Social Profile: 
… View more
Delicious handmade Key Lime Pies, Key Lime Pie Bars all made from scratch in house daily. All natural ingredients to give you the finest in Key Lime Pie.. We are not the key lime grocery store where you can buy the same cookies, jams etc you can back home for 1/3 the price. Come see how it’s made, the way it should be made. If we don’t make it we don’t sell it. Come watch us make every piece of our pies while you eat.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 511 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040
Phone: (305) 517-6720
Website: http://www.keylimepieco.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Key West Key Lime Pie Company – Award Winning Key Lime Pie
The best prices in the Keys! All natural Key Lime desserts including Key Lime Pie, Key Lime Pie on a stick, dessert bars, sauce – Featured on CNBC’s The …
Key Lime Pie Bakery
Delicious homemade Key Lime Pie and thousands of beautiful souvenirs for our local and online community.
Our Journey – Key Lime Pie Co
The Rowe family launched this company as one of the original Conch Key Lime Pie businesses. They were well-loved and known throughout the island—especially for …
Product
Last Updates
Reviews
Merra Luna
The best lime pie ever yummy
Good service friendly ☺️ made my day first time in Key west Florida
… moreGood service friendly ☺️ made my day first time in Key west Florida
Janet Caudillo
I’m a key lime pie fan. We went by a few places to try their key lime pies. We got a small pie, it frozen, we ate it about a day later and it wasn’t good. It felt as the crust melted (got runny like the caramel of a flan). The texture wasn’t good, I’m not sure if it was because we got it frozen but it’s definitely not worth it. My daughter ate the whip cream. Publix key lime pie is a whole lot better.
… moreDr. Rosie Ann Riley
This was the absolute best key lime pie I have ever eaten. My niece and her husband actually saw this company on The Profit and said the gentleman stated the same thing.
I guess you’ll have to visit Key West to get a taste of true key lime pie or order it online and have shipped.
I wish I had bought more!! I highly recommend visiting if in the area.
… moreI guess you’ll have to visit Key West to get a taste of true key lime pie or order it online and have shipped.
I wish I had bought more!! I highly recommend visiting if in the area.
Jorge Gonzalez Graupera
Stopped in on my way out of town to get a slice of key lime pie for my wife back in Miami. The shop had just opened, and the sweet, attentive lady behind the counter really made my day. Back in Miami, we served those mini pies, and they were delicious. I don’t know if KWKLPC has the best pie in the Keys, but I do know it’s the only place I will ever go when I’m down there.
… moreDonna
Purchased a pie on line last Sunday as a gift, paid $60 for their 2 day shipping, initially received notice that the pie would be delivered Wednesday, all is good. Next received notice of a Friday delivery date instead. Concerned about a frozen pie in transit for that length of time I phoned the company, spoke to a woman named Stephanie who assured me that as long as the pie arrived frozen all would be OK. Pie arrived, recipient noted it was “soft” I notified the company of my disappointment, will NEVER order from them again. Update: after posting this review the company did refund my purchase. Grateful for the refund but the purpose of my gift never came to truism.
… moreMonica
While visiting we took a sampling of people to ask whom had the best Key Lime Pie and hands down this was the place.
Yum Yum Yum
… moreYum Yum Yum
Laura Stabell
I was just in there. I bought a lime drink for $2.75 +tax. They’re always $3 bucks even. But today the cashier told me $3.50. I said $3.50? Do you mean $3.15? How can it be $3.50? He again said $3.50. Ummm ok. So I give him the $3.50 questioning that. He then puts $3 in the drawer and puts 50 cents in the tip bucket. I didn’t say he could do that.I GOT HUSTLED. BEWARE. This was a small ticket item. WATCH YOUR TAB
… moreWassim Ayass
Very well clean place with nice designs and space. The service was friendly. The slices of key lime pies weren’t that tasty. It’s nice to see the process of making pies in front of you but personally I didn’t like the taste.
… moreJeff Reffner
DO NOT EAT THE FOOD HERE! I just bought a piece of key lime pie and the lady that helped me, did so with a mouth full of French fries and just handled an entire pie with the same gloves on her hands that she was just eating her Wendy’s with, then went back to eating with those same gloves on again. It is the most disgusting thing I’ve witnessed at this place. I’ve been coming to KW for 16 years and will never eat at this place again. The pies were good, the staff if disgusting now.
… moreN Patel
Definitely the BEST Key Lime Pie in the Key West!!! We have tried Key Lime Pie from other locations during the same visit, but their Key Lime Pie and taffy definitely have that Key Lime punch, great consistency and taste as well. We the the mini version, soft serve. Great service, great ambiance. I would definitely love recommend and I know I will definitely crave it when I’m back home.
… more