Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3821 N Sterling Ave, Peoria, IL 61615
Phone: (309) 682-3722
Website: http://tavern41pizza.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home – Herolds Pizza Oven Peoria Illinois
Herold’s Pizza Oven. In 1967, Chuck Herold launched Pizza Inn, a Sterling Plaza staple in Peoria, Illinois. After its sale in 2013, the Herold family …
Herold’s Pizza Oven | Peoria IL – Facebook
ALL FOR ❤ Buffet: Brunch: Sun 10a-2p, Lunch: Tues-Fri 11a-1p Dinner: Tue-Th 5-7p & Fri/Sat 5-8p 3821 N. Sterling Ave, Peoria, Illinois ☎ Carry-out: 309-682- …
Menu – Herolds Pizza Oven Peoria Illinois
Starters, fried-chicken, WINGS, SALADS, sandwich (1), SANDWICHES, PASTA, STROMBOLI, PIZZA, HPO since 1967. Visit us 3821 N. Sterling Avenue Peoria, IL 61615
Reviews
Nia S.
I’ve been here few times I’m usually at the bar. The pizza is pretty decent. The buffet is okay not a lot of vegetarian options for pizza. My most recent trip (1/6/2026) was not so good. Came in around 6:20 our server seemed pretty nice. I asked if they could make a pizza. The young lady behind the counter making the pizza boxes was a bit rude. She asked what kind of pizza I told her a veggie pizza then she said it’s not up to her. Like why ask if you weren’t going to make it. I took a look at the buffet and it most certainly was not worth the $$. They had just put the last pizza it looked dry and wasn’t even enough for 2 people. I understand it was late but there was enough time to make a pizza at least accommodate a person who doesn’t eat meat pizza. I’ll just stick to the bar.
… moreChef King Curry
I really enjoyed the food here. I had the Fajita Pizza, Potato Pizza and Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich. All of it cost 40 Dollars. First the Fajita Pizza it was good a little bland the dough was nice and soft. 7/10. 2nd the Potato Pizza was very delicious, just needs more bacon. 8/10. Last the CBR sandwich was amazing, flavorful, nice, and soft, and It was only 8 dollars. 9/10. Food Game 8.5/10. Portion Game 8/10. Price Game 8.5/10. Overall Herolds Pizza Oven 8.5/10. I will come back again forsure. Shout out to the cook!!
… moreSandra McBride
Garlic Chicken Parmesan and The Meats Pizza were delicious. Great service and excellent food. Check this place out!
… moreShan B
This is our first time eating here and the ONLY reason it received a 4/5 is because of the taco pizza sauce. I think I had higher standards because of happy joes or even Casey’s with their sauce and how it tastes. The sauce here tasted like sloppy Joe and we just weren’t fans at all. If we would have known we would have ordered a different pizza and the review would’ve been 5/5. BUT we lovedddd the crust. We also got the breadsticks and ravioli and they were delicious! The ravioli were a little overcooked and burnt on the bottom but the flavor was amazing. Our waitress was new and only working 3 days but she did AMAZING. She was soooo kind! We will definitely be back and can’t wait to try the buffet. $12.99 with drink included is a steal. The workers greeted us as we entered the building and even as we left to ensure we had a good night. I will update once we eat there again with buffet!
… moreEric Lorenz
We had a small group and got a few different choices. Loved the flavors. We tried both the thicker crust and the thin crust. Both good. Saw a cauliflower crust option too. I can not say enough good things about the place. I also did the salad bar and it was fresh.
… moreK Schmidt
I was so excited to win a large pizza and breadsticks from one of their FB contests! We ordered the Tavern Style Parmesan Garlic Pizza and it was delicious! The breadsticks and beer cheese were fantastic as always, and we also ordered a Silician Stromboli and a Chocolate Chip Pizzzza, which were so good!
… moreTodd Batitis
Wife loves pizza buffets but in Seattle they were non-existent for the most part. This works great for her. Daily lunch buffet and a couple nights of dinner buffet.
I am ketovore so very low carbs and the wings were great and the last trip I had them make a crustless pizza. Not a problem, just pick the type you want and everything but a crust gets cooked in one if the aluminum take-out tins Luke you might get pasta delivered in.
Price was reasonable and plenty of space for plenty of people.
Very friendly staff and they didn’t even blink when I knocked the parmesan shaker off and shattered it. Swept it up and handed me another one.
… moreI am ketovore so very low carbs and the wings were great and the last trip I had them make a crustless pizza. Not a problem, just pick the type you want and everything but a crust gets cooked in one if the aluminum take-out tins Luke you might get pasta delivered in.
Price was reasonable and plenty of space for plenty of people.
Very friendly staff and they didn’t even blink when I knocked the parmesan shaker off and shattered it. Swept it up and handed me another one.
Heather McCann
Thanks to Riley & Carrie today @ Herold’s Pizza Oven! They were phenomenal today. We had lunch for my office; Chris Herold & his Staff did their thang!!!! Thanks Chris! Signed, Totally Happy & Full @ Total Income Tax
… moreJon Kucharz
Buffet was good and the price was right. Left full and satisfied. Good selection of pizza to choose from. The mini corn dogs surprised me on how good they were. Good salad bar too! I’ll be back.
… moreShannon Johnson
I will go back to try out the buffet. Friendly prompt service. Our group had 3 different pizzas. And 4 in our group had salad from the salad bar. All salad eaters said was exceptional. Pizza was fresh and hot and beer was good and cold. Very reasonable prices.
… more