Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2709 E Newberry St, Appleton, WI 54915
Phone: (920) 734-4472
Website: https://www.facebook.com/The-Wishing-Well-119644321380908/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Wishing Well | Appleton WI – Facebook
No photo description available. Debra Gosse and 5 others · . 6 · · The Wishing Well. Jul 1, 2025 . . Open July 4th Serving until 8pm Closed …
Wishing Well, 2709 E Newberry St, Appleton, WI 54915, US
Despite the temporary issue, Wishing Well is known for providing a welcoming atmosphere and a variety of services to enhance the community’s well-being.
Wishing Well: A Hidden Gem for Great Food and Friendly …
Wishing Well, located at 2709 E Newberry St in Appleton, WI, is a hidden gem that draws diners in with its welcoming atmosphere and delicious offerings.
Reviews
Lost Voice Music
Love it here! This place was recommended to us by a few people so one Friday we gave it a try. Now we are here every Tuesday Friday and Sunday. Tuesday is taco night aaaaaaaaand hott damn these tacos are hella HUGE, fun to eat, and very filling. Also, the staff is absolutely amazing. Even the costumes are cool. I meet a new person every time we go there. 10 out of 10
Stop in and give them a try
… moreStop in and give them a try
irv mackmiller
Nice local pub and fare. Short staffed today, so the bartender was also taking orders for food and drinks in the dining area. Sometime the fry cook ran food out when possible. Had to goto the bar for refills otherwise our party of 6 wouldn’t get any in a timely manner. Everyone approved of their orders. Being Friday, some of us ordered fish of some kind and others ordered burgers. All good for bar food. Will be there again.
… moreFLAMINGO MOM
I been here a couple of times now, and it’s a really fun place to hang out! I have not tried the food yet, but I will soon. Bartenders are very friendly. They even have a back room if you need more space. This bar is not very big however the crowd is very good.
… moreWANDA TIMM
Highly recommend. Great fish fry!! Batter was light and crispy. Broiled haddock flaked perfectly. Now I want to try their Sunday chicken.
… moreGlenn Sokol
This was a great place! Kara was truly “the friendliest bartender.” The food was really good. The atmosphere was nice and the karaoke was great!
… moreAlan Cinqmars
First time here. Very happy with the service and the food was great.
… moreSandy Hawley
Has to have been the worst haddock/perch/shrimp lunch I’ve had. No flavor at all. I can’t believe it was melted butter in the cup either. Might have been yellow but again didn’t taste like any butter I’ve had. Potato salad and coleslaw were very good. We’re great to my grandson while waiting for food.cheeseburger was ok.
… moreAshley Morgan
Great Fish Fry, great drinks, great people in a friendly bar atmosphere!
… moreBailey Lawless
Cold beer, great fish and shrimp, great price! Go early on Fridays to avoid a wait
… moreLu Reschke
Service was good even though they were busy. Seafood plate is a very generous portion. Good Friday fish fry.
… more