Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 9125 Otto-E Otto Rd, Cattaraugus, NY 14719
Phone: (716) 257-3443
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
New Waverly (@thenewwaverly) • Facebook, Connect with friends
Profile photo of New. New Waverly. For questions or to order call 716-257-3443 Address 9125 Otto-East Otto Rd, Otto,NY. Otto, NY. . Lives in Otto, New York …
The New Waverly of Otto – American restaurant in Cattaraugus …
The New Waverly of Otto stands as a welcoming gem in the heart of rural dining, offering a delightful blend of quality food and friendly service.
The New Waverly – Otto – MapQuest
The New Waverly is a charming bar located in Otto NY known for its welcoming atmosphere and friendly service. With a diverse selection of craft beers …
Reviews
Chris Ellis
Finally.made it. Nice little diner in the middle of nowhere. Food was good. The small fish is pretty small but was filling. Left some room for some cheap drinks. Pool table only costs 50cents. How nice is that. Could use a new house stick but they work. Bathrooms are nice and clean.
… moreNancy Gangloff
Food and service awesome! Wings huge. Sides with the fish fry homemade. French Onion soup loaded with onions and rich broth topped with lots of cheese. Prices very reasonable. We’ll be back!!!
… moreTeresa McWhirt
When we came up for a visit, I had the fish sandwich & it was delicious & that coleslaw was awesome. I’m looking forward to the wings this coming Wednesday. I can’t wait
… moretammy lagowski
Waited no lie 20 mins just for the bartender to come give us a menu, waitress walked by at least a dozen times and never said anything to us. Fish was good and a nice size but way to many pickles in the tarter sauce. Salads were less then desirable. Lack of taste and not good at all. Going to try again to support the small business, hope it changes a bit. Prices were a little high however all fish fry are going up so that was to be expected.
… moreKeenan Tadt
We had an extremely large party, staff was excellent, food was good and everyone had a good time. My family now comes for wing nights!
… moreLeah Guerin
Just started going to the new Waverly. We take our kids and granddaughter for dinner and will definitely go again. We have also been for date night for fish fries and drinks and recommend it for good food that won’t kill your wallet. Its very clean with exceptionally friendly staff. I would recommend if your in the area, passing through or just looking for some good food.
… moreRon Minin
Fish dinner on Friday was just like old day. Freshly battered and a large portion.
Customer service was awesome
… moreCustomer service was awesome
First Last
2022-09-09-Fri
The first time my family and I tried this out-of-the-way Food and Drink Establishment. 5 out of the 6 of us chose from Friday’s Fish selection and the other chose The ‘Waverly’ Burger. We all agreed our choices were especially fresh and delicious.
The cost was inexpensive, especially considering the quality of the plates.
The staff was courteous, professional & proficient.
The décor was simple & the restaurant was clean & comfortable. As this is a very rural location, there is no Wi-Fi however country music is played and there is a jukebox available. My family and I will definitely be going back.
… moreThe first time my family and I tried this out-of-the-way Food and Drink Establishment. 5 out of the 6 of us chose from Friday’s Fish selection and the other chose The ‘Waverly’ Burger. We all agreed our choices were especially fresh and delicious.
The cost was inexpensive, especially considering the quality of the plates.
The staff was courteous, professional & proficient.
The décor was simple & the restaurant was clean & comfortable. As this is a very rural location, there is no Wi-Fi however country music is played and there is a jukebox available. My family and I will definitely be going back.
Fred Petersen
We went on 75¢ wing night. The wings were awesome! And a variety of flavors. It is in the middle of nowhere, the dining room was not half as nice as the bar. And no A/C, and the server was hard to find
… moreshelly corbran
The food was very good and the prices reasonable. The wings are perfect also!! If you are looking for a good Friday night fish fry, then you have found your place!!!
… more