Relaxed, late-night haunt with TVs & a Civil War theme preparing specialty burgers & other pub grub.
Bryan Caswell
The Blue & Gray continues to be my absolute favorite place to eat in Gettysburg. They opened while I was there for college, and their quality hasn’t dropped a bit in over a decade. Every return visit to town requires at least one meal there, with no exceptions. The staff is unfailingly friendly and helpful. The dining room can get crowded (though there is now some outdoor patio space since the pandemic), and the place is super busy on Friday and Saturday evenings until late; hour long waits or more are common. This most recent visit was for an early lunch around 11:30 on a Saturday, though, and we had our pick of tables.
The many different burgers are all named after officers from both sides that fought in the battle, and most have unique and elaborate toppings that match the spirit of that officer. The Longstreet is a particular favorite, almost a calling card of theirs.
Ordered a Hays burger w/ fries and a meatball sub w/ sweet potato fries. Both were excellent, as we knew they would be.
… moreAmanda – Lambies on the Go
This place never disappoints! From the juicy, meaty wings that are perfectly coated with the most delectable sauces, to the HUGE burgers with the crazy delicious topping options. No matter what you choose you’ll be left full and happy! Make sure to see what weekday specials they have because they are quite the deal. We came on a Monday and got to enjoy their shrimp special! The vibes here are welcoming and fun with the bustling bar crowd. The service is always quick and attentive and seems to always be one step ahead from drink refill to extra napkins, they have you covered!
BONUS: Always make sure to order a side of Garlic parm wing sauce as a dip for your fries or whatever you please! It’s only $1 to add and its garlicky cheesy goodness will have you questioning why you haven’t done it sooner!
… moreMichelle Clark
Visited from California. This was the cutiest place ever. My daughter and I enjoyed a pizza we shared. She had 2 drinks from the bar that were also very delicious
Bring you patch if you’re a first responder
… moreJodie Poirier
We were there twice today, first for an appetizer lunch (no pictures) and then for supper. The food is fantastic! Our appetizer lunch consisted of grilled cheese, chicken fingers and cheese sticks. The cheese sticks were definitely the favourite! The chicken fingers have an great breading. For supper we had burgers and wraps. Again, the food was all excellent. Service isn’t amazing. We needed to ask for refills both times. The food is enough to get us back there though!
… morejess nemeth
We stopped by after a day of walking around the battlegrounds and boy was this food exactly what we needed! Kayla was amazing and recommended drinks and wing flavors for us to try. Service was quick and food was amazing!! The burger flavors were interesting, and worked in an unexpected way.
… moreBridgette Turner
First time visitors in from Ohio. We had a party of 7 and were able to get a seat together outside. The weather was very nice out so that worked perfectly. Our server was very nice and all of our food was made accurately and delicious. My mom is still going on about her brisket burger.
… morejeff allen
Food was great. Steamed shrimp special 1 lb for $12.49. Service and patrons were very friendly.
… moreAndrew Cox
Some of the more unusual and diverse hamburger styles you find. The General Hayes the I ordered was grilled right, juicy, and full of flavor unlike the awful smash burgers every one is doing. Sweet potato fries were nice and crisp, no complaints on anything. I would add a few more caramelized onions though.
… moreGunny L
Can’t say enough good things about this business. The wait staff were amazing. The food was exceptional. The grilled cheese bites were to die for, so much so that my wife wouldn’t mind the hour and a half ride up just to have lunch on the weekend. My burger was cooked perfectly and required nothing else, the flavor profile was so well thought out. I asked and they offer outdoor seating in the summer so motorcycle rides on the horizon.
… moreJ.R. Ricco
All right, I knew it was a tourist trap going in but having lunch with a friend in December, it was centrally located. Paid street parking, easy access, attractive venue. The hamburgers, with a Southern or Northern flair, (General George Meade, General Andrew Jackson) were a little on the dry side and that’s okay but it was not necessary for the server to check in every 10 minutes. The restaurant was not busy, and yet we felt hustled to eat and leave.
… more