I Love NY Pizza of Woodstock

Pizza is excellent, salad is excellent. I really enjoyed the crust and the ingredients are fresh. If you are ordering for delivery or take out this is a great place to pop in and pick up a meal. A fountain drink or tea option inside would have made this a better dining experience. The restaurant is clean and the people working here are friendly.

… more

Alex Fiser

We tried it for the first time last night. The food was good. We really liked their Ceasar Salad and pizza. We ordered a pepperoni, sausage and mushroom pizza and it was very good.
The service waa great, polite and professional. The owners are very nice.
The atmosphere is basic “pizzeria ” with sports decor and a TV. It was clean.

Try the salad and pizza. We think you’ll like it

… more

Suzanne Berne

My husband and I tried I Love NY Pizza a few years ago. It is our go to for take out Pizza. The crust, sauce, and toppings are delicious. The people who own it are great. We went to get pizza on this valentines day and they had an order for a calzone that was not picked up. They gave it to us for free. We always get a large pizza so we can have left overs. We defiantly recommend this place 100%

… more

Marielle Clark

This is the best pizza and I ❤️NY location! Family owned and very convenient to the local neighborhoods that are tucked away on 140! To the hater 1 star comments (ex. the guy who ordered a margarita pizza and expected tons of shredded cheese, it’s time for you to read a menu and a history book, just goes to show they are traditional, fresh and care about ingredients and the labor of love vs. your chemical papa John’s you are probably use to. You definitely taste the labor of love here as you can see the family making fresh dough right there when you walk in. Don’t listen to BS reviews from baba down the street. Definitely on this location! It’s the only family owned of all the others. Lasagna Pizza and their meatballs are my favorite

… more

Ali Kocabacak

I’ve been a regular at this family-owned gem for a while now, and it never disappoints! From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with warm, friendly service that makes you feel like part of the family. The pizza is top-notch — classic NY style with a perfectly thin, crispy crust and just the right amount of sauce and cheese. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients, and the flavor is always spot-on.

The menu has a great variety, but I always find myself coming back to their classic Margherita or a simple pepperoni pizza. They also have fantastic garlic knots and their homemade cannoli is a must-try for dessert.

If you’re looking for a cozy, authentic pizza experience with a personal touch, this is the place. Highly recommend supporting this wonderful local business!

… more

Chef Osiris

The pizza was delicious. Their crust is not doughy, but perfectly crispy. The space was super clean and the people were so sweet. I will come back for a pizza. Try their margarita pizza with some pepperoni

… more

TM B

I honestly did not have high expectations of this pizza place, but I was pleasantly surprised! I’m a native New Yorker, and the pizza was very good. The Greek and Caesar salads are delicious. And the mozzarella sticks were delicious as well! If I lived closer I’d eat here more often.

… more

H O

Family owned business treats families right. They offer variety of Italian goodies. Pizzas, strombolis, calzones and more. I enjoyed their Greek pizza.

… more

Michael Munger

Food is great, and we really wanted to love this place, but the experience wasn’t great. For starters, the air conditioner is not working. It’s a mini split, which is good, and it was set to 62, but there was no cold air blowing out of it. There’s just a fan in the corner. That’s not enough for hot Georgia summers. They don’t have fountain drinks, which was disappointing. Just plastic bottles. The ice machine is a mini countertop ice maker: the kind you have to manually fill and scoop ice. There wasn’t enough ice in there for my family of five, and it was all frozen together. I didn’t bring an ice pick. Not sure I want to risk sanitary issues with a non dispenser style ice machine. Pizza was good. Salad was good. Value wasn’t great. Two XL pizzas, drinks, a salad, dessert, and tip came to just under $100. If I had refills from a fountain drink and unlimited ice (and AC), this would have been acceptable. Unfortunately, the retail space seems to only be set up for the occasional customer. It’s clearly not their bread and butter, and the lack of investment shows. (At least get a Follett countertop ice machine that makes nugget ice). We live 5 minutes from here, and we REALLY wanted this to be our new weekly dinner place. Now, after tonight, we’re not sure we’ll be back.

… more

Laura

When we arrived at the place it was busy and we had to park behind the building. We ordered the deluxe pizza and sat down. I had unsweet tea while waiting for our food. We have tried New York Pizza in the past and we’re never satisfied. Until we tried this place. The crust and toppings were fresh and tasty. The staff were friendly too. We already decided what we’ll try next visit. This is a great place to try for anyone curious about NY pizza.

… more

… View more

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Menu – I Love NY Pizza WoodStock

I Love NY Pizza of Woodstock – Woodstock, GA – 10214 Hickory Flat …

I Love NY Pizza WoodStock – Pizza | Calzone | Salads | Sides …

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

🍽️ List or Update Your Restaurant

Recent Posts