delivered 🙂 Thanks for a great product!
… moreDj Potts
Always great food. Go to location But last time pizza was little undercooked and our bread stix were too crispy. All in all would always eat here again.
… moreCheri Thomas
i normally do not do reviews. my mom and i were at christy’s 2 weeks ago. The pizza we got was horrible. Not fresh and felt like it was reheated. We went last night June 21st to give them one more chance. we ordered and was told would be 20 minutes. After waiting 35 minutes my mom said something. The person who took our order did not place it. This person knew we were waiting a long time because she was washing tables and looked right at us. I think it was the manager who came to us and apologized and offered free cookies. Poor customer service. We should have been offered a full refund. Finally after almost an hour waiting we get the pizza. The pizza was good but definitely lacking in customer service. This is your second strike Christy’s one more and you’re out.
… moreTrent Westcamp
This Cristy’s location used to be our “go-to” but something happened in the last year that’s made several experiences now unenjoyable and unreliable.
Let’s start with some positives. The pizza is always great, and the delivery drivers are always very professional. This location does have some bright spots, so I don’t want to just focus on the negitive here.
Unfortunately, this particular Cristy’s is always out of the things that we love. Specifically the Peperoni Nibblers. I understand that these are a speciality item, but come on. There’s not that many options to choose from on the menu. I could understand if the menu was several pages.
Items are constantly forgotten about with our order as well. I can’t tell you how many times they’ve forgotten things like dipping sauces, and can’t remember the last time we received garlic butter that we ordered.
We order from this Cristy’s as a “last resort, nothing else is open” meal. Maybe I’m expecting too much from a pizza place, but for the price I’m being charged(alot)..my order should be right ♂️
… moreLet’s start with some positives. The pizza is always great, and the delivery drivers are always very professional. This location does have some bright spots, so I don’t want to just focus on the negitive here.
Unfortunately, this particular Cristy’s is always out of the things that we love. Specifically the Peperoni Nibblers. I understand that these are a speciality item, but come on. There’s not that many options to choose from on the menu. I could understand if the menu was several pages.
Items are constantly forgotten about with our order as well. I can’t tell you how many times they’ve forgotten things like dipping sauces, and can’t remember the last time we received garlic butter that we ordered.
We order from this Cristy’s as a “last resort, nothing else is open” meal. Maybe I’m expecting too much from a pizza place, but for the price I’m being charged(alot)..my order should be right ♂️
Rae Sanderson
Worst pizza experience I’ve ever had. A bunch a teenage girls run the front, lost my order, then apparently delivered my order so some random address. They made me wait almost an hour for a “itll be ready in 15” pick up order. Told me theyd make it, 20 minutes go by and the NEVER started it.Absolutely horrible customer service.
… morezhpxr
We go to Cristy’s pizza a lot. Customer service is very good and so is the food. Thank you for your hard work!
… moreMr. Branham
Good sauce. It’s a regular pizza shop. I wish the crust was thinner. However you won’t be disappointed.
… moreRay
Let me start by saying the food is good. However hearing the lady in the back I assume the manager talk to her staff like they are fully incapable of doing their jobs is disgusting and not becoming of someone in management. That reason alone I nor my family will ever return
… moreNonia Biznatch
Hadn’t had Christy’s in quite some time and had never visited this location before. But was visiting a friend and decided to give this location a try. Our pizza was really good! Crisp thin crust, lots of cheese and pep and looked as good as it tasted! Will visit again when in the Baltimore area. Cashier was friendly and service was quick.
… moreNicholas Salisbury
Edit: We went back, two weekends in a row. Picked a few different topping combinations and everything was top notch. Upped those stars from 4 to 5.
There isn’t a lot of good pizza around Granville. Some friends turned us on to Cristy’s. We made the trek down there to try it out and it was great. The crust wasn’t too thin, sauce and toppings were tasty. And the bake was perfect.
The only reason this is a 4 and not a 5 is because I need to go back for round two and try a couple different options.
… moreThere isn’t a lot of good pizza around Granville. Some friends turned us on to Cristy’s. We made the trek down there to try it out and it was great. The crust wasn’t too thin, sauce and toppings were tasty. And the bake was perfect.
The only reason this is a 4 and not a 5 is because I need to go back for round two and try a couple different options.