Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Mahogany Run Golf Course’s upscale restaurant serving market-driven American fare in a 1750s stable.
Address and Contact Information
Address: Mahogany Run Rd, Mandahl, St Thomas 00802, U.S. Virgin Islands
Phone: +1 340-725-6279
Website: http://www.oldstonefarmhouse.net/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fine Dining Restaurant | Old Stone Farmhouse | St. Thomas
The Old Stone Farmhouse offers the perfect blend of historic ambiance and cutting edge cuisine on the beautiful island of St. Thomas, USVI.
Dinner Menu – St. Thomas – Old Stone Farmhouse
St Thomas, VI 00802. DINE WITH US. Quick & easy reservations are now available … By accepting, you agree to our use of such cookies.Privacy Policy.
Menu | Old Stone Farmhouse | St. Thomas
Dinner Menu. HOURS. Mon – Sun. 5:30pm – 9:30pm. . (340) 725 6279. Mahogany Run. St Thomas, VI 00802. DINE WITH US. Quick & easy reservations are now …
Reviews
James Nichols
Go here. I’ve been all around and this was maybe the best meal I’ve had. Our server was friendly, funny, and helpful. The food was amazing. The chicken with the glaze was outstanding. So was the fresh fish. Not a single thing to improve except valet sign that left me confused. Great place. You should just go here.
… moreBrianna Ohman
My husband and I went here for our anniversary, everything was amazing! We had Dan as our server and bartender- he was 10/10. Honestly, everything was 10/10. We had the surf n turf, catch of the day (wahoo) and everything was perfect. We loved reading about the history of the buildings and the family winery. Everything was amazing. Would definitely recommend. Also, would make a great spot for a special occasion!
… moreDonna E
From start to finish, our experience was nothing short of exceptional. Aaron, our server, was professional, attentive, and ensured we had everything we needed throughout the meal.
The food? Absolutely out of this world! Every course – from appetizers to main dishes to desserts – was bursting with flavor and beautifully presented.
We were especially impressed when the chef personally came to our table to ask for feedback. It’s clear they care deeply about the quality of their food and guest satisfaction.
Highly recommend a visit – this place is a gem!
… moreThe food? Absolutely out of this world! Every course – from appetizers to main dishes to desserts – was bursting with flavor and beautifully presented.
We were especially impressed when the chef personally came to our table to ask for feedback. It’s clear they care deeply about the quality of their food and guest satisfaction.
Highly recommend a visit – this place is a gem!
IU Fan
We had a wonderful experience at Old Stone Farmhouse! The service was excellent — our party of six was well taken care of and the staff was attentive throughout the entire meal. We ordered the lobster, grilled and fried fish, and steak, and everything was absolutely delicious. Highly recommend for a fantastic dining experience!
… moreTucker Norman
The Farmhouse has a lot left to be desired. With its great bones of an old building something truly special could be done with the place unfortunately that was not the case during our dining experience.
We were greeted by a member of the staff that was to valet our car. This staff member was wearing a baseball hat skew, chains around the neck hanging outside of their clothes, and smelled STRONGLY of marijuana. Not a great start and not someone I would want to have valet my car. And to no surprise, when we returned our car smelled of weed.
Upon entering the establishment we thought the bones of the place were great but the decor was quite bad. The tables that were set up were awkwardly placed, they had folding plastic tables draped with pink table cloths and horrible chair covers. Further there were fairy lights hung up on some of the old iron work that really, in our opinion, cheapened the atmosphere. Once again, small details that missed the mark and ruined the feel of the restaurant.
We then were served our drinks and both of our orange slices with our cocktails were previously used for zesting and were missing a large part of the rind. This made of quite a laugh for us since we did not expect that for a $12 drink.
The food when it came out was decent. The lamb was cooked well and tasted very good, the ribeye although being cooked the way that was requested had about 3-4 oz that were strictly fat and not the typical ratio of meat to fat in the fat cap. Worth the $65? Not in my eyes.
At the end of the night we concluded that to pay for two people to both have drinks a main course and sparkling water, it should not have been close to $200 and was not worth the value.
A lot left to be desired with The Farm House. I would try a different place before coming back to this restaurant.
… moreWe were greeted by a member of the staff that was to valet our car. This staff member was wearing a baseball hat skew, chains around the neck hanging outside of their clothes, and smelled STRONGLY of marijuana. Not a great start and not someone I would want to have valet my car. And to no surprise, when we returned our car smelled of weed.
Upon entering the establishment we thought the bones of the place were great but the decor was quite bad. The tables that were set up were awkwardly placed, they had folding plastic tables draped with pink table cloths and horrible chair covers. Further there were fairy lights hung up on some of the old iron work that really, in our opinion, cheapened the atmosphere. Once again, small details that missed the mark and ruined the feel of the restaurant.
We then were served our drinks and both of our orange slices with our cocktails were previously used for zesting and were missing a large part of the rind. This made of quite a laugh for us since we did not expect that for a $12 drink.
The food when it came out was decent. The lamb was cooked well and tasted very good, the ribeye although being cooked the way that was requested had about 3-4 oz that were strictly fat and not the typical ratio of meat to fat in the fat cap. Worth the $65? Not in my eyes.
At the end of the night we concluded that to pay for two people to both have drinks a main course and sparkling water, it should not have been close to $200 and was not worth the value.
A lot left to be desired with The Farm House. I would try a different place before coming back to this restaurant.
Mirkelys
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Old Stone is a place with excellent service and food. Every dish is delicious and well-presented, and the staff is always friendly and attentive. It’s a true gem on the island, perfect for enjoying any occasion.
… moreOld Stone is a place with excellent service and food. Every dish is delicious and well-presented, and the staff is always friendly and attentive. It’s a true gem on the island, perfect for enjoying any occasion.
erin mercuri
If you’re on the fence because of some recent poor reviews I’d urge you to go anyway. We ate here last night and had a wonderful meal and excellent service. The atmosphere is soothing and elegant. Our service was well paced, so we could relax and really enjoy our food and surroundings. Not rushed and not slow. My fluke feature was fabulous, wonderfully balanced creative flavors. The wine selection is very nice with a wide range of price points. Desserts are made in house. Overall fabulous dining experience and we would absolutely go back again!
… moreN’lani Francis
Sin was our server (2/21/26) ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. Noah is also very amazing! The food was absolutely delicious. We had the lamb, the meatless lasagna, and lobster. This was our second time being here. It was an amazing experience both times!!
… moreH Marie
This is a nice upscale restaurant to eat at while in St. Thomas. Very cool history behind the place. The food was phenomenal. I have no complaints. It was the best dinner we had the entire time on the island. They’re often changing their menu.
… moreBrian
This isn’t a meal. This is a culinary experience. One of the best restaurants on St. Thomas. Every detail is well thought out and amazing. The appetizers, the cocktails, the main courses, as well as dessert were all over the top. The location is also great and feels both historic and laid back. If you come to St Thomas, you owe it to yourself to try this place.
… more