Andrew Clark
What a phenomenal spot! Stopped in here with some friends on our way back to Jersey from a nearby hike. Wouldn’t expect good pizza in PA, but this place sets the bar high. Johnny & his staff are all great people who know how to cook! Would definitely recommend!! They homemake their mozzarella, be sure to indulge!
… moreKristin Stasak
We’ve been going to Johnnie’s for almost 20 years, our rehearsal dinner for our wedding was even there, they are absolutely phenomenal, we frequently go there for dine in and take out! Pasta dishes are highly recommended especially the Rigatoni à la Johnnie’s and penne ala Benny! Pizza is just like the NY pizza I remember from a kid and the sandwiches are amazing too!! I HIGHLY recommend them to everyone!
… moreJacklyn Nystrand
Have been coming here ever since I was little. Always welcomed here and always makes sure you always have a good experience. When we get delivery the boys are very nice and fast. The best in the area for sure!!!!!!!!
… moreJessica Coe
The family and I ate dinner the other night at Johnnie’s!!! I am a VERY picky eater and their food was AMAZING!! I had the Chicken Milano and it was to die for!! My husband had the Chicken Vlora and he scrapped his plate clean. They also have options for children and sandwiches if you want something smaller We will be back to try some other dishes!! Thank you Johnnies for bring so awesome!!!
… moreUnikah Graham
My brother and I moved to the area around a year ago, and for the first few months, we basically lived off Johnnie’s. The food is fantastic, from the pizza to the garlic knots, wings, pasta, and more. I went in for lunch before work two weeks ago, and the owner and I had a pleasant talk about work and future plans. At the end of the conversation, he removed $10 from my wings and gave me the garlic knots for free. I strongly suggest this eatery!
… moreDebra Scott
When it comes to pizza I’m a tough critic. We haven’t been able to find a good pizza in the mount bethel area since we’ve been up here. Until now that is. Johnnie’s definitely got my vote. Their pizza even tastes good cold in the morning like I like to eat it sometimes leftovers
… moreKristen Vanderhoof
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Absolutely amazing! This restaurant is a true gem. From the moment we walked in, the warm atmosphere and friendly service made us feel right at home. The food was outstanding—fresh, flavorful, and authentic. The pasta was cooked perfectly, the sauces were rich and delicious, and the desserts were the perfect finishing touch. You can tell everything is made with care and high-quality ingredients. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a memorable dining experience. Can’t wait to come back!
… moreGabby Sabia
Amazing, delicious, fresh food ALWAYS. This restaurant Never disappoints! And the gentleman that always brings food to our office is so sweet and caring. All around an amazing place to gather with friends or family and to sit and enjoy a nice homemade meal. If I could give 10 stars I totally would!
… moreLee Stanziale
Owner fantastic, food even better. Ordered the Stromboli you won’t be disappointed.
… moreLisa t
My husband and I have been in the Bangor area now for over a year and Johnnie’s has become our favorite place to eat. Friendly service for sit down, pick up or delivery Johnnie’s has you covered. Excellent food and a wonderful recipe for their cannolis.
Thank you for the amazing food and service!
… more