Seth Fayerman
Only stopped in for a few bagels but they had a great selection and of course the coffee cake on the counter looked heavenly. Bagels were fluffy and tasty! I think I’ve found my new favorite spot!
… moreKenneth McArdle
One of the last great bagel shops around, good old school bagel the way it should be. All the new bagel places in the area serve bread, not bagels. Climb the hill and let go of the eggo bagels.
… moreLisa McCarthy
Ordered online but they gave me the wrong sandwich. Called to let them know, didn’t offer to credit me just offered to make the correct one. Too late, since I picked up and brought it home. Going right in the garbage.
… moreMichael Bell
Mike and his staff are amazing! The coffee is always hot and the breakfast sandwiches are consistent and on point. This strip mall has certainly seen better days and I’m starting to think the only reason it’s not a complete failure is because these guys have been here for 30 years making the areas best Here’s To 30 more! #TheHungryAgent #NJLocalRealtor #foodreviews #localseatbetter
… moreRebecca Krueger
I could have made a better bagel at home than half an egg, 2 slices of bacon, and 1 slice of bacon and a crappy everything bagel. You might as well go to the store and buy everything you need for cheaper. Than go here to get a bagel with barely anything on it.
… moreChristos Kazameas
Pastrami egg and cheese on a cheddar jalapeno bagel was one of the best breakfast sammies I’ve had.
… moreElih North
Bagel Bliss at Bagels on the Hill!!!
No trip to New Jersey is complete without indulging in some iconic bagels, and Bagels on the Hill delivers perfection every time! Their bagels, slathered with thick, delicious cream cheese, are a true delight for the taste buds. With their longstanding reputation, it’s no wonder they’re a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Don’t miss out on the bagel experience of a lifetime at Bagels on the Hill!
… moreSteph Vacca
We ordered two 3 foot Italian subs for a party. The owner Mike called to confirm the order and was totally lovely on the phone. The sandwiches were some of the best we’ve ever had. They were a complete hit with the family and were an amazing value for what we got. Fresh, tasty, and amazingly presented. I will definitely order from Bagels on the Hill again. It was so good I’d give it 10 stars if it allowed.
… moreMelissa McKenna
Love it here! Bagels has been my go to since I can remember. The shop is super clean, I’m always welcomed with a smile and all of their food is delicious. They have amazing bagels and make really great subs, too. I also love their chicken & tuna salad. You cant go wrong with anything you order here. Highly recommend this place!! Tell your friends!
… moreOak !!
I stop in 3-4 times a week and they have the best bagels around, there everything bagels are fantastic. The staff is super friendly and the bagels come out quick! If your in the area for an amazing bagel I highly recommend stopping here. 10/10
… more