Enduring neighborhood fixture serving thin-crust & deep-dish pizzas, along with other Italian fare.
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cataros Italian Villa: Exceptional Pizza and Italian Delights in …
Welcome to Cataro’s Italian Villa, a hidden gem nestled in Milwaukee at 5641 W Beloit Rd. This charming eatery is unclaimed yet unapologetically devoted to …
Cataro’s Pizza | West Allis WI – Facebook
… , WI · Greenfield, WI · West Allis, WI. Services. . Specialties. Dine-in. Contact info. . (414) 545-1520. . [email protected]. Photos. See all …
In search of the perfect pizza: Cataro’s Italian Villa – OnMilwaukee
started working at Cataro’s in 1966 when he was still a student at West Milwaukee High School. At that time Cataro’s was one of two very popular …
Reviews
Steve Cz
Fantastic as always. Not only does it taste great, but it’s always perfectly assembled also! Toppings on every piece that most places struggle with.
… moreJayne Larson
First time here but definitely not the last! Pizza was great! It was not busy when we were there so it was very comfortable. I could imagine it gets less so, however, when they have a full house. Pleasantly surprised by alternative entrée list.
… moreChelsea McDougall
Our favorite pie in West Allis! For the piece, it’s unbeatable! We ordered a large 2 topping, appetizer, dinner salad and a bottle of wine for under $50. We will definitely be returning.
… moreBrock Budde
Best pizza I’ve ever had. Been coming here for 20 years and I would put this place up against any food in Wisconsin
… moreSmalltown Wireless
Great food and amazing service! We had a big group of 13 people and they did a great job at serving us. The food is perfect portion sizes and the seasoning is perfect.
… moreJoyce Britt
Today was my first time dining at Cataro’s Restaurant. The pizza was outstanding! Our server was exceptional. Very cozy atomphere.
I highly recommend going there.
I know I will be back with my friends.
… moreI highly recommend going there.
I know I will be back with my friends.
Ben Kellom
The Food was Awesome we eate in had a large deep dish and a large thin crust I thought the thin crust was a little better but I’m splitting hairs we also had the opinion rings they were great also I will go again.
… moreZ Zylka
Pizza is thin crust n crispy. Fresh mushrooms garlic bread is good. Mozzarella sticks. Side salad is good…your basic salad with cukes, tomatoes, black olives. Had ol fashions n pizza as always was excellent!!! Crispy crust all the way thru…middle pieces are crispy. Service was good.
… moreBrooke Minik
If you haven’t had this pizza you are missing out. The thin crust special with pepperonis what my husband and I had. This is a well thought out made pizza. It’s not just a bunch of cheese and toppings thrown on there it is a work of art. I can honestly say it’s the best pizza I’ve had ever!!!
… moreKarina Ortiz
Disgusting.. no flavor.. absolutely not. Waste of $37. Literally threw away all the food in the garbage!
… more