For those who enjoy good taste and a filling meal, the Red Tomato Pizzeria is the way to go! Along with a large variety of tasty pizzas, we offer a medley of salads, pasta dishes, paninis, cheese steaks, chicken steak sandwiches, and a number of other types of hot and cold sandwiches. With our homemade dough, bread and sauces you will see that this AIN’T YOUR NORMAL PIZZA JOINT!!
Amber D
I went here my for lunch with 1 other person in my party. I ordered pasta and garlic knots. The woman behind the counter had HORRIBLE customer service. She rung me up and I was using tap the first transaction said $0.07 and the second transaction said $25.69. After the first transaction was processed the lady said your card was declined. I remained calm but was very upset because I know this was an untrue assumption. So when she went to charge me the second time I used the same card that she said was declined for my transaction and once again it was approved. The cashier lacked professionalism completely how she handled me the customer. I actually should’ve left when the cashier who was sitting down and eating wipe her hands with paper towels and then took my order. Regardless if you’re touching the food before you wait on a customer when you go behind the counter the first step you should do is wash your hands with soap and water. I just reviewed other reviews and saw one that talked about unsanitary conditions with gloves and this shows a clear pattern of uncleanliness. The other person in my party and said she was completely rude as if she was racist because she was treated better and is of a different race than me. She was proud how I didn’t argue with her despite her irrational behavior when all I requested to know why I had one transaction versus two. After we got our food the other person in my party stated to me that what she received was boneless wings and she clearly ordered bone-in wings. The cashier woman who sat back down inserted herself in our conversation by saying you ordered boneless wings in an aggressive confrontational tone of voice. It’s very apparent that this cashier needs another position because providing customer service is the last thing she should do. The food was horrible with the exception of the garlic knots. I ordered a pasta dish and the noodles were over cooked and swimming in sauce, the boneless chicken wings were hard as a rock. I write a lot of reviews and visit many establishments and this is by far the worse establishment I visited in 2025 thus far. I urge all people to go where you are valued, able to order great food and even better service.
… moreAWM
Home delivered pizzas are always hot and on time and decent quality for this area, an area where most pizzerias make the crust too thick. But this last time we ordered a large Margherita with pepperoni, and I have to say it was one of the best pizzas we’ve had anywhere including Philly and NYC. Crust nice and thin, sauce and cheese excellent. Not sure what they may have changed, but their pizzas went from B+ to A++.
… moreKate
The pizza bottom is thin but not crispy-I prefer more crispy, the crust was very crispy. The quality and quantities of toppings on the pepperoni overload were perfect. I requested it cooked well done, and they checked with me twice to make sure I was happy with it. The small eat-in area was uncomfortably cold. It is a small space with tiny tables that barely hold a pizza and two plates. Seems to be a big spot for delivery.
… moreShelly
I didn’t realize this joint was more or less one of those ‘Along with Dunkin Donuts’ places, but it was getting late and we wanted some quick pizza so I did a quick grab on ‘Maps. It’s fine for travelers as there is a Speedway gas station right next to it. The soft drink machine was out of order. The single slice selection was minimal. But in fairness, the white pie was delicious… ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, and prosciutto. The other slices were fine. The lady taking care of me was a total sweetheart and very nice. So the white slice and the lady get the increased stars.
… moreLOR D
Stopped in for some take out. They have a nice menu and the service is friendly. Ordered the chicken piccata that comes with choice of pasta and a side salad. Food was good and portions were filling.
… moreAshley Dreas
I want to first start off by saying I’ve never written a bad review in my life. I’m the most easy going customer a business could ask for. I picked up an order Saturday night and when the lady ran my card she was waiting for the system to print the receipt. It never printed, so she told me she needed to run my card through again. To make the transaction go smoother, I offered to pay cash instead. Later on I checked my bank app and saw that my card had been charged even though I paid cash. Of course I was given no receipt either (which I didn’t think twice about in the moment). I had called on Tuesday explaining the situation. I was told that the manager would call me the next day regarding the issue. It’s now been 4 days later and no call back. After reading a few other reviews, based on other transactions, plus my own experience, I no longer trust or respect the integrity of this establishment. The $32 I owed ended up being over $60 that I spent on a buffalo chicken calzone and garlic knots since I was charged twice. I understand accidents happen, but there is a way to go about them and make things right. Unfortunately I will no longer be giving them my business.
… moreSam Belman
When I was a kid, my dad used to take us here twice a month and I would always get the cheddar bacon cheesesteak. It still appears to be under the same management – the guy who runs the place is super nice and it looks like they recently renovated the interior (which they did a great job on). There’s even a giant QR code to their menu on the outer wall of the front counter.
I went here recently to get a taste of memory lane and goodness, the food is just as delicious as it used to be! I can’t wait to come here again.
… moreJason Danweber
This is the home to genuine Italian food. They have uniquely delicious and crispy on the outside garlic knots. The “side” salad shown in the picture came with the meal and was large enough to be almost considered a full salad. The vodka pasta (see pic) was original according to my Italian wife. We will return again. This place is a step above all the other places.
… moreKyle T. Evans
Some of the best pizza is the valley. The guys who run the place are solid dudes. Wouldn’t give my business to anyone else!
… moreSamantha
Not to be a Karen but I came here for the 5.00 Cash special of 2 plain slices and the guy behind the counter told me it was $6.00. Which is odd because I was here THE DAY BEFORE and got the same deal for the correct $5.29 adding tax. This special is also clearly marked on their door. I had brought in the exact amount I knew I would need, so once hearing it was now $6.00, I had to run out to my car to grab an extra dollar. Feeling a bit annoyed I said to the guy behind the counter that it was $5.00 yesterday, and it says $5.00 on the door. He didn’t say anything to me. He took my 6 dollars and gave me my pizza. I saw my receipt had printed so I asked for it. ! It says my total is $5.29! This is the main reason for my review. I’m not hurt over the .71 cents, but rather baffled at the lack of integrity and dishonesty at this establishment. Why tell me it’s $6.00 when your own system says $4.99!! A simple “we raised the prices to cover expenses” would have sufficed, but lying, having a customer go of their way to pay an extra cost that isn’t shown, and not saying anything at all is just unacceptable business behavior.
… more