Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Simple stop for thin-crust & Sicilian pizza by the pie or slice, plus calzones, wraps & more.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 831 Bass Pro Ln, Cary, NC 27513
Phone: (919) 677-8484
Website: http://www.theoriginalnypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Original NY Pizza – Cary
Bringing A Taste Of New York To North Carolina Since ’91. Premium Wisconsin Cheese, Freshly Packed Italian Tomatoes, & Dough Made In House Daily is Our Recipe!
Original NY Pizza HARRISON AVE Cary, NC Extra cuz … – Facebook
Harrison Ave. The OG. I used to work there 20 years ago and the same manager has been there for 30 years so it’s super consistent. This was really good.
The Original NY Pizza, 6458 Tryon Rd, Cary, NC 27518, US
Get more information for The Original NY Pizza in Cary, NC. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Mags
Since moving from New York earlier this year, we have been searching for a good pizza place. I found a pretty good one here at NY Pizza. I knew it would be good when I saw firemen waiting for their order! I just had a slice of cheese pizza which was very good: thin crisp crust (I asked for it well done), the right proportion of cheese to sauce, that was placed to the edge. Sauce was nicely cooked-down and seasoned just right. I have found food here, in general very salty, this was not salty, just well seasoned, delicious! Service was nice and friendly. The only thing I would say is that the size of the slice was a little small compared to pizza in New York. But I will definitely go back for pizza, and try other things on the menu too. Thanks for making it authentic!
… moreMayson Finley
Excellent pizza craftsmanship and great service. My mother and I came in looking for dinner for the family and ordered a stuffed pizza with everything on it. At first the gentleman behind the counter didn’t know if could be cooked throughly but a gentleman from the back stepped up to test and served us an amazing quality pie! Shout out to Quan! he really did his thing!
… moreJay
Mediocre pizza and lousy service.
I visited before heading to the airport after having not come in years. I don’t know if ownership has changed, but the pizza isn’t nearly as good as it used to be.
I ordered two slices with sausage, pepperoni and spinach. The spinach was raw and just slapped on top, the sausage was barely cooked and the crust was comically crunchy to the point of being burned.
Perhaps worse is the service. I was the only patron in the place when I walked in. The three guys behind the counter barely greeted me, took my order and didn’t even say thanks. As I waited for my food, I watched several others come in and be greeted like family members. When my food arrived the guy just said “your slices are ready”. No thank you or anything. When I left nobody even bothered to say anything, despite the place (again) being empty.
I don’t like making assumptions, but as a middle aged man of color I can’t help but notice how I was treated vs others. Perhaps the employees should check their biases. Combine this with lousy food and it’s a recipe that guarantees they’ll never get my money again.
… moreI visited before heading to the airport after having not come in years. I don’t know if ownership has changed, but the pizza isn’t nearly as good as it used to be.
I ordered two slices with sausage, pepperoni and spinach. The spinach was raw and just slapped on top, the sausage was barely cooked and the crust was comically crunchy to the point of being burned.
Perhaps worse is the service. I was the only patron in the place when I walked in. The three guys behind the counter barely greeted me, took my order and didn’t even say thanks. As I waited for my food, I watched several others come in and be greeted like family members. When my food arrived the guy just said “your slices are ready”. No thank you or anything. When I left nobody even bothered to say anything, despite the place (again) being empty.
I don’t like making assumptions, but as a middle aged man of color I can’t help but notice how I was treated vs others. Perhaps the employees should check their biases. Combine this with lousy food and it’s a recipe that guarantees they’ll never get my money again.
Scott McLendon
My credit card transaction shows Bass Pro Shop as the merchant; that’s odd! It’s crazy how corporate America has taken over everything.
It’s really good pizza! I had a slice of pepperoni. Super quick and friendly service. Why is my money going to Bass Pro Shop?
… moreIt’s really good pizza! I had a slice of pepperoni. Super quick and friendly service. Why is my money going to Bass Pro Shop?
Caitlin
I am long overdue with this review. This has been our go-to local pizza place for years. Reliable, delicious, really nice guys working there, and if you sign up for their loyalty program you get $10 off every now and then! Give them a try!
… moreVasil Abed
The best slice of pizza I had in a long time. Cooked to perfection tasted like my childhood in Brooklyn. The Cannoli was the best, simply delicious. Going back for their calzones.
… moreDaniel Smyrski
One bite, everyone knows the rules and these guys kill it for authentic NY style thin crust slices! Great under carriage/crisp, nice tang to the sauce, right amount of other seasoning. Portnoy would be impressed!
… moreVikki Martin
I debated on the rating because there are good and not good things experienced. I opted to be more generous versus more critical. 3.5 would be true rating. The positive is they are very fast with delivery compared to other places. The ingredients are good quality. Salads are nice and they’re generous with dressing. Usually the amount of toppings is good but we had a few times in recent months where things were skimpy, to the extent I started ordering double toppings. On this occasion they were back to being generous so double meatballs was overkill. We find the veggy toppings are barely cooked but if you ask for the pizza more done the crust is too done. Favorites are meatball parmesan and ham and pineapple. Husband always gets pepperoni and mushroom. Their wings are pretty good, 7 out of 10 according to wing connoisseur husband. They do have a reward program so you earned $10 off after you spend so much and they periodically send me a we miss you $5 off or free garlic knots offers.
… moreB Bailey (Raptor Face)
For starters, the pizza is great! Definitely the highlight of the menu.
The wings on the other hand, not so much. I’ve got them 3 times and not once have them been crispy – including when I specified cooking them longer for crispiness. Also, they don’t make their own ranch and give a packet of Ken’s ranch.
The “Greek” salad is not bad, but they give you Balsamic vinaigrette as opposed to Greek dressing, which I don’t get.
A few tweaks could really take this place from average to great!
… moreThe wings on the other hand, not so much. I’ve got them 3 times and not once have them been crispy – including when I specified cooking them longer for crispiness. Also, they don’t make their own ranch and give a packet of Ken’s ranch.
The “Greek” salad is not bad, but they give you Balsamic vinaigrette as opposed to Greek dressing, which I don’t get.
A few tweaks could really take this place from average to great!
Bobby Lee
Stopped in after BP Shop excursion and was absolutely delighted with it. Tried the stuffed pizza, stk/ch panetto and the spinach panetto… Very good and will definitely be back.
… more