Bella Pizzeria - Noblesville - Noblesville, IN 46060

The price is right for their delicious pizza. We had the meat lovers stuffed which is literally STUFFED FULL with a perfectly seasoned top crust that tasted like a yummy breadstick. I suggest getting a dipping sauce for the last few bites of crust. You will want to eat those last few bites, it’s amazing. We also got a side of pasta for a little one. The portions were huge and the price was small! There are different toppings for the pasta, not just regular spaghetti sauce to fit different taste buds. Atmosphere is relaxed with adequate seating for a smaller shop. Service is quick and staff is helpful with new patrons trying decide from the many options. I would recommend and will return when we shop the plaza again.

… more

Z W

I loved their Bella, Deluxe, Hawaiian, and Meat Lover’s. Cheese was just okay. I didn’t like the Buffalo Chicken, it was a bit too sour and salty. Crust seems a bit thicker than other New York thin style pizzas that I have had. The pizza did feel and taste like other New York style pizzas I have had. The sauce for the bread sticks and cheesy weezy was a bit bland but good. Works return.

… more

Richard Canada

I give 2 stars because the pizza is good. However, I ordered two kids pastas with marinara and got home to two bowls of noodles. I called them and they just said come back and we will put the sauce on. 30 minute round trip didn’t seem worth it to me. The inadequacy of this state is laughable.

… more

Amy H-R

This may be the best bbq chicken pizza I’ve ever had. It was the perfect amount of tasty sauce and toppings. The crust was nice and crisp and it arrived piping hot! The meatballs on the spaghetti were so tender and delicious. Loved the garlic knots, they were hot and fresh. Even the side salad was delicious with the homemade ranch dressing.

The prices were very reasonable, especially for the portions!

And did I mention the HUGE, fresh-from-the-oven chocolate chip cookie??

I will definitely be ordering again!

… more

Phillip Hiner

Bella’s pizza is pretty darn good. When they have it. See, the problem is that they see the closing time as the time when the employees leave the store, rather than the time to lock the doors and start cleaning up. Meaning that they start shutting down over half an hour early. I usually don’t get the chance to get over there until a bit later. Three times in a row now they simply had very little to no pizza options because they’d have to stock those options before they close, but they’d already cleaned up and were shutting down. The occasion that made me feel I needed to review I showed up at 7:45 and was told they had no pizza left and were closed. Fifteen minutes before their posted closing time.

I guess it really comes down to: do you want to go to a restaurant that may not be open during it’s posted hours because the employees don’t want to stay past close like every other restaurant in existence? Even if they are open, it is very clear what the priorities are and it isn’t you, the customer.

… more

Chris Deering

Moved to Noblesville from Philly in 2020. When I saw Bella Pizza I was thinking about my home town Bella Pizza and that was hard to beat, Especially when most Pizza places around here are chain stores. I was pleasantly surprised and very very pleased to get an authentic REAL DEAL PIZZA . Just like the taste I remember in Philly. Thank God I said. NOW I JUST GOTTA FIND A REAL CHEESE STEAK near me. Thank you Bella Pizza

… more

Christopher Conway

It’s not the best slice in town but it’s okay. Salad with ranch was good, breadsticks and cheese dip is 5 stars. The pizza needs a more crispy bottom, more cheese at the top, but flavor is good. 6.5 would be my score.

… more

John Wallace Richert

We happened to be heading back to Indy on I-69 and we needed a few things so shopped at the Hamilton Town Center. Lunch was in the air and we landed at the outdoor food court and decided to continue our search for exemplary pizza . Well, we finally had some very good pizza. It is NY style pizza, large slices and warmed up to order. We opted for a couple of the Combo #2s at around $7.50 each with a small salad, soda and a slice of pizza of our choice. My partner went with the margherita slice and I went with the supreme. Both were superb with just the right crust thickness, a slight crunch on bottom and done all the way through . The margherita had distinct garlic overtones along with the tomatoes and cheese. The supreme has green peppers , mushroom and pepperoni. Just the right amount of sauce and cheese. These slices’ ingredients were fully integrated and each bite was wonderful. So many pizzas are prepared and come out like you’re eating a pizza crust with toppings that seem like they are a separate dimension to the crust. These were a perfect balance of crust thickness , sauce and toppings. Highly recommend this pizza .

… more

Aleksandar Gecevski

If I could leave zero stars I would. Drove over 25 minutes to pick up a couple pies from this supposed ” NY Style” pizzeria because my wife was craving a taste from back home. A plain cheese and a meat pie. You would think that that’s difficult to mess up, right? I don’t know how pizza could be so bland and tasteless, but it was just that. The sauce was non-existant, and the crust was just bleh.Much akin to hospital food. Wife says that the one other time she had pizza from this place about 9 months ago that it was tasty and the closest she had found to authentic NY style in the area. I don’t know what happened since then, but the whole family agreed, this place was not it, not even close.

… more

Keenan Poff

Not gonna lie this pizza is VERY GOOD for food court pizza.

Typically food court food you think rushed, sub par quality – not Bella Pizzeria.

Their rolls and pizza were very good. I have to stop by this place everytime im in Noblesville.

Thank you for the amazing food!

… more

… View more

Bella Pizzeria – Noblesville

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Bella Pizzeria – New York Style Pizza and Pizza by the Slice

Bella Pizzeria – Noblesville – Noblesville, IN – 13901 Town Center …

Bella Pizzeria – Noblesville – View Menu & Order Online – Slice

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

🍽️ List or Update Your Restaurant

Recent Posts