Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 999 Montauk Hwy #8, Shirley, NY 11967
Phone: (631) 281-1476
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Your Bagel Cafe 999 Montauk Highway – Order Online
… Your Bagel Cafe at 999 Montauk Highway in Shirley. Order … Your Bagel Cafe Kohl’s Shopping Center. Sign In. Your Bagel Cafe. 999 Montauk Hwy #8, Shirley, NY …
Order Your Bagel Cafe – Shirley, NY Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Your Bagel Cafe at 999 Montauk Highway in Shirley. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Your Bagel Cafe Delivery Menu | 999 Montauk Hwy Shirley – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Your Bagel Cafe in Shirley! View Your Bagel Cafe’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with Grubhub!
Reviews
Christina Carbone
Amazing food and all the ladies and gents working here are welcoming. My chicken salad sandwich had so much chicken salad on it! Shout out to Linda for making me a mean coleslaw BLT the other day! Thank you Gina as well. Alot of Coffee creamers to choose from and right now there is a really cool window mural for christmas!
… moreTom Kirchhoff
Place us straight up legit! Excellent sandwiches their fresh bagels with cream cheese and crispy bacon is succulent don’t tell my cardiologist.
… moreHeidi Feser
Every year I fly up from Florida and stop here for my bologna sandwich! Thank you Linda for making me the best bologna on a bagel! You’re a gem. I always bring a dozen back to Florida. My family loves your bagels.
See you next year!
Update! She made my bologna on a bagel perfectly. Got some bagels to take home.
… moreSee you next year!
Update! She made my bologna on a bagel perfectly. Got some bagels to take home.
Toni Sterling
Breakfast sandwiches are so good. Plenty of bagel flavors to choose from out in the display case. Their bacon was nice and crispy. Service was good. Food came out quickly. Coffee is self serve, they have a lot of different flavor creamers. A couple tables up front if you want to eat there. Would definitely reccomend!
… moreSavannah Darrow
VERY DISAPPOINTED. My fiancé called in our order and reads my order the same way on the phone any time we order from any bagel store. An egg everything bagel lightly toasted with very little cream cheese and two pieces of bacon. I get to the store 15 minutes after the call was made and it was pretty busy so I understand a little bit of a wait. I waited 10 minutes in the store and so after a total of 25 minutes to complete a 1 bagel and 1 breakfast sandwhich order I would have liked our orders to atleast be correct. My bagel was made way ahead of time so it didn’t even matter that I asked for toasted at that point and when my fiancés breakfast sandwich was finally ready they didn’t even call the right name when I went up to the counter. I got home and my bagel was LOADED with cream cheese to the point you can barely see the bacon. The bacon was soaked in cream cheese I could barely even taste the bacon. I literally had to scrape off the cream cheese to even try to enjoy eating my bagel. And if that wasn’t already disappointing enough my fiancés sandwhich had no hot sauce on it like he had asked for. For almost $14 and a 25 minute wait for two things I’d atleast like it to be correct. Please listen to your customers over the phone when they are ordering and make it the way they ask for it.
… moreStefanie Di Carlo
This is one of the worst places I haven ever been. Ordering the sandwiches over the phone I will say that the staff was alright. After picking up the sandwiches though I was shocked. First of all, the bill was over $30 and for what?? I asked for three sandwiches. Two with 3 egg whites and two orders of small home fries on the side. The sandwiches looked like they had only one egg white on and and the bagels were squished. They charged me $6 for home fries that looked like they were a large and not a small. They were full of red spice sauce and god awful large onions and peppers. As shown in the picture there is something that looks like a gigantic uncut onion. These were more like dinner potatoes and honestly don’t know how they think that people would even eat this when it was mostly a bowl of spicy peppers and onions! Ever since this place changed over they have never tasted the same. When I used to go out to breakfast with my family I would spend about $18-$20 for three sandwiches. Not over $30!! When I called to confirm the woman was not the nicest when we sounded unsure of the pricing. The place did not change for the better and I will not be going back there.
… moreFran Cioffi
Best bagels. Sandwiches are made generously. No skimping on the meat. Everyone is always so nice and pleasant. I would definitely recommend this place. Bagels are hugh with a really nice variety.
… morekhemran ramesar
I must say that I’m very disappointed with the sandwich that I received!
Purchased a chicken cutlet hero today with bacon cheese, mayo etc, and a chicken salad at this establishment.
There was hardly any chicken cutlet to fill the bread, hardly any bacon also!!!
Both sandwiches was very salty also.
I have no problem paying the going rate for food in today’s market if I’m getting good service and a good product!!!!
This review is not intended to hurt your business but instead help you improve your service and standards!!!
… morePurchased a chicken cutlet hero today with bacon cheese, mayo etc, and a chicken salad at this establishment.
There was hardly any chicken cutlet to fill the bread, hardly any bacon also!!!
Both sandwiches was very salty also.
I have no problem paying the going rate for food in today’s market if I’m getting good service and a good product!!!!
This review is not intended to hurt your business but instead help you improve your service and standards!!!
Manny
I use to enjoy coming here for my bagels. I would normally come 3-4 times per week. Today was my last day. Throughout the years I would normally use the bathroom with no issues, but in these last 2 months I’ve been getting told that the bathroom isn’t available and “needs repairs”. I’ve asked on 3 separate occasions. Gina is very rude and I won’t be giving them anymore business. I tried giving them the benefit of the doubt but it seems like they have a specific preferenc on whos allowed to use it. I’ve personally seen them allow other customers before me, and when I’ve asked I’ve been told no. I thought that maybe they were employees, turns out they weren’t. I can’t be giving any business to a cafe that discriminates. I’ll be eating breakfast elsewhere.
… moreMelissa Kaufmann
My mom and I visit this bagel store every Thursday morning and order the same egg sandwiches. We love the staff! They are very friendly and kind. They work hard and it shows.
The bagels are consistently good, I’ve never had a bad one
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreThe bagels are consistently good, I’ve never had a bad one
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️