Athena Sevastos
OMG I hadn’t been there in years & it’s still as wonderful as always. When I opened the door and smelled the awesome food a million wonderful memories came flooding back! Their bread is amazing! My Husband had the Italian wedding soup which is a very hearty soup! You definitely have to try it! The salads were fresh with excellent dressings. My husband had the house dressing and he was very impressed. I had the blue cheese and it was as tasty as I remembered! Then I got my favorite, spaghetti with mushrooms! It was even better than I remembered! My husband had veal piccata with the side of spaghetti that was the size of a main meal at other restaurants! We ended up bringing lots of food home!
… moreAdrienne Andrews
Wonderful bread and 2 garden salads and zucchini straws and 2 soft drinks at 3.50 a piece, really? Waitress over bearing almost rude. 23.00 for pasta? Little pricey for me. Patty asked for our order like she wanted to get rid of us. 4 times, lost my appetite, sorry.34$ was a little overboard for mom and pop shop
… moreMargaret Valletta
We Love Vicinato’s! Family owned and run and they welcome you like you are part of the family. Food is always delicious! Friday is pasta Fagioli and Tripe special. My husband’s favorite. A favorite is the fresh hot Italian Bread and Butter. Its SO GOOD! Our server Shannon was fabulous! She has been here over 20 years. I love my salad and Mushroom/onion Pizza! It is a great little restaurant that you will want to come back for lunch and dinner again and again! Subs, Pasta, cutlets and all things Italian. And they have Take Out too!
… moreFirst Last
Did an online order and picked up seemed busy and got helped fast and it was pretty hospitable.
The pizza was a little light on cheese the pepperoni didn’t have any crunch to it. The dough almost tasted slightly frozen which sucked and the dough didn’t have much flavor nor did the tomato sauce. Maybe getting one of the specialty pizzas would be better or one of the other entree types? Wouldn’t spend money here again, which sucks since my co worker recommend it. Maybe it was just a bad pie.
I felt like I was just eating mediocre bread. It’s already bad for me, at least have it taste good. Really made me sad for the price of 50$. Anyone know any good pizza places in mayfield? I need some flavor.
… moreEman Good
This place really disappointed me because I had food from here and it was actually good. The first time this time. It was terrible. Got a three-piece fish dinner with fries and a salad and it was absolutely mediocre at best. The staff did not wear gloves and they was very unsanitary saw people wiping their nose and still cutting bread was very disappointed. Had to throw the food away and go somewhere else.
… moreJeffrey Vender
Awesome, old school Italian restaurant. The pizza in particular in phenomenal, the prices are reasonable, and the servers were very friendly.
… moreDrew Webb
The best local pizza parlor in Lyndhurst. It took me seven years of living here to finally try them. They never disappoint.
… moreA G
You will not leave hungry. Not only is the food very tasty, the portions are ample. The garden salad was crisp and the house Italian dressing is very good. I had a chicken parm “sandwich” which was no doubt made in house. Companion had rigatoni Alfredo with broccoli and added chicken. Report is that the chicken to pasta ratio was excellent (read lots of chicken)
… moreMichael Zaslov
Service was excellent, pizza was perfect, chicken parm was perfect. Didn’t take pictures of the food, they were to busy, but trust me you will enjoy.
… moreEd Klimas
Wonderful neighborhood family Italian restaurant. The staff is very friendly and the menu is outstanding. Great value. The pizza is one of the better ones in the area.
… more