Glow “Glowing” Worm
This place used to be fantastic!! They Have definitely lost their touch. I ordered a baked spaghetti…I got regular and it was only filled halfway. I asked for extra meat sauce and got 2 meatballs. Their pizza is still good and that will be the ONLY thing I order and it will be a last resort
… moreKyle Vo
The waitress was very nice! She made me a very awesome Margarita <3 ! We had a great time great food here.
… moreJaney Sawyer
The outside with the car sales might deter some folks but we decided to stop since this place was not far from our house. It was very good. Service was excellent and the Alfredo Sause was light and did not taste like paste the way alot of Italian restaurant do. I was extremely pleased with my dinner and definitely will be back.
… morekaren spurr
It was average. I ordered spaghetti with meatballs. She brought out baked spaghetti which I don’t like. We were in a time crunch and I did not have time for them to remake my order. We will not back. The waiter was very nice and attentive but the food was lacking.
… moreKim MONTCHAL
Food was fresh and flavorful. We ordered, greek salads with chicken, a club sandwich and a Chicago Pizza. We didn’t even pull out of the parking lot and had to try the pizza. It was so good! The dough was light and airy, yet thick and so delicious. Thank you, Brother’s Pizza, for a wonderful meal to end a busy day!
… moreDaisy
Excellent taste with superb service.. the chicken was tender and seasoned well.. I normally don’t eat bread served, however, this bread was delicious.. pasta was perfect and sauce was tasteful.. only thing I did not like was the sawdust cheese over top the salad
… moreSarah Bates
I try to support small businesses and avoid leaving negative reviews, but this experience left us disappointed. My husband had a very disappointing experience at Brothers Italian Restaurant in Providence Forge on 09/24/25 around 1:00 pm. He had called ahead and placed an order. When he arrived, the cashier ignored him and proceeded to help three different men who came in after him. When my husband finally asked why others were being served first, the cashier’s response was, “Oh, they always come here.”
That’s an unacceptable excuse for bypassing a paying customer who was there before them. To make matters worse, all three men were white, and my husband is not. While I don’t like to make assumptions about intent, it’s hard not to see this as discriminatory behavior and it’s certainly how they made him feel.
A small, local restaurant—especially one without many other options nearby—should be welcoming to everyone, not dismissive of new customers. Sadly, this experience left us feeling unwelcome and disrespected. We will not be returning.
… moreMarLo
The pizza was good. But they need to add more salt in their dough. When pizza dough is under salted it lacks flavor. But we would go back.
… moreBill Brown
Found this restaurant while returning home from the Outer Banks. The service was good. The white staff was very friendly. The food was very fresh. My wife and I had the Caesar salads. I had chicken with mine. We also had the fried ravioli with marinara sauce and it all tasted very good. Should we ever be back down on Highway 60, we’re gonna make sure that we stop into Brothers’s Italian restaurant for a meal or a quick snack. Thanks to the great staff.
… moreJohn Fleming
Sorry to say I’ve had to edit my review. Just waited close to one hour for a chef salad and a “stromboli”. This “stromboli” was the single worst Italian food item I’ve ever received. Dough dry and not crispy. Half the stromboli not even full of anything. Just a mouthful of bad dough and cheese.
Totally unacceptable. I’ll probably give their pizza one more try, which is usually great. If their pizza falls off the cliff then I’m done with Brothers.
Hope this was a one time blip on the radar otherwise I feel sorry for the future of this restaurant.
—————-
We’ve had takeout and dine-in and we’ve been pleased with the food. I have had to wait a while after the due time for pizza pickup, but I attribute that to a small staff. These are tough times for restaurants, and yes, they could use another server in the dining room. But they are friendly and work hard. So a little patience might be needed on a busy day. Their pizza is the best around. I’m happy to have them in town.
… more