Micheal
Fresh out the plane looking for a little bite to eat later in the evening so we ran across Mister M. The portions were good. The homemade chips were great to go with my sandwich. The garlic Parmesan wings were OK and the blue cheese had chunks just like I like. I typically just drink water but tried the grape soda which was perfect to top of the meal. Good deal for the money.
… moreAnthony Carbone
Mister M’s knocked it out of the park! I went with my mom on a Friday night and we had an absolute blast. The pizza was loaded with toppings, the wings with the recommend house sauce was delicious, and the grilled cheese sandwich was huge. Their house brew was dynamite and paired perfectly with everything. We left completely stuffed and still had leftovers to take home! Can’t wait to go back. Highly recommend!
… morejames conner
We finally made it to Mr. M’s after much anticipation. We come to town several times a year to see family…..now we will make this a regular spot. We had a blast. Proper old school food and atmosphere. Honest, no pretense, simple pleasure. And our very sweet server Alex is the greatest. We’ll come back just to see her!!! She’s the best Rep they could ever have. Cheers.
… moreRachel
I’ve been traveling all over this country working for years and I have to say Mister M’s has to be at the top of my list! The atmosphere is laid back and welcoming. The staff is accommodating and I haven’t met one that wasn’t, well just pleasant to say the least. But the food.. OMG, the food! Granted I get the same thing most of the time, but it’s amazing! And I have tried other stuff on the menu but… Their chicken parm sandwich is something to write home to Mom about!c Amazing! When you stop in, try “The Gotti”! You WON’T be disappointed! I typically try to eat half there and take the other for lunch the next day, but getting the first part all eaten is a challenge in itself. I also love their house chips it comes with, and I’m not a potato chip kinda girl!
Also, I’m not one to give 5 stars anywhere because I believe there’s always room for improvement.. But Mister M’s deserves every one of them!
… moreWarren Schanback
We were looking for some good ol’ Western NY Soul Food; you know, Beef on Weck, Chicken Parm, Gnocchi, Chicken Wings, Pizza and Cold Brew on Tap. Oh boy we weren’t disappointed. In comfy hometown surroundings, Alex fed us and shared stories that made us feel at home. We can’t wait to come back on another night to try some of the other nightly specials. We hear the dinner theater the owners put on while they prepare dinner for a lucky handful of patrons is worth the wait. We will be back!
… moreStacey Love
I got a to-go order so I cant comment on the atmosphere, but the staff is super friendly! was my first time ordering from Mister M’s and will definitely return in the future. I got the chicken parm chips and breaded mozzarella. the chicken parm chips are 10 out of 10 for sure! was slightly disappointed with the breaded mozzarella, but im super picky. was still good, just not for me. plus the prices are great, especially nowadays. definitely nice size portions as well! thanks for a delicious dinner
… moreNicholas Navas
Worst parking. Best food. PERIOD. All jokes aside, this was the highlight of my first visit to Niagra. Didn’t get the Armenian/Italian waitresses name, awesome still, very cool. Introduced us to Tyler. Had a chance to share how much we enjoyed everything as well as with the gentlemen (forgive me for not recalling his name at the moment, our cook for the evening, and a quality craftsman). Thank you so much, much love and well wishes, and maybe hopefully visit again sooner than later. Cheers!
… moreJennifer “Jaypez423” Perez
**Review: A Hidden Gem for Italian Food Lovers**
Tucked away on a quiet street, this small, cozy Italian eatery is a delightful find for anyone craving authentic flavors in a warm and inviting atmosphere. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with the rich aroma of fresh garlic and herbs, instantly transporting you to the heart of Italy.
The menu is thoughtfully curated, featuring classic dishes made with high-quality ingredients. The pasta is homemade, and you can taste the difference in every bite—al dente and perfectly seasoned. The sauces are rich and flavorful, with just the right balance of savory and tangy notes. Their pizza, with its thin, crispy crust and generous toppings, is a must-try.
What truly sets this place apart is the ambiance. The intimate setting, with soft lighting and rustic decor, makes it perfect for a romantic dinner or a quiet meal with friends. The staff are friendly and attentive, adding to the warm, family-like atmosphere.
If you’re looking for a spot that serves delicious Italian food with a personal touch, this charming little restaurant is definitely worth a visit. It’s the kind of place that makes you feel at home while delivering a dining experience that’s nothing short of exceptional.
… moreChel O
I came in late on a week night after a long travel day. The bartender was extremely personable and the kitchen took me as the last order. I was able to order the cauliflower crust pizza with steak and it was amazing. The crust was light and crispy and tyne pizza had amazing flavor. Thank you for a wonderful first day experience.
… moreS D
ONE OF THE BEST RESTO-BAR’S IN THE FALLS, FUGGHETABOUTIT!!!!!
Try the chicken parm, its served on DiCamillo bread if you get it as a Hero and is supurb.
Mad respect to Mr. M always
… more