Raven Thorne
First time ordering and I am very happy.
Very cheesy (me gusta cheese ) and delicious. Great proportions. The “small cheese stick” is a meal in itself. Fast delivery.
Will be ordering again wayyyyy better than mediocre huge chain options I’m used to.
… moreBrooke Yount
First time trying this place, and we absolutely loved it. The shift leader, Dallas, answered all our questions with a friendly attitude, met our dine-needs with a smile, and visited briefly with 100% hospitality. The food was out quick. Although the inside is not equipped for more than about 4-5 dine-in customers, Dallas was accommodating to give us plates, cups of ice for our drinks, and silverware. Their take-out business is very busy also. Cheezy, scrumptious pizzas, soft warm cookies, cold drinks, and unique breadsticks. Highly recommended and will definitely eat there again when we are in town.
… moreChris Breseman
First time trying this pizza place. Absolutely a winner for pizza and the calzone I ordered.. Be aware theres only 4 or 5 seats at a counter for dine in. Its more of a order to go or delivery via doordash place for pizza. The food was very reasonably priced and I was super impressed with the very friendly service. An added bonus is it is locally owned and operated instead of being a chain.
… moreBecki Riehle
Pizza flavor was delicious but could have been cooked longer. Wings were huge and flavorful. Cinnamon bites were yummy. After tip we spent just under $100 and our 2 liter was forgotten.
… moreMary Pennington
The pizza and cheese sticks were so greasy. As could have been cooked more. Not pleased at all. Definitely will worth it.
… moreIsabella E.
pizza was alright. there was no mold on the bottom so that’s good. hopefully i don’t get food poisoning like some of these other reviewers. papa john’s is better. i had to park around the back and it was dark, didn’t appreciate that. guys at the store were nice though.
… moreZach Storer
The overall rating just really doesn’t add up. Spent $40 for a large pizza, breadsticks, and a Caesar salad. The only good thing was the breadsticks. Honestly couldn’t pick this pizza out of a lineup with Papa John’s, Pizza Magoa, etc – just mediocre. The Caesar salad pictured on the menu did not match at all what was provided; felt like the opened a pizza shaker of Parmesan and dumped it on the salad (was supposed to be shaved pieces). It’s probably decent for a college town joint, but the price doesn’t match the product.
… moreAmber Gray-Kurz
10.29.2025 Update: I tried this location again recently and the service was much better. However, the pizza was lukewarm again. I think they still have an issue with making the pizza right when it comes through instead of closer to the quoted time. I did find out that they have four ghost kitchens at this restaurant. (Baked Potato Company, Best Clucking Wings, College Cookie, and Bomb Burger) I have not tried any of these yet.
Update: I wanted to provide an update. I went back and my experience was the exact opposite of my initial visit. When I got there I had to wait up front for about three minutes before someone came to the counter. When someone did come up front he looked a bit annoyed. I had ordered ahead and arrived at the quoted time. I think they must have made the pizza right when I ordered instead of planning out the arrival time because it was barely warm. I got a small chicken bacon ranch pizza….and they forgot the ranch. The chicken was also extremely dry. Not sure if I will be going back.
Original Post: I tried Stoner’s for the first time today and I will be back. I ordered a small “Nice to Meat You” hand tossed pizza. The meat was fresh and the sauce was flavorful. The pizza also came with a side of garlic sauce. I ordered ahead and I got there right when my order was due for pickup. It was hot so I know they timed the cooking according to the pickup time. The customer service representative was friendly and professional.
… moreJonathan Richardson
Oh my gosh some of the best pizza if not the best pizza I’ve ever had in Lexington. Check out my reviews I have like 2 million views on my Google posts and this is the best pizza I’ve ever reviewed in Lexington Kentucky. The wings are also delicious. Please everyone try this place out and tell them I told you about it . We need more pizza like this in the World!
… moreSydney Lowe
Horrible. My order always gets messed up today was the most recent experience and it annoyed me enough to post a review. I ordered a big inflation buster with 2 larger pizzas, order of bread sticks, 4 cookies, and a half gallon of sweet tea. Well I can tell you that they will always forget your tea, this is the 5TH TIME IN A ROW that it has happened, they also have forgotten the bread sticks 3 of those times, and 5 of 5 of those times the pizzas were wrong as well and this most recent time I ordered a pepperoni with bacon and a extra cheese with pepperoni but instead I got a pepperoni pizza and a bacon pizza. The photos attached will include the most recent order and the proof I wish I had taken the last 5 times I wasted my money. I wish I could say they make up for it, but THE STORE REFUSES TO ANSWER THE PHONE. All of the times I have ordered I try to call and am always sent to voice mail. Save your time and money and go somewhere you will get what you pay for!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! THEY ALSO BARELY CUT THE PIZZAS!!!!!! I DEMAND A FULL REFUND FOR THE AMOUNT OF TIMES I HAVE HAD TO WASTE MY MONEY ON THIS BUSINESS!! THE BIG INFLATION BUSTER WAS A BUST!!!!!
… more