Arley Bolanos
Ryan was very friendly on the phone! Nick was very attentive and convenient whenever We needed anything!
Teamwork is very present here ✊
We ordered the Mushroom & Cod Tacos as well as Sweet Potato Fries
For dessert: Rumchata Cheesecake and Key Lime
Thank You for such a wonderful experience
… moreAnthony M
The food was really good, and the staff is friendly. I like the outdoor patio area the best, as the inside is a bit dimly lit for my tastes. The kitchen is surprisingly slow considering we were there well after the main lunch crowd. There were very few patrons when we arrived but well over 20 minutes before the food was ready. I did like the food, but probably would not make a special effort to visit again.
… moreNeil M
Come here for: happy hour specials ranging from $2-$9, excellent appetizers, and the nest rum selection around
Don’t miss: bucket of fries, tuna tacos, watermelon cilantro mojito, and Trinidad lemonade
Skip the: nachos
Some pirate translations for the happy hour menu: scurvy nachos are regular nachos, crispy cannonballs are mac and cheese balls, moby pickles are deep fried pickles, calypso fries are crab dip fries, tender tacos are buffalo chicken tacos, and the bucket of fries is seasoned fries with Chick-fil-A-like sauce.
The tuna tacos are teriyaki marinated chopped tuna pieces in a mini hard shell taco. I highly recommend it. Jerk chicken tacos had pico, sour cream, and spiced chicken. The fried pickles were beer battered and the fried mac and cheese were covered in breadcrumbs. Both had a chipotle-ish sour cream under. The crab fries had a generous topping of crab dip.
The mojito was the best happy hour cocktail, followed closely by the Trinidad lemonade. If you like fruit juices, the punch is okay. The Dark Stormy is similar to a dark and stormy, but there isn’t the same bite from ginger beer as they use a ginger syrup. Our server Theresa was excellent, polite, attentive, and had great suggestions. The atmosphere was unique. The price was a but high and the regular menu (not the appetizers not) were pretty generic. I will be back.
… moreOlek Wojnar
Delicious food and awesome ambiance! They have an amazing rum selection. The place is also very kid-friendly and has a plethora of decorations that a pirate-obsessed kiddo would love. The benches are the perfect height for both adults and small children, probably due to the semi-firm cushioning.
… moreAlexandra Ng
My friends and I had a lovely dinner here! Our server, Cassidy, provided very friendly and professional service. I ordered the fish and chips, which I enjoyed. However, the fish tasted bland and could have been seasoned a little more. I did not eat the oysters, but my friends enjoyed them. The restaurant itself is pirate themed and I loved the decorations. I would absolutely recommend this restaurant to others!!
… moreLeigh
Wow! The food is so good! We did an online pick up order and it was easy, the food was ready on time. The fried mac and chesse is everything you can dream of, crispy and cheesy – will be back for more of those! Also couldn’t get enough of the old bay chips.
… moreRob Spengler
I come here whenever I want good rum and great service. We’ve been patrons since the old location and will continue to come until I fill my rum book. (One of these days ..) We’ve always tried to sit at the bar because we’re bar rats and every time we’ve had Priscilla. She’s the best kind of bartender. Knows what people drink, knows how to guide the people who don’t know what they want (and that’s tough considering they have at least 120 different rums before I lose count). Never had a bad time yet.
… moreMichael “Zane” Smith
Service was friendly and good, food was flavorful and well prepared, atmosphere was relaxed, consistent and inviting. Not a big place, and two larger groups were seated just before we arrived, so not surprised our meal took a little longer to come out. Portions were reasonable and fairly priced. It’s a nice, Caribbean-themed bar that’s worth visiting just for the food. We’ll be back.
… moreDan Stein
Driving by Mutiny Pirate Bar, you might wonder whether it’s open. There are curtains on the windows, so while the atmosphere is subdued and intimate on the inside, it looks closed from the outside unless there are customers on the patio. Mutiny is great for a date night or for a place to take the family. The decor is thoughtful and tasteful while being faithful to the pirate theme. They have a rum club which gives prizes as you sample different rum flavors. Mutiny is also a great place to meet up with friends and hang out at the bar. I highly recommend the rum punch! Burgers are made to order and are juicy and delicious. Cannonballs (fried Mac n cheese balls) are a favorite of my family.
… moreAK Jess
My partner and I are big wing fans, we have tried wings from just about every place around. And we found our absolute favorite here at Mutiny. So we were excited to order our favorite, the mutiny sauce. We ordered 16 wings but about 5 of them looked really weird, the meat and skin separated and was completely dried out. But we still had 11 that looked okay. But with one bite I knew something was wrong with the chicken, it tasted rancid. No big deal stuff happens. So I called and the manager was too busy so she kept relaying back and forth between the hostess. I drove back up to exchange the wings. I was shown one box that only had 1 weird looking wing but the bottom box was full of them. I honestly didn’t care as long as some of them tasted okay . But again same rancid taste. Then the manager refused to come up front, I go to the back and she was very rude. Still trying to defend this poor excuse for food. How do you go from being the best to this? Sad to say we are 100% never coming back. The picture I attached was part a video, the chicken on the left looks great and the piece of the right is the dried out wing
… more