Matthew
I decided to try it again and give it a second chance and boy was I wrong to. Bad pizza, very little red sauce and very little cheese. I definitely had better frozen pizza that I got for less then $5. Definitely don’t come here, 100% bad. Also taste like 2 day old pizza.
… moreRich
Order here a few times…at first good 2 wings and a thigh. Lately when I ordered, wings and thigh over cooked. Tonight, I ordered 6 wings….WINGS I asked for flats and she said no, can’t do all flats….got 6 drumsticks. The young girl at the front desk took my order, put me on hold for 5-6minutes came back on and asked me is this for delivery or pick up. No problem, I understand this may be their first job but to not realize I already ordered…hmm.When I returned with the drumsticks, the cook (who is not to blame at all) he had to ask her if it’s ok to make me 3 flats. He had to ask….smh. I’m done with Molly’s P&C.
… moreJamie Mayer
I placed the call for a pickup, was put on hold five times in between talking to someone that was trying to take my order.
I requested the food lately baked.
They got that one right.
Ordered two pizzas and two breadsticks.
For what they charged me, you would think that they would use BETTER CHEESE.
Hey I know the cost of everything is going up.
For what they charge for pizza they need to use a better cheese because they’re way overpriced for what they’re serving…
The breadsticks were a hit here.
They truly were good.
The pizza however, not so much.
Even had a over buttery taste to the dough.
Don’t get me wrong the pizza was not bad.
However for what you’re charging for it is a different story…
… moreChristine Cetnarowski
First time trying the chicken based on a friend’s recommendation.
BEST CHICKEN EVER!
Leg had sooo much meat; was huge.
Crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside.
Will definitely order again!
Pizza was good too.
… moreJohn Lopez
New ownership of a classic Pittsburgh pizza shop located in the south hills part of the city. This review is a comparison of the new vs what it was a year ago.
I purchased a Large 16inch half pepperoni half cheese. I was told the price was $19 and when is arrived it was $21. Not the best way to start even though the delivery person was very nice.
The goods, its better than its neighbor and the friendliness of the staff. The pizza is edible.
The bad, tough and no fluff crust. It was tough to bite, probably needs more yeast and a warmer H2O temp or possibly a little time for the dough to rise. The cut was all over the place. Some large, some small. A little more sauce and better cheese would make this pizza a 4 vs a 3 star.
Overall, will I eat from Molly’s Pizza again…Yes. I aware that there is new ownership and that the local establishment needs time to perfect after being closed for amount of time.
Should you try Molly’s Pizza, well that’s up to you.
… moreT
The food is delicious, the staff are friendly and welcoming, and the eating area is cozy. 10/10, will be coming back for more chicken wings.
… moreZeke Cane
We ordered for delivery a pizza split between ham and green peppers and pepperoni. Polite service, arrived early and the pizza was perfect. Temperature was on point and the crust was crispy. Definitely would recommend.
… moreJoseph Murray
Molly’s by far has the best chicken bacon ranch sub along with its pepperoni pizza. It is a simple, no frills place that delivers on quality
… moreBernadette Hughes
Ordered Molly’s pizza a lot over the years., Not sure if they changed hands or what’s going on but we had company today ordered 2 large with various toppings a & Hawaiian pizza & macaroni bites. Hawaiian pizza and the bites were great but the two large pizzas were nothing like a typical Molly’s pizza very thin crust very dry hardly any cheese, the Half with black olives had a lot of black olives on it but the other halves with sausage and pepperoni had very little toppings. Definitely not the typical Molly Pizza that we’ve gotten over the years. Hopefully it’s a one time fluke otherwise we’ll be looking for a new pizzeria.
… moreLori Russo
The pizza is weird. Crust doesn’t taste like pizza crust. Where’s the sauce? Hardly any cheese and strange oil taste on top. I can’t even call it pizza.
… more