Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Lively, casual pizzeria & bar serving New York-style pizza & other Italian fare.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 45 Pembroke Dr #105, Hilton Head Island, SC 29926
Phone: (843) 689-2229
Website: https://www.newyorkcitypizza.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
New York City Pizza Bar & Restaurant | South Carolina
New York City Pizza | NY style pizza, pasta, entrees, subs, salads & appetizers. Great food, made from simple ingredients. Five locations in South Carolina.
New York City Pizza (Heritage Plaza) – Hilton Head Island
New York City Pizza has been a Hilton Head Island Tradition since 1996. We are located on the North and South End of Hilton Head Island, …
New York City Pizza (@ilovenycp) · Hilton Head Island, SC – Instagram
South Carolina’s best New York-style pizza! Bluffton Charleston Hilton Head Island Open Monday – Sunday #ilovenycp to be featured. Order ↓.
Reviews
Jess Cloninger
Came on a Saturday night. It wasn’t busy. Pizza was SOO GOOD! Crust was good, portion size was great. I also got a house salad and it was big and filling. Their house vinaigrette looks like it’s made in house and was really good.
Service was great, bathrooms and dining area was clean.
We don’t drink but the bar looked really nice as well. They do have outdoor seating and corn hole boards.
We visited from Charlotte NC region and I haven’t found pizza close to us as good as this place!
Overall I was very impressed. It was great. Would definitely come again if we are in the area again.
… moreService was great, bathrooms and dining area was clean.
We don’t drink but the bar looked really nice as well. They do have outdoor seating and corn hole boards.
We visited from Charlotte NC region and I haven’t found pizza close to us as good as this place!
Overall I was very impressed. It was great. Would definitely come again if we are in the area again.
Gab Freeman
My family stopped here as an impromptu birthday lunch and we are so glad we did. Mandy did an amazing job making us feel welcomed as she was doing several duties on her own. We jokingly asked her who didn’t show up for work, but she handled everything with grace. My father had the spaghetti and was pleasantly surprised by how good it was. My mother had the wings, which she devoured. I had two slices and they did not disappoint at all. We will definitely come back if we are ever in the area again.
… moreConner Castagno
My family and I came here on June 7th. We had a really rough experience at this place and I would not recommend to anyone. I will say that I don’t mind a restaurant if they don’t hurry and get your food out ASAP as it can give you the chance to chat. But it was honestly unacceptable how slow this experience was. It took them 50 minutes just to get our breadsticks to us, and then another 30 minutes to get us our 3 pizzas. The waitress never came back one time after getting our order until she brought the breadsticks and then the pizza. She should have informed us of whatever delay was happening. We had to go up to other employees on two different occasions to remind them that we were still there and still waiting! They were not helpful or apologetic and I can’t tell if it was bad training or that they were too busy with online orders or something. From looking at some of the other reviews though, it’s a very common occurrence! I give 2 stars though because although the toppings were poorly loaded in the middle of the pizza and there was too much crust, it did taste good! The employees need better training. It is one thing to have a busy night, but it is another thing when the employees and wait staff do not keep us apprised of what is going on. A little communication on their part goes a long way in customer service.
… moreAnnette White
Not sure about the recent reviews, but don’t listen to them! Dominick provided wonderful service and great conversation while we dined in. We had the deep dish and the cheese was awesome! Great stringy-ness to dough ratio. Our daughter is picky about pizza cheese and loved it. The deep dish had a great crust, crispy bottom and fluffy top so we had the best of both worlds. Would definitely come again and order take out if we were local. The prices match a local joint and not a huge chain. Don’t listen to the Karens and enjoy a great little place while you are vacationing. Bonus…right next to a Publix and ABC ☺️
… moreTerran Reid
Definitely a solid pizza choice! Most of the bad reviews seem to come from the service people received when dining in, but as far as taste, this pizza holds its own. When I’m in town, NYC Pizza is a quick and tasty spot to pick up dinner. In fact, I look forward to it every time.
… moreNick Banks
Absolutely bs. I ordered a delivery order.. they sub out to Uber ok. The Uber driver texts me in spanish i cant understand so i try calling him won’t answer his phone. All this because he can’t find YOUR address to pick up my pizza..
… moreChristi Hovater
We just ordered from this restaurant and ordered a large cheese pizza and breadsticks. We received a very cold pizza with mushrooms, sausage and onions instead of our cheese pizza (which my kids will not eat). Our breadsticks were also cold and covered in sauce which had spilled out all over the bag. I tried calling the store and nobody answered.
Edit: I had spoken to them the following day and had been told they’d mail me a gift card due to the mistake. I was going to update this once recieved, but still haven’t gotten over a month later. Will update if it ever comes lol
Edit 2: The restaurant reached out and apologized last week and did send me a gift certificate for the full amount I paid!
… moreEdit: I had spoken to them the following day and had been told they’d mail me a gift card due to the mistake. I was going to update this once recieved, but still haven’t gotten over a month later. Will update if it ever comes lol
Edit 2: The restaurant reached out and apologized last week and did send me a gift certificate for the full amount I paid!
Rob Madrid
This is a good stop for reliably good New York style pizza. When we have gone in May, sometimes the inside bar where you pick up the food can be a little deserted and we’ve had to wait for a minute or two, but they are always nice. I think the calzone is a B+/A-, which is great – most are B or less. The pizza options were also good – we had a Margarita pizza, which was really well done.
… moreSasha Coleman
We went based on reviews and a love of NY style pizza. The restaurant was empty and there were half empty beer bottles in the windowsill. Our waiter was young and inexperienced. He didn’t know of a bar menu and then returned to say they were out of wine. No red wine. The first two pizzas arrived and were good. Greasy and undercooked, but good enough. Our third pizza came out 30 minutes later and was not good at all. We left it behind. Sadly, this location disappointed and I hope others have a better experience.
… moreGina Marlowe
This is New York Pizza. It’s flat Pizza that you fold over and eat. That’s what New York Pizza is. That’s the way Us New Yorkers like it. We were very happy with it. Our waitress was wonderful.
… more