Dawn Michael
Cute little old school place in a strip mall. I bet their regular pizza is great, I have to eat gluten free so that’s what I got. I called the order in on the phone then decided to eat there, the person at the register was very polite both on the phone and in person. Gluten free crust is always a bit uninteresting, but the sauce was very nice. They served it in a metal pan which indicated to me they took precautions to keep it off the floor of the oven where the gluten would be. Would order from here again.
… moreNick Fanelli
I had gotten pizza here before and been happy, but we recently ordered a full tray of chicken parm catering for a party and it was AMAZING and got a lot of compliments. Could not have been an easier or better experience and would highly recommend.
… moreMatt N
A friend took me out for pizza, the pizza was great! BUT it’s the meatballs that will be bringing me back! What a pleasant surprise dinner was tonight, thank you! I’m looking forward to a meatball sub and more meatball pizzas!
… moreLaurie Butler
We can not praise the Sal’s crew enough. We are always welcomed at the door, treated with respect, promptly and accurately served, and always sent off with good wishes.
… moreShelby Falcone
Such a cute spot with great service and even better pizza!
… moreDouglas Wilson
This is a no frills pizza place – ambiance is a bit lacking if you’re looking for that. BUT, if you want incredibly tasty pizza and a friendly staff: run, don’t walk to grab a pie here. Absolutely delicious!
… moreMaureen Lavy
Delicious pizza and wings!!!! Amazing customer service! Will definitely go back!
… moreJenna Sybert
This is an Ithaca gem! I’m from Buffalo and this is the closest thing we can get to Buffalo Pizza and wings. The crust is crispy, but has a slight chewiness. It has a great oven baked flavor and tastes so fresh (doesn’t taste artificial). The sauce is amazing, not overly sweet or acidic. The cheese actually tastes like mozzarella and not fake cheese! The toppings are plentiful! The staff are top notch. They make everything to order, with whatever special cooking instructions or sauces you prefer, and make everything taste fabulous. The staff are very friendly, courteous, and efficient. They have a strong emphasis on customer satisfaction. I love their family atmosphere and vibe. It’s the only place we would ever recommend for pizza in Ithaca and surrounding areas.
… moreM S
Amazing food and service! They have the best pizza and Lasagna I have ever had!
… moreMelody M
Amazing food and service. I didn’t think I was that hungry but I demolished that lasagna all the same!
… more