Sherry J (Sherbear)
Nice cozy restaurant with delicious breakfast & great service! We will be back to try the fish fry! : )
… moreBonita Phillips
We ate at Elroy Eatery today. The food was so good. They have the best country fried steak in the area and I have tried several others. It was just perfect and our waitress was so kind and cheerful and even the other customers were so kind. Keep up the good work
… moreJulie Blackard
Their fish fry is definitely really good! Includes two sides and desserts, can’t beat that
… moreRebecca Emberson
Freezing in there due to the door drafts terribly, dress warm. Sourdough is actually white bread and a chocolate chip pancake might just have some sprinkled on top. Paid extra because I don’t eat pancakes at all but wanted a chocolate chip one to share with my husband. Now left hungry still
… moreNorton Lam
Quaint little restaurant in a small town Wisconsin. We stopped in for lunch and were very happy with our meals. I ordered a philly cheesesteak and very good. I appreciated that it wasn’t overly greasy like other restaurants can do. My family was also happy with their meals.
… moreCarla & John Pretsch
Service was excellent, the food was cook perfectly had the fish crispy outside flakie inside large pieces potatoes perfectly cooked……. daughter, my wife and I loved it and the atmosphere is homie and warm and inviting
… moreNina Gonzales
I have always loved the breakfast and I had the pizza for the first time last night and it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! I would absolutely recommend every one to try the Eatery!
… moreDayna Dalton
Morgan was our server and she was perfect! She was the only waitress working and the place was fairly busy! She did a great job of being professional and was attentive. The food was great and well priced! 10/10 would return and recommend
… moremonica baker
Pizza was delicious and hope that they will be able to start selling pizza on the weekends. I ordered a regular hamburger and fries only thing wong about my order was i didnt ask for cheeseburger. I didnt have time to contact them do to closing soon so no time for them to fix it. Normally id take it back but on time crunch
… moreMari
Great to have a breakfast place that opens fairly early in rural Wisconsin. We were there at 8.00am on a Saturday but they might have been open sooner. Service with a smile is always appreciated. The one drawback, too much grease: my omelette, O’Brien potatoes and toast seemed to be slathered in it.
… more