Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Fatman’s Pizza is the place to go when you want a handcrafted pizza on-the-go that doesn’t sacrifice on quality or delicious taste! We’ve been serving up mouthwatering selections since the 1970s, but we’ve recently started our next journey under new ownership. Jeff Galdys and his friendly staff are ready to offer you the best pizza in WNY, along with our crispy and saucy wings, fresh salads, and other satisfying menu items. Whether you reside in North Tonawanda, Wheatfield, Amherst, or one of the surrounding areas, count on our pizza and wings restaurant for delicious food whenever you’re hungry!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2712 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda Town, NY 14150
Phone: (716) 693-7477
Website: https://www.fatmanpizzawny.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fatman’s Pizza: Pizza Shop in Buffalo, NY
Discover mouthwatering pizzas, wings, & more at Fatman’s Pizza, your go-to pizza shop in Buffalo, NY. Craving a slice? Call today & satisfy your cravings!
Fatman’s Pizza – Tonawanda, NY – 2712 Niagara Falls Blvd – Hours …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Fatman’s Pizza in Tonawanda, NY. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Fatman’s Pizza | Tonawanda NY – Facebook
Fatman’s Pizza, Tonawanda. 2313 likes · 47 talking about this · 1057 were here. Fatman’s Pizza has been delivering handcrafted pizzas and more to the…
Product
Last Updates
Reviews
M P
**Another edit – tried the chicken finger calzone, and it did NOT disappoint! Made with the blue cheese inside is definitely the proper way. Thank you to the chef from last night (12/9/25)! That hit every craving for me, best of both worlds!
First time trying this place, not going to be the last! We had a hankering for some calzones, and this dude brought some of the best I’ve had.
The dough was cooked perfectly to my preference, slathered with an exquisite garlic oil. The ratio of mozzarella to ricotta was perfect! The pepperoni is top shelf, and has a great bite. Sautéed onions are next level! Everything seemed fresh, everything was undeniably delicious.
Only critique is that a couple of the calzones needed better topping distribution, the corner pieces were mostly cheese. Not an issue, will definitely be back.
Update!
Been back several times, never a disappointment. They even made an off-menu fried bologna calzone, it was amazing! Can’t go wrong with FatMans!
… moreFirst time trying this place, not going to be the last! We had a hankering for some calzones, and this dude brought some of the best I’ve had.
The dough was cooked perfectly to my preference, slathered with an exquisite garlic oil. The ratio of mozzarella to ricotta was perfect! The pepperoni is top shelf, and has a great bite. Sautéed onions are next level! Everything seemed fresh, everything was undeniably delicious.
Only critique is that a couple of the calzones needed better topping distribution, the corner pieces were mostly cheese. Not an issue, will definitely be back.
Update!
Been back several times, never a disappointment. They even made an off-menu fried bologna calzone, it was amazing! Can’t go wrong with FatMans!
Shining Crystal
Have to say overrated. Turkey sub very good. Pizza crust and sauce decent, sausage hard and fatty, pepperoni average bland taste or undercooked. BBQ chicken fingers, sauce very food, fingers themselves fatty, not tender, fries dried out or greasy tinge. They seem to get part of the meals right, the other parts not great. Wish I could say otherwise. I tried it years ago and it did not change or what reviews say is not accurate. Subs I would give a high mark, everything else mediocre. Not what you want to spend $50 on being honest.
… moreAlexa Wisel
Fatman’s Is consistently the best! Friendly service, amazing food, and each food item better than the next. The sauce is sweeter so would 10/10 always recommend if that’s what you’re looking for. Wings are crispy and the sauce is perfect. Also, the bleu cheese …. Chefs kiss
… morePatrick G
Ordered this today for the second time and we got a large cheese and pep well done with sweet sauce, extra sauce and extra cheese. Pizza was flavorful and made to our specifications. We also ordered some Cajun Honey butter bbq wings and honey BBQ fingers as well. The blue cheese it came with was amazing. The wings blew me away as I usually don’t expect so much from pizzeria wings but they really over delivered in terms of quality and flavor. They could be larger would be my only complaint but they were cooked perfectly once again to our specifications of extra crispy. Fries were crispy and the fingers were a hit as well. Very impressed and we will be ordering from them again! Loved the amount of variety and specifications available to all of their food on the menu and it really stood out how well they listened to those specifications!
… moreTekk Nomad
Great pizza and service!! Pizza has a thick but crunchy crust. We got pepperoni and mushrooms. The pep is crispy, and the mushrooms are large and fresh. The garlic marinara sauce is excellent and there’s a perfect amount of cheese also. The 2 fellas behind the counter were extremely friendly and even offered up a spatula so we could serve our pizza (it’s a to go place but we ate at the inside table as we live out of the area). Highly recommended!!
… moreMargaret McDonald
Fat Mans being a locally owned pizzeria provides excellent food with a very warm atmosphere when you go in. They pay close attention to the customer and their needs. I have always had a great experience there.
… moreGreg D
Fantastic!!
Stopped in before Bills game and was greeted immediately by friendly staff.
The pizza was perfectly prepared with delicious cup & char pepperoni.
Highly Recommended!!
… moreStopped in before Bills game and was greeted immediately by friendly staff.
The pizza was perfectly prepared with delicious cup & char pepperoni.
Highly Recommended!!
Diane Cunningham
Ordered subs. Takeout. Asked for veg on the side. Subs were great. Everything, except meat & cheese was on the side so ladies could help themselves. Delivery was early. Thank you.
… moreNicole Galdys
Always a great experience. I appreciate the creative specials every month. I continue to look forward to see what they come up with next! Highly recommend.
… moreThe Updated Ranney48
Jeff and Crew always make sure that your experience, and your taste buds, are well catered too! Fat Man’s is a staple of our family and will be for years to come! The monthly specials also give a big added bonus to make sure you never feel like you’re chosing “the same old” even with such a large menu!
… more