Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Nicolo’s Family Restaurant, [12227 – 12299] Route 16, Chaffee, NY …
Photos … Nicolo’s Family Restaurant is a cozy eatery nestled in the heart of Sardinia, Town of, NY, offering a menu of traditional Italian dishes and family- …
Nicolo’s Restaurant Menu (Updated 2026) – Wheree
Nicolo’s Restaurant is a beloved dining destination in Chaffee, NY, known for its inviting atmosphere and exceptional menu offerings.
Nicolo’s Family Restaurant in Chaffee, NY – Reviews … – Yahoo
Read customer reviews and get hours of operation and contact information for Nicolo’s Family Restaurant, a(n) Pizza business in Chaffee, NY.
Reviews
Griffin A
Absolutely amazing food, the best Italian in the area. Prices are great and the service was lovely. They have a good selection of beer and wine. The menu is huge and they have a ton of options if you’re not sure what to eat.
… moreJerry Dalrymple
I have gotten takeout lately but even their dine in was great last time I was there. Pizza is just really really good. Leftovers are very good.
… moreJennifer Smyth
The food was amazing, and so was the service. We had 2 waitresses (one was in training), and our service was great. The owner came out and said, “Hi,” to the people he knew. It was a very friendly atmosphere. Will definitely go again!
… moreJake Miess
Three cheese steak pizza with banana peppers and their taco pizza is fantastic and their chicken subs are good their chicken wings are amazing
… moreMatt D
Great quality food,huge portions, and pre-COVID prices. Staff was very friendly too.
… moreConnie Andress
I have to say the pizza is the best in WNY.My husband and I grew up in this area and everytime we come out here from West Seneca,we grab. a pizza..Absolutely the best.
… moreJoshua Riordan
NY pizza and wings. The hot aren’t too hot and when you order extra crispy you don’t have to complain or send them back.
… moreApril Ritter
My favorite pizza is from here. For me, it’s chef’s kiss. The chicken lips are really good also. Large servings, you get leftovers for later.
… moreFood Review
This was my first time here and No wonder why the place is packed could not even find a place to park so I can pick up a to go order. Food tastes like you just got done cooking it at home so good and fulfilling. I got spaghetti and meatballs and let me tell you the meatballs where the star of the show I also go a fish fry and it was so delicious
… morepeter s
Absolutely “HORRID”!!! Order Italian broiled fish and get this disgusting slab of god knows what.Looks like lemon pepper but the rude 28 year veteran waitress says it’s Italian! Lmao. I’d give no stars if I could.
… more