Juan Sandoval
The place felt exactly as it should, like an classic pizza joint. It was very clean and tidy. The pizza, sub, and cheese rolls were excellent. We ordered a 2 topping pizza, cheese rolls, and tea combo. It was amazing. My wife ordered a sandwich, and she really enjoyed it. She won’t usually finish her meal, but she did this time. The staff was a little dry, but the place was empty, other than us and take-out orderers. The price we paid overall was very affordable, and we will stop by again next time we visit the area.
… moreNeeley’s Household
We have just moved out to Canyon Lake and the first time we visited wicked pizza was the day we moved and we had a bunch of teenage boys that were starving and they’re two pizzas with a drink for 25 bucks was one heck of a deal
Today we went back for a second time, and Mike remembered us welcomed us warmly and Had amazing customer service we followed his advice and got the homemade tea. They served there instead of the soda. It was phenomenal. It was extremely clean and the atmosphere was awesome and if you’re a kid from the 90s or 80s, they have a sticker machine there that you gotta check out.
10/10
Can’t wait to try the BLT pizza next!!!!
… moreReagan Riemer
The food is decent but way overpriced. The only pleasurable experience I’ve ever had with an employee as a kid named Austin who was willing to accommodate in any way possible. The coffee shop next-door that is connected is great.
… moreAlexis M
Wicked Good Pizza really lives up to the name. The food is always good and the quality is on point every time.
Mike is also the best and always patient, friendly, and gives great customer service whenever we order. Thank you Mike, we appreciate you!
I also highly recommend the cheese rolls they are our absolute favorite!
… moreJae L
We had take out this evening I thought we would give this pizza joint a try. I had ordered cheese rolls and meat lovers with olives mushrooms and jalapeños the mushrooms were not added on but still charged. Pizza was pretty soft as though it was not cooked all the way. Pretty pricy for a large pizza and some cheese rolls.
… moreTimothy
As you walk into Wicked Good Pizza in Startzville, the first thing you’ll notice is the abundance of seating—perfect for family dinners or group meetups. Upon entry, I was immediately greeted by a friendly staff member at the counter, setting the tone for a welcoming experience.
I went with their Wicked Special: an X-large two-topping pizza, a small order of wings, and a gallon of tea. The entire order took just under 20 minutes to prepare, which is impressive for fresh, made-to-order pizza.
When I grabbed the pizza box, the warm aroma hit me instantly. And once we took our first bite, it did not disappoint. The flavor was outstanding, with the right amount of crunch and chew, topped with a perfect cheese pull that rivals what you’d expect from top-tier pizzerias in New York or Chicago.
In speaking with the owners, I learned that Wicked Good Pizza makes their dough fresh in-house. They don’t cut corners with pre-made crusts—they make everything from scratch at each location. That level of dedication to quality shows in every bite.
If you’re anywhere near Canyon Lake and craving a slice, Wicked Good Pizza is my top recommendation. With outstanding food and exceptional service, this place is a must-visit.
… moreOrlando Rodriguez
The restaurant closes at 9 o’clock, called my order in at 8:23. And from the get-go of the conversation, when I was placing my order the person taking the order was very rude and obnoxious, he insisted that I had to pay over the phone, which was fine, but then commenced to say that if I did not get there at 9 o’clock because the doors closed automatically at 9 o’clock that I would not get my pizza and I will not get a refund. I agreed I said that’s fine. I’m five minutes away, but he continued to express that if I did not get there that I would not be given my money or my pizza, I just tried to ignore it and just play it off because I know people have bad days but what really got me was That they decided to add a 15% tip on their own without even asking for a pick up order.
And by the way, if you are placing a order of boneless wings, they only come in medium and large. They won’t tell you how many pieces come in the orders.
… morestacy ramirez
I had my reservations about Wicked Good Pizza because of a few negative reviews, but I’m so glad we decided to try it for ourselves! We ordered a pizza for pick up on a Monday night & it was ready in about 20 minutes.
The crust was fresh w/fluffy edge & crispy bottom & the ingredients were very fresh too. We ordered an extra large 1/2 feta & spinach & 1/2 mushroom & jalapeño.
Added bonus is that your order is saved so the next couple of times we ordered all we had to say is use our previous order!
We will definitely continue coming!
… moreMiranda S.
I ordered curly fries, got home, and had very regular fat and not curly fries instead. After calling the establishment, I’m told that their curly fries shipment came in straight, and they hadn’t thought to say anything because they should taste the same.
The same, they did not taste. They taste like disappointment, and food I wouldn’t have ordered if I’d been properly informed when I was placing my order, or even even I picked up. I’ll be making the drive out to the older location next time.
… moreAnh Pham
My first time tried the pizza here and it’s pretty good. I love thin crust pizza
… more