Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3436 Tampa Rd, Palm Harbor, FL 34684
Phone: (727) 474-3797
Website: http://www.3brothersny.com/home
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Three Brothers Pizza – Home of the NY Pizza
Odessa, FL 33556 · Palm Harbor. 727-474-3797. 3436 Tampa Rd Palm … Three Brothers Pizza Rewards. 150 points. $5 Off. 250 points. $10 Off. 500 …
Three Brothers Pizza | Palm Harbor FL – Facebook
We serve the finest Italian cuisine and NY style pizza! Available for dine in, take out & delivery. C… See more. Italian Restaurant · $$.
Three Brothers Pizza Delivery Menu | 3436 Tampa Rd Palm Harbor
Order delivery or pickup from Three Brothers Pizza in Palm Harbor! View Three … Cheese Pizza. Classic NY Pizza with red sauce and Grande Mozzarella. $15.80+ …
Reviews
Austin Hildreth
We took advantage of the 2 large pizzas + 20 wing special and it was a great deal. Everything came out hot and fresh, the pizzas were loaded with toppings, and the wings were flavorful and cooked just right. Solid portions for the price and no corners cut on quality. Staff was friendly and the food hit the spot, definitely a go-to when you want to feed the family without breaking the bank.
… moregregory
I recently ordered the large pizza, spaghetti, and Caesar salad meal from Three Brothers Pizza, and I was honestly surprised by how good everything was. It’s rare these days to find a place that gives you both quality and large portions without overcharging, but this place really delivers on both.
The large pizza was the standout — it came out hot, fresh, and loaded with flavor. The crust had that perfect balance between crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, and the toppings tasted fresh rather than something thrown together. You can tell they take pride in how they make their pizzas.
The spaghetti portion was huge, way more than I expected for the price. The sauce had that homemade style taste — rich, a little sweet, and seasoned just right. It didn’t feel like something scooped out of a can; it tasted like real cooking. The pasta was cooked well, not mushy, and the whole dish was filling.
The Caesar salad was also a nice surprise. The lettuce was crisp and fresh, not soggy like a lot of places. The dressing had good flavor, and the portion size was generous enough to actually count as part of a meal instead of an afterthought.
Overall, I was extremely happy with what I got. The food was good, the portions were big, and the price was more than fair for how much they give you. It’s the kind of meal that makes you feel like you got your money’s worth and then some. If you’re looking for a reliable place with great flavors and big portions, I definitely recommend giving Three Brothers Pizza a try. I’ll absolutely be ordering from them again.
… moreThe large pizza was the standout — it came out hot, fresh, and loaded with flavor. The crust had that perfect balance between crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, and the toppings tasted fresh rather than something thrown together. You can tell they take pride in how they make their pizzas.
The spaghetti portion was huge, way more than I expected for the price. The sauce had that homemade style taste — rich, a little sweet, and seasoned just right. It didn’t feel like something scooped out of a can; it tasted like real cooking. The pasta was cooked well, not mushy, and the whole dish was filling.
The Caesar salad was also a nice surprise. The lettuce was crisp and fresh, not soggy like a lot of places. The dressing had good flavor, and the portion size was generous enough to actually count as part of a meal instead of an afterthought.
Overall, I was extremely happy with what I got. The food was good, the portions were big, and the price was more than fair for how much they give you. It’s the kind of meal that makes you feel like you got your money’s worth and then some. If you’re looking for a reliable place with great flavors and big portions, I definitely recommend giving Three Brothers Pizza a try. I’ll absolutely be ordering from them again.
Paulina Mejuto Fine
Hands down some of the BEST NY style pizza in the Tampa Bay Area. The staff was super friendly and helpful as first time customers. The star of the show is, of course, the food! The pizzas are a slice of heaven—a perfect crust with a light char, bubbling mozzarella, and fresh, vibrant toppings. The Sicilian is an absolute classic show stopper and a must-try if you’re looking for something special. Make your pizza an original culinary masterpiece with their fine selection of toppings.
We tried their garlic rolls as an appetizer and they did not disappoint. As for the pasta, each dish is a masterpiece, cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of chew. I would highly recommend Three Brothers for anyone looking for a truly authentic, excellent NY food experience. Dine in, Carry Out or get it delivered right to your door.
… moreWe tried their garlic rolls as an appetizer and they did not disappoint. As for the pasta, each dish is a masterpiece, cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of chew. I would highly recommend Three Brothers for anyone looking for a truly authentic, excellent NY food experience. Dine in, Carry Out or get it delivered right to your door.
S Rayburn
Amazing food and fantastic people! Just dined in with a big group and so thankful they could accommodate us. Highly recommend the penne alla vodka and meatballs. The salads are always delicious too. The employees were super friendly and service was great.
… moreJohn Negron
First time here, and it was great! I ordered two slices with sausage and extra cheese. The pizza was very tasty, and the correct temperature and consistency with New York Style pizza for sure. The staff is very friendly as well. I have family in the area, so we will be ordering from here whenever we want pizza.
Update: After my wife finished getting her nails done, we went right back to get her something to eat. She ordered a Grandma and a meat lovers pizza. I tasted the Grandma and it was so good!
… moreUpdate: After my wife finished getting her nails done, we went right back to get her something to eat. She ordered a Grandma and a meat lovers pizza. I tasted the Grandma and it was so good!
Tim Queen
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
One of the Best New York-Style Pizzas in Tampa Bay
Three Brothers Pizza absolutely deserves five stars. The crust is perfectly crispy with zero flop, and the sauce is packed with flavor without being overpowering. I’ve been to hundreds of pizza places over the last 20 years, and this spot truly stands out as one of the best New York–style slices in the entire Tampa Bay area.
If you love a classic slice done right, this place is a must-try.
… moreOne of the Best New York-Style Pizzas in Tampa Bay
Three Brothers Pizza absolutely deserves five stars. The crust is perfectly crispy with zero flop, and the sauce is packed with flavor without being overpowering. I’ve been to hundreds of pizza places over the last 20 years, and this spot truly stands out as one of the best New York–style slices in the entire Tampa Bay area.
If you love a classic slice done right, this place is a must-try.
Kelly Madden
I ordered a build your own pizza with rosemary crust, basil and fresh mozzarella all over, and then half portabello and half ricotta.
– They left off the sauce, which I did not request.
– They did not use rosemary crust.
– They swapped the basil with pesto, which is absolutely not the same.
The pizza tastes good, but it’s NOT what I asked for and I actually really don’t like “white pizza”, so this is incredibly disappointing to be eating. I also got charged $2 extra for a specialty crust that I did not receive. Unfortunately, it was carryout, so I’m not about to ask them to fix it.
… more– They left off the sauce, which I did not request.
– They did not use rosemary crust.
– They swapped the basil with pesto, which is absolutely not the same.
The pizza tastes good, but it’s NOT what I asked for and I actually really don’t like “white pizza”, so this is incredibly disappointing to be eating. I also got charged $2 extra for a specialty crust that I did not receive. Unfortunately, it was carryout, so I’m not about to ask them to fix it.
Mark Walls
Went in on Friday2/6/26 pick up a few slices. Waited my turn at the counter. Then got ignored by the staff. Ride share delivery drivers came in after me were helped immediately. I said something that there was a line and I was next. Again, ignored by staff. Finally the employee asked if I needed something. It was about 10 minutes of me waiting there. I told him to forget it and walked out. I guess 3 Brothers doesn’t want l9cal business only deliveries. Too bad, good pizza, horrible service.
… morelenin bojorge
I had the pleasure of trying Three Brothers Authentic New York Pizza for the first time today, and I can honestly say it exceeded my expectations. The pizza slices are absolutely incredible—packed with flavor, and the crust has just the right amount of crunch. The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming, making the whole experience even more enjoyable. What’s great is that they offer much more than just pizza; there’s a delicious selection of pasta, appetizers, salads, and more to choose from. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or something different, this place has it all. I highly recommend checking them out—you won’t be disappointed. I’ll definitely be back again soon!
… moreDakota G.
One word for this place: amazing! Today was $9.99 for a large pie, amazing deal. The pizza is amazing and you can tell everything is freshly made. We got a large cheese pizza with bacon and mozzarella sticks. Everything was hot and fresh out of the oven. The cashier was super sweet and made sure we were okay throughout the visit. Definitely a hole in the wall place, but I’m not sure why people were complaining about cleanliness. All the tables were clean and there wasn’t even any trash on the floor. Definitely a little small on the inside but you can always bring your pizza home to eat! I will definitely be coming back as I’m super excited to try other types of pizzas and other foods from the menu. Highly recommend!! Also, the tool they had for the pizza is absolutely genius and helped with actually getting a slice instead of just kinda flopping the pizza all over and getting sauce everywhere lol.
… more