Jaqui V.
Stopped in briefly to get some slices to go while my cat was at the vet. Ordered just regular plain slices. They seemed on the smaller size but slightly on the higher end price point for that size of a slice. It wasn’t the worst slice, it was good, decent. Definitely not the best slice I’ve had, but edible. Would I get a pie from here or come back, probably not. I’m a pizza snob and this was just a quick slice. Not a wow, and not memorable. Other than that, the workers were lovely. Cashier was helpful, guys making pies were quick to throw my slices in the oven and get me out of there quickly. Decent local spot I suppose.
… moreCynthia Verrone
Having lived in Montclair for 5 years and complaining about not being able to find a great tasting authentic Margarita pizza, we finally found it at Belgiovine’s. Bottom line: the highest quality ingredients – San marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, perfectly baked crust -folds but doesn’t flop and topped with fresh basil. It’s just so very satisfying! The square version is the best! I can’t understand why it’s not ranked the best pizza in the area. We’ve also enjoyed their eggplant parm and Cesar salad
… morerika R
Delicious !! Picked up a Too Good To Go order from here . If yu don’t know what that is it’s an app that restaurant use to get rid of leftover food close to store closing time . First time trying them , the pizzas were so good crispy in every bite. We got 5 square slices . 2 chicken buffalo and 2 I believe were pepperoni speciality . They were all good . Def good pizza
… moreAngel Arce Jr.
I love pizza. I usually prefer to eat at the locations above all, especially my first visit. It’s Christmas Eve, and this is one of the only pizza spots open after 4 pm. They have the “CLEANEST RESTROOM” I’ve seen besides my own at home. Now on to the establishment itself. The decor and atmosphere make me want to return, and I haven’t tried their pizza yet. Tony is the gentleman who assisted me with my order. He maintains a level of class while still keeping the guest and cooking area in stellar shape. My next review will be about the food when we get home. I can’t wait.
… morePaul Hazan
I got a Too Good To Go order from here, we got 2 pie slices of sausage and 2 square slices one margherita and one buffalo chicken for a reasonable price, they were hot and the crust was crispy. I want to try all the pizza places in Montclair before I repeat but I will definitely come back here.
… moreBrian Wade
Was in Montclair early on a Saturday and craved pizza, this place was one of the only ones open…glad it was because the pizza was awesome. I got the hot grandma, sausage was excellent, crust was great. It was one of the best pizzas I’ve had and I love pizza…and great customer service!
… moreM K
Disappointing first experience. Ordered delivery. Two square pies – plain and mushroom/spinach/truffle.
1) The pies were overcooked. Bottom of crusts were half black and they were near brick-ish.
2) Truffle oil pie had no truffle flavor.
Garlic knots were good though.
Love the deli and wanted to try the pizza but don’t think we’ll do again because the pizzas were so hard/overcooked.
… moreDionne R
Best Pizza in Montclair and surrounding area! Had a slice of sausage (sausage is made in house) and it was delicious. The new owner, Tony is very nice and from
a brief conversation has been in the restaurant business successfully for years. Quality food is hard to find these days and top notch, kind business owners are also rare. This will be my new go to, give it a try you will not be disappointed.
… moreRyoji Yamada
Really really good pizza. It’s all done in the same shell. Plain and grandma were both stellar. The buffalo chicken slice was the standout in my opinion. Reasonable pricing too! Can’t wait to come back and try the deli side or their chicken parm. The thinly pounded cutlets looked incredible too.
… moreCammy Hardison
Good thin crust with tasty sauce! Good value also
… more