Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
The Bagel Club, Deli and Catering – Flemington
The Bagel Club. 20 Commerce Street. Flemington, NJ 08822. Located in the. Commerce Street Shopping Center. Phone (908) 806-6022. Fax (908) 806-7022. 6:30am to 2 …
The Bagel Club, Deli and Catering – Flemington
Bagel Club 20 Commerce Street Flemington, NJ 08822 908.806.6022. View Larger Map. The Bagel Club. 20 Commerce Street. Flemington, NJ 08822. Located in the
Best Bagels in Flemington, NJ | The Bagel Club | Bagels near me
Welcome to The Bagel Club—your local spot for handcrafted bagels, fresh salads, and classic deli favorites. Located at 20 Commerce Street in Flemington, NJ, we’ …
Reviews
Nicole Esposito
Stopped by The Bagel Club and overall had a solid experience—definitely a good spot if you’re looking for a casual bagel place with plenty of options.
Service:
The staff was friendly and welcoming, which always makes a difference, especially during a busy morning or lunch rush. Ordering was easy and everything moved along smoothly.
Food & Options:
There’s a great selection of bagels to choose from—something for everyone whether you like classic flavors or want to switch it up. They also offer a wide variety of cream cheese flavors, which is a big plus and makes it easy to customize your order.
I ordered an onion bagel, toasted, with extra cream cheese. Flavor-wise, it was pretty good and the cream cheese portion was generous. One small downside was that it wasn’t fully toasted on half of the bagel, which was a little disappointing. That said, it was still enjoyable overall and I’d order it again.
Coffee & Drinks:
The coffee bar was well stocked with all the necessities—creamers, sweeteners, stirrers, the whole setup—and the coffee itself was really tasty. Definitely a good place to grab both breakfast and a caffeine fix in one stop.
Seating & Atmosphere:
There’s a good amount of seating available, which is great if you’re planning to eat in rather than grab and go. It felt comfortable and not cramped, making it a nice spot to sit and enjoy your food.
Overall:
If you’re wondering whether The Bagel Club is worth a visit—yes, especially for the variety of bagels, solid coffee, and friendly service. While my bagel could’ve been toasted more evenly, the overall experience was positive. I’d come back and try other bagel and cream cheese combinations next time. A nice neighborhood bagel spot with plenty to offer.
… moreService:
The staff was friendly and welcoming, which always makes a difference, especially during a busy morning or lunch rush. Ordering was easy and everything moved along smoothly.
Food & Options:
There’s a great selection of bagels to choose from—something for everyone whether you like classic flavors or want to switch it up. They also offer a wide variety of cream cheese flavors, which is a big plus and makes it easy to customize your order.
I ordered an onion bagel, toasted, with extra cream cheese. Flavor-wise, it was pretty good and the cream cheese portion was generous. One small downside was that it wasn’t fully toasted on half of the bagel, which was a little disappointing. That said, it was still enjoyable overall and I’d order it again.
Coffee & Drinks:
The coffee bar was well stocked with all the necessities—creamers, sweeteners, stirrers, the whole setup—and the coffee itself was really tasty. Definitely a good place to grab both breakfast and a caffeine fix in one stop.
Seating & Atmosphere:
There’s a good amount of seating available, which is great if you’re planning to eat in rather than grab and go. It felt comfortable and not cramped, making it a nice spot to sit and enjoy your food.
Overall:
If you’re wondering whether The Bagel Club is worth a visit—yes, especially for the variety of bagels, solid coffee, and friendly service. While my bagel could’ve been toasted more evenly, the overall experience was positive. I’d come back and try other bagel and cream cheese combinations next time. A nice neighborhood bagel spot with plenty to offer.
Amy Susney
The bagels aren’t the same, but they’re still good bagels. Place is clean. It’s a bagel place. If you place a big order at a busy time, check your order. That’s standard for any food establishment. Their bagels are good, I’ve never had bad service, nor do I expect a gala in a bagel shop. I see people with some reviews that make it abundantly clear they’ve never worked in food service, and perhaps should be less judgemental, and take time to be a more conscientious consumer.
… moreTarra Vargas Waters
The bagels are delicious. Just check your order before you leave. Sometimes they are spot on, other times not so much
… moreRocco Limone
I’ve lived in Flemington for 15yrs, Bagel club was always a decent place. The past yr it gone downhill. Long wait, bagels are average at best and the prices don’t match the quality or quantity. Will not return.
… moreAlyssa
SO GOOD. Bagels & fillings were great, better than others in the are. we also got breakfast potatoes that were great, took most of them home and reheated them the next day and they were just as good. I think the potatoes were like $2.50? and bagels were also priced well/lower than expected. staff was friendly, shop was busy but didn’t have to wait long for our food at all. you could tell that this is a local favorite. will definitely be back!
… moreSanjoy Mukherjee
Excellent bagels – firm on outside moist inside without being too doughy. Wide selection of bagels. Great egg sandwiches. Online ordering app needs some enhancements. Nice atmosphere to eat in.
… moreBarry Lasher
I tried everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, absolute perfection. Strong coffee, friendly and efficient staff. Catherine welcome me with a big smile, Definitely will be back and Highly recommend!
… moreLayla Quiroz
I was at the DMV, and i saw this was the nearest bagel spot. Went to give it a try, definitely old school looking but in a good way. Service was good. The bagel itself was mid, coffee was good though.
… moreMario Paparozzi
I wish I could give this place ten stars! It’s phenomenal! My wife loves its power bars!
… moreVirginia Siglin
While the food is great, I’ve never been to a restaurant that shuts down their equipment early. I tried to order a single bagel sandwich and they denied me because they closed the grill before it was actually closing time. I’ve been a cook for over 20 years and have never worked in a restaurant that turns away a customer before closing time. If you are open to a certain you should offer your whole menu till that time. Very disappointing.
… more