Big Fitz
These were supposed to be honey garlic…….heavy on the garlic no honey very unpleasant taste, no flavor/seasoning at all. If you’re a wing lover I would suggest going eles where because these are not it….. JBH
… moreEirik
I’ve been is SFL for 20 years now and it’s hard to find pizza like you get in NY. This is NY pizza and the staff is amazing. I heard what I assume is the owner spit verbatim to one of the other employees exactly how a regular that was ordering liked their order.
Def found my new go to.
… moreTina
The pizza was great. The special was a great price for the amount of food. The owner was extremely pleasant. Small pizza joint tucked away in a strip mall, totally worth the stop!
… moreMatt A
My normal go to while in town. Prices have gone up, can’t fault them there. But the pizza we just had tasted like the dough had been premade a while ago. Not there normal, crispy standard.
… moreBari M Guzikowski
Placed takeout order via slice app. Everything was decent and tasty and done right (hence 4 stars) but seemed like cheap ingredients – cheesy bread was cheap hoagie rolls turned into garlic bread turned into cheap garlic bread. Caesar salad- romaine was fresh but could tell croutons were store bought and dressing on side (I asked for that) was ken’s packets. Not the best pizza we’ve had and not the worst – decent (ordered large pie half mushroom). Someone else mentioned it was like good quality roller rink pizza and we agree. I did think it was nice that they threw in 2 garlic knots with our order.
Folks at counter seemed nice though not much to comment on as I was in and out of there in less than a minute. It did smell faintly of cigarettes in there – I think it came from the staff.
Only two small tables in there – this place is clearly meant for takeout!
… moreAkil Grant
I first visited this establishment around 5-6 years ago, and while my experience was decent, I wasn’t particularly impressed at the time. However, when I decided to give it another shot about two months ago, I was pleasantly surprised and have been returning almost weekly ever since! The pizza is absolutely delicious and consistently exceeds my expectations.
It’s evident that a lot of hard work and dedication goes into every aspect of this place, which truly elevates the overall dining experience. I’m thrilled to have found such a fantastic pizza spot in the area that I can confidently recommend to my friends and family!
… moreThais Purdy
NYPD Pizza is my go-to pizza place in the area! The crust is super light and tasty, and the toppings are always fresh. You can tell they really care about the quality because every bite is just so good. Definitely my favorite spot when I’m craving pizza!
… moreАсэль Карабаева
The pizza is delicious, truly authentic Italian, the place is clean, and the staff are great. If you want real pizza, this is the place to go!
… moreSid A
First time ordering from here, from a friends recommendation. We got a House Special Sicilian. Crust was a little overcooked, compared to places I normally go to, so a lot of chewing. Most of the vegetables on top of the pizza were undercooked, and the ones on the edge were slightly cooked. I was surprised that the pizza was 16×12. All the local places I normally visit are 16×16. Their site only says 16″ when ordering a Scilian, and Scilians could be square or rectangular, but a customer would assume it would be square 16×16 because their picture on Google Reviews shows a square one which looks amazing. All in all, it wasn’t too bad. It’s definitely a place worth stopping by if you’re on the go or grabbing a slice, but for the price I paid, I’ll probably stick to a place I know. I will definitely order again from here since this was just my first time, but maybe I’ll try a regular pizza. When I do, I’ll update my review accordingly.
… moreVictoria Amor
Me and my husband were looking for some good pizza for the family in our area and came across this gem, we ordered delivery and let me tell you the pizza was so fresh and delicious and it was exactly what we were looking for my kids loved it and my husband told me wow this is some good Ny style pizza, and the delivery was fast and delivery person was nice and cool. Hands down best pizza ever in greenacres.
… more