4.7 – 41 reviews • Ice cream shop
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 12–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–8 PM |
| Thursday | 12–8 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–7 PM |
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Reviews
Jake Ellis
My wife absolutely loved the blueberry lemonade—the flavor was perfect! The pretzels were some of the best I’ve had in a long time: golden, buttery on the outside with just the right touch of salt. The owner is friendly and clearly knows his craft. The small indoor seating area overlooking the plaza and Lincolnway makes for a refreshing stop while walking through downtown. Highly recommend!
… moreJosh Zacher
Came here with my family to try the new ice cream place in town. They serve soft serve ice cream only as well as pretzels, slushies, soda pop, and other desserts. I highly recommend the shakes. The root beer float was just ok, nothing beats a frosty mug or when the pop gives the ice cream that icicle texture, which this was missing. It was clean and the staff was friendly and they also have a pickup window.
… moreAlexandra Salerno
Our family really enjoyed stopping in here on our late night walk! They are open until 10pm.
The ice cream is SUPER creamy and delicious and you can create your own flavor with mix ins 🙂
We tried the heath & pineapple and both were absolutely delicious.
The pretzels are THE BEST PRETZELS AROUND!! better than Ben’s pretzel, wetzel pretzel, or auntie Anne’s.
They have multiple different options for pretzel size & flavor- along with many different cheeses.
We got the mini pretzel bites with beer cheese & they were to die for!!!! They are coated with a little butter & salt, crisp on the outside with just the right amount of chewiness to them.
The customer service was great & they checked in with my kids to make sure they were enjoying their order.
We will definitely be returning again!
… moreIva Deondrae Jordon
We stopped through on our way home from Roger’s City, MI. This was the absolute BEST Apple dumplings a la mode I’ve ever had. I literally made myself sick because I ate it so fast. We plan to stop on our way through next time.
… moreSasha Sato
Pretzel and ice cream was absolutely delicious! The customer service was even more impressive. 10/10 recommend!
… moreLaura U
I really wanted to like Central Park Creamery, but unfortunately my experience has been frustrating.
Our order was canceled twice due to “store-related issues,” even though we only ordered simple milkshakes. I also tried calling during business hours on another day, and the phone rang more than 20 times with no answer and no voicemail.
Because of this, we won’t be trying this place again.
… moreariel
Yummy place with a ton of sweet options! Will go again and they gave us a free treat!
… moreShaina Canlas
Super cute small dessert shop that stays open later than the surrounding sweet shops. Had pizza next door and walked here for dessert. I came in for a malt shake but was sold on the apple dumpling. It’s like a mini apple pie they cook, dump in a cup, pour soft smooth icecream over and top with whipped cream and cinnamon powder. I would definitely return to try different things on the menu.
… moremadeleine
Such amazing customer service and the lemonades, pretzels, ice cream, and strawberry shortcake are all so amazing. I highly recommend going here for a sweet treat.
… morePetar Arsenijevic
Central Park Creamery is wonderful place to get ice cream and pretzels with family and friends. The place is very clean and neat. Their products are delicious. I highly recommend the vanilla pecans, and caramel mix. I am very happy with the prices as well. The staff are professional and friendly. I highly recommend you try it!
… more … View more