Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Your “Go To Place” in Conneaut Lake, Pa. for Artisan/Craft Foods and Desserts.. The “Ice House Pizzeria has the biggest selection anywhere! Best Hometown Bakery and Pizza shop in Conneaut Lake and the entire Pymatuning Lake Region… Largest Menu with so much selections to choose from… 24 pages of food within our menu!! Amazing Pizza, over 130 Artisan Pizzas, 54 Flavors of Wings, Calzones, Wedgies, Burgers, Pasta, Salads, over 60 styles of Subs and so much more… plus we have a bakery connected to us too.. amazing food all the time If you like Great Food, Amazing Cannoli’s and Cool local History, then stop in at the “Ice House Pizzeria & Grille” and let us spoil you and your tastebuds. Thanks, hope to see you soon!!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 390 Water St, Conneaut Lake, PA 16316
Phone: (814) 213-0076
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Ice House Pizzeria & Grille Menu Conneaut Lake – Postmates
390 Water St Conneaut Lake PA 16316 $$ • Pizza • American • Italian x $0 delivery fee Other fees x Enter address to see delivery time.
Order Ice House Pizzeria & Grille – Conneaut Lake – Uber Eats
Subs and Melts (Hot- Melt -subs- Hoagies). Pittsburgh ”strip District” Subs. Fresh Cold Subs/hoagies. Burgers. Our Classic Burger. Loaded Baked Potato …
Ice House Pizzeria Grille: A Culinary Gem in Conneaut Lake, PA
Discover Ice House Pizzeria Grille, your go-to destination for delicious pizzas, homemade pastries, and an inviting atmosphere in Conneaut Lake, PA.
Last Updates
Reviews
AJ
This place is great!!! We were looking for a local store and found this gem. It looks like the place is family-owned, the people who manned the place were great. It looked like they knew everyone in the community too which is a great sign.
The food wait time is about 15-20mins because everything is made fresh! The owner doesn’t use that much sugar in their pizza sauce, it’s more tomatoes than sugar,
Food is great especially the price point! All prices you see are with tax already which is awesome!
I hope people who travel in the area or nearby go here. It’s an experience. I will definitely go back! There’s lots of stuff on the menu to try which I will be doing
… moreThe food wait time is about 15-20mins because everything is made fresh! The owner doesn’t use that much sugar in their pizza sauce, it’s more tomatoes than sugar,
Food is great especially the price point! All prices you see are with tax already which is awesome!
I hope people who travel in the area or nearby go here. It’s an experience. I will definitely go back! There’s lots of stuff on the menu to try which I will be doing
Sherry M
First I will be say this is carry-out only! But when we walked in it was very homey. They had a case with cookies, cake and pie slices, mini bread loaves and a wall of all sorts of jams, jellies and lots more. We then ordered our pizza from a book that has pages of items on them. You need to go to the website to see the menu as I couldn’t even put a dent in the variety they have, which is more than just pizza. Definitely recommend if your in the Conneaut area to pop in and order yourself a pie. Allow at least 25 minutes as we stopped in the late afternoon and I feel around the dinner hour it could be a bit longer. A solid 4.8!!!
… moreChristin Smith
These pizzas were loaded with toppings! We got a supreme, Alfredo steak vegetable, and cheese.
Will go back to try more, it’s remarkable the variety of pizza choices available or create your own. The bakery case inside has options you never knew existed, such as chocolate mud cake, giant cookies, and turnovers in a variety flavors. Will be back when in the area!
… moreWill go back to try more, it’s remarkable the variety of pizza choices available or create your own. The bakery case inside has options you never knew existed, such as chocolate mud cake, giant cookies, and turnovers in a variety flavors. Will be back when in the area!
Stephanie Lamperski
My husband and I are visiting the area and stopped in on a whim..the delicious aroma of pizza convinced us to stay and look at the menu -it’s the most extensive menu we have ever seen! So many options! Creative dishes, clever and fun pizza toppings. Specials were told to us by the nice girl at the counter. We looked at all the bakery items, donuts, huge cookies at prices I haven’t seen since the ‘80’s! Donuts start at $1 each and they are huge not succumbing to shrinkflation you see everywhere else! Huge specialty freshly baked cookies -$1.25 each – 3/$5! Also local jams, salsas, pickled vegetables, and more all much lower than grocery store prices and many more flavors than typical. The owner was very friendly explaining how he views his business as having fun with food, loving what he does and thinking and working “outside the box” as the key to his success. He told us all this while working on an order for customers. A real multitasker! We walked out completely satisfied with goodies and jars of jam to take home as gifts. We will recommend Ice House Pizzeria and Grill (and bakery and specialty foods ) to everyone we talk to who might be visiting Conneaut, Linesville, Meadville areas!
… moreDave VanArsdale
I have stomach cancer and order my food very specifically so I am able to digest it. I should not have to return my sandwich because you decided to make it how you wanted instead.
EDIT. I will also add that the person taking the order repeated back the order, and she wrote it down correctly. I have ordered the SAME order for the last year and a half, so this was not a new request, and we were not new customers. You gave my wife a gift card with no balance, or value printed that is basically useless to anyone. We won’t be back!
… moreEDIT. I will also add that the person taking the order repeated back the order, and she wrote it down correctly. I have ordered the SAME order for the last year and a half, so this was not a new request, and we were not new customers. You gave my wife a gift card with no balance, or value printed that is basically useless to anyone. We won’t be back!
Monica Ferguson
This place is incredible & should have more stars for me to fill in! The massive array of offerings is second to none. The owner Randy & his wife truly care about every detail of the food they serve as well as every customer. The pepperoni rolls are heavenly & so much thought has gone into making them better & more delicious than any other I’ve ever had! Pastries, pies, cakes, macaroons, donuts, cookies, cheesecakes, breads… the list is endless! All freshly made, & all insanely delicious! This gem of an establishment couldn’t be more perfect. From the offerings to the lovely owners, the bar has been raised! What a unique & rare thing to not be able to decide which is your favorite item is!
… moreEthan Rimolt
Gary did the wedding cakes for my cousins wedding. PHENOMENAL. He made the cakes with love and care and they were absolutely incredible to eat. We also came twice for breakfast during our weekend here and once for dinner. You can’t miss on this menu. Go out of your comfort zone and try a crazy pizza, you won’t regret it. We will ABSOLUTELY be back.
… moreSteve Schilling
I absolutely love this place! Best pizza since I left NY over 25 years ago! The atmosphere is great, the service is amazing, and the food is to die for. Pizza, wings cookies, donuts, bread, everything! If you want good food and lots of choices for even the pickiest of eaters, you can’t go wrong going here.
… moreChristopher Winn
Such an awesome place to go. Definitely recommend checking it out. Such nice people working met the owner as well he is a groovy cat. So much to choose from. Literally how could a person not love this place. The atmosphere alone!
… moreJ Rossey
pizza is really yummy here taste and texture plus not thick crest. plus they have donuts ,cookies plus all different things there plus try out there bacon donut. they have donuts in the box good price on pizza and 6 donuts in the box.$ 21.00 not bad price.
… more