Chain outlet serving pizza, plus pasta, calzones, chicken wings & submarine sandwiches.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 11655 Anthony Hwy, Waynesboro, PA 17268
Phone: (717) 749-7007
Website: https://www.toasttab.com/toledo-pizza-800-s-potomac-st/v3
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Toledo’s Pizza – Order Online
Pickup from 11655 Anthony Highway, Waynesboro, PA. ASAP•Pickup in 20 – 25 min … Italian. Ham, salami, capicola, and provolone cheese. $9.99 · Ham & Cheese.
Toledos Pizza and Italian Restaurant | Waynesboro PA – Facebook
toasttab.com/toledo-pizza-800-s-potomac-st/v3. Services. . Specialties. Italian food · Food delivery. Contact info. . (717) 749-7007. Photos.
Toledo’s Pizza, 11655 Anthony Hwy, Waynesboro, PA 17268, US
Toledo’s Pizza in Waynesboro PA is a cozy eatery known for its delicious handcrafted pizzas and welcoming atmosphere. With a variety of toppings and crust …
Reviews
Don Schilling
We usually come here for pizza or steak sandwiches. Tonight we decided to venture into their world of pasta and meatballs.
I ordered ziti and meatballs and my wife had baked cheese ravioli.
I must admit that we are QUITE the meatball snobs. My wife and I are well known for our homemade meatballs and pasta sauce.
Well, we were pleasantly surprised by the flavor, texture, and presentation of our dinners. The sauce was delicious and the meatballs get 9 stars. They would be 10, but mine are a 10, so… My wife gave her ravioli a 9 for the same reason. Great homemade bread.
The prices are more than reasonable. The servers make eating here an even greater pleasure. Zorah was our server tonight… Excellent !
… moreI ordered ziti and meatballs and my wife had baked cheese ravioli.
I must admit that we are QUITE the meatball snobs. My wife and I are well known for our homemade meatballs and pasta sauce.
Well, we were pleasantly surprised by the flavor, texture, and presentation of our dinners. The sauce was delicious and the meatballs get 9 stars. They would be 10, but mine are a 10, so… My wife gave her ravioli a 9 for the same reason. Great homemade bread.
The prices are more than reasonable. The servers make eating here an even greater pleasure. Zorah was our server tonight… Excellent !
Linda Burger
Toledo’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant provided food for a family dinner following a funeral, and we can’t thank them enough for how accommodating and generous they were during a very difficult time. They were flexible with our order and made the whole process easy and stress-free, which meant so much to our family.
We ordered pizza and chicken marsala, and everything was delicious. The food was comforting, well prepared, and perfect for serving a large group. The chicken marsala in particular was a hit.
It was clear that care went into both the food and the service, and we truly appreciated being able to rely on Toledo’s when it mattered most. Highly recommend, and we look forward to ordering again.
… moreWe ordered pizza and chicken marsala, and everything was delicious. The food was comforting, well prepared, and perfect for serving a large group. The chicken marsala in particular was a hit.
It was clear that care went into both the food and the service, and we truly appreciated being able to rely on Toledo’s when it mattered most. Highly recommend, and we look forward to ordering again.
Shawnta
Pizza and a movie is Friday routine in this house. We ordered LG pepperoni pizza and big boy add mushroom green pepper and olives. The sub came without the original topping it was just burger bread and my add veggies. I call she says it had what you asked for I said no I asked for the sub and just added extra. She says we can send another but you need to send back the old (why to resell lol). I told her honey read your own damn menu it comes with lettuce tomato onion and mayo stupid and hung up. Smh
… moreMagic Mike Metzger
Visited here to try out the new location. The food is still as good as it always was at their old location and at fairly good prices. If you’re going to eat at the restaurant, I recommend drinking water as anything else costs $2.65 a glass with one free refill, and that definitely tends to drive the bill up. I’m not too sure about their new location. The building used to be owned by a catering company, and it still kinda to me gives me that same vibe. It’s almost like you are eating in less of a restaurant and more of some kind of venue where you would be attending some kind of formal event. Because of this style of dining room, there is also no feeling of separation between you and the other diners at the restaurant, which to me is kinda awkward. I understand the needs of the restaurant owners wanting to get their new location open quickly, but its a fine line between wanting to make money quickly and having a restaurant that wont make money in the long run because the atmosphere turns people away. Its almost as if not enough planing and / or forethought went into the opening of their new location to make it restaurant ready. So that being said, I still recommend Toledo’s, but as far as I’m concerned, I’ll probably stick with carry out.
… moreLevi Mixell
My go to spot for pizza and cheesesteaks you can’t beat their prices. The food is always hot and quality every time. The staff is friendly
… moreLuke Hade
WORMS IN PASTA. Very unfortunate experience, have eaten here multiple times in the past and gotten pizza and was always satisfied. Tonight I was served ziti alfredo with a side of maggot/worm. Staff member proceeded to lie to me and tell me it was part of one of the spices used in making the sauce. Ill let you make your own determination from attached phots in my review but it certainly looks like a worm to me. I highly question the cleanliness of the kitchen at this establishment after this experience. Staff did not offer to comp other meals or provide any further support than bringing me another plate of possibly wormy pasta. Highly disappointed and would recommend a health and safety inspector to go check things out here.
… moreEmily Boyd
They have some of the best food ever. You are not getting fries from anywhere that better than they have here. The pizzas are very big just have a bit too much grease.
… moreJoshua
One of the best local spots around! Not only is the food always fresh and delicious, but the customer service is truly next level. They will bend over backwards to help you out and make sure you leave satisfied.
The girls at the front counter are incredibly friendly, helpful, and welcoming — they make you feel like family the second you walk through the door. Whether it’s a big order or a last-minute change, they handle everything with professionalism and a smile.
Highly recommend supporting this amazing local business. It’s places like Toledo’s that remind you what great service and great food are all about!
… moreThe girls at the front counter are incredibly friendly, helpful, and welcoming — they make you feel like family the second you walk through the door. Whether it’s a big order or a last-minute change, they handle everything with professionalism and a smile.
Highly recommend supporting this amazing local business. It’s places like Toledo’s that remind you what great service and great food are all about!
Michael Smith
Very good local pizza joint in town. Their pizza is good for a classic NY style slice. I wish they would do something to separate themselves, because it’s very similar to the other pizza places in town. Their sandwiches and main dishes are all good quality. I recommend this place to try out.
… moreJames H
I’m a Philly guy and I finally found a very good cheesesteak on an excellent roll in Franklin County.
I ordered a meatball parm sandwich to go, which was also good.
… moreI ordered a meatball parm sandwich to go, which was also good.