Old-school German mainstay with rib-sticking traditional dishes such as sauerbraten & vintage decor.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 640 Main St, Northport, NY 11768
Phone: (631) 757-7959
Website: http://pumpernickelsofnorthport.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pumpernickel’s Restaurant – Northport
Friday – Saturday 11:30AM – 10PM Sunday 1PM – 9PM. 640 Main Street, Northport NY 11768 631.757.7959. *We Do Not Honor Or Accept Any Coupons From Restaurant.com*
Pumpernickels – Updated 2026, German Restaurant in Northport, NY
Pumpernickels, located in Northport, New York, serves traditional German cuisine in a setting decorated with vintage décor. The restaurant prides itself on …
How is Pumpernickel’s in Northport it used to be good – Facebook
This weekend, Northport Historical Society is thrilled to honor Artie Glad and The 50th Anniversary of Pumpernickels Restaurant at our Annual …
Reviews
Amanda Young
Was craving a hearty meal potatoes and gravy so we decided to stop here for dinner. For appetizers we had the clams casino that had so much flavor! For dinner we ordered the famous sauerbraten with mashed potatoes and red cabbage my husband ordered pork schnitzel! Sauerbraten was so tender and the gravy was spot on! We cleaned our plates. For dessert we had the Black Forest cake which was the perfect ending! The atmosphere was great loved how all the waitresses wore cute German Dresses. We kept saying we felt like we were out of state! Live piano player and singer. Overall we will be back again!!
… moreRobert Thompson
Great community favorite. Heart German cuisine as well as numerous Continental dishes. Cozy seeing. Family oriented.
… moreNicole Mangano
Awesome food and the service was excellent! Sherry our waitress was amazing! We had a lovely time for my mothers birthday the other night. Couldn’t have picked a better place!
… moreKevin Smith
The food and menu are excellent, the waitress is expert and German-speaking. The food is not just German (mainly German) but continental. The interior is great, the upstairs bathrooms and phone cabinet are classic and there is an ample parking lot. This was out of the way for me but my detail thought I would enjoy this. On a rainy Saturday afternoon in an empty German restaurant my soul was refilled. The waitress was joy personified. Dance. Mahlzeit!
… moreGreg Arbutine
The food quality was outstanding and very authentic. The sauces were absolutely superbly made. Very generous portion sizes. The atmosphere felt like being in Germany. The staff were friendly. Highly recommend!
… moreJon Rivera
Food is horrible and overpriced. Ordered the goulash and the noodle were watery. I’m not Hungarian but I have had goulash before I know how it should taste and look. Also ordered wings and read that it was $19 but menu didn’t state how many wings, so I asked and the waitress said “like 12 wings”. I accepted and only received 9 dried wings for $19. They also gave us refrigerated bread. The place is really a bar for locals and not worth it for food. Very disappointed. The French onion soup was the only good thing they had. If you want beer and to hang with locals and maybe just have French ion soup then this is your spot.
… moreKevin Smith
This German restaurant was a bit out of the way but just what I needed on a rainy Saturday afternoon. The combo lunch included soup, dessert and coffee with an entrée and is a phenomenal deal. The wiener schnitzel was divine, the rice beautifully cooked. The interiors were a restrained Bavarian and the service was impeccable. This is not Figlmüller’s but I was blissfully unaware. So Northport isn’t Vienna. Who cares? Mahlzeit!
… morePaul Bayer
Artie the owner is a bin vivant, greets every customer warmly and enjoys every minute in his place. It shows through the service, the food and the atmosphere of the place. The waitresses are wonderful – mine read the menu for me and translated the dish names (which are in German) and explained each dish. I asked for something that wasn’t quite on the menu, and she said she would figure it out. I had the beef rouladen and she brought a side of mushrooms, which went perfectly with the roulade sauce. The desserts are good, the bathrooms upstairs (something to note if you have trouble with stairs), but overall – it’s a great restaurant.
… moreFrank Lee
I love this place! Always great food. I have never had a bad dish and have been coming here for decades.
… moreHeinrich Beck
I grew up in a German household. My parents, German immigrants, used to eat here back in the day.
Tragic. The food is terrible and the prices are ridiculous for what they serve. Tasteless carrots, potato dumplings are some bizarre mashed ball covered with terrible brown gravy.
Schnitzel was terrible. The soup and mashed potatoes were actually good. The decor was nice. My wife liked the Tiffany lamps.
There are many better places to eat in Northport. Even McDonald’s is across the street.
… moreTragic. The food is terrible and the prices are ridiculous for what they serve. Tasteless carrots, potato dumplings are some bizarre mashed ball covered with terrible brown gravy.
Schnitzel was terrible. The soup and mashed potatoes were actually good. The decor was nice. My wife liked the Tiffany lamps.
There are many better places to eat in Northport. Even McDonald’s is across the street.