Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria is a beloved multi-location pizzeria headquartered in Rochester, NY since 1978! We serve up delicious pizzas that are crafted with the finest ingredients. Our diverse menu includes classic and gourmet pizzas, mouth-watering wings, subs, salads, pasta dishes, and more. Whether you’re dining in, taking out, or enjoying our efficient delivery service, you’ll experience the same high quality and exceptional taste that has made us a local favorite. Catering services are also available for events of any size. Visit one of our convenient locations to taste Rochester’s Favorite Pizza!
Area chain restaurant offering creative pies, tons of toppings, wings & Italian subs.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Geneva | Salvatore’s Pizzeria
Welcome to Salvatore’s Pizzeria in Geneva, NY. Located at 812 Canandaigua Road, our Geneva location brings Salvatore’s full menu to the Finger Lakes with a …
Locations – Salvatore’s
Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizza is proud to have over 25 locations throughout the Rochester and Western NY region, order Salvatore’s Pizza online in your …
Salvatore’s pizza in Geneva NY? – Facebook
Salvatore’s pizza in Geneva NY? Pizzaholics … 19″ Pepperoni, mushroom, onion from Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria in Rochester, NY.
Reviews
Geoffrey Hellauer Geiger
Delicious and fresh. I love Salvatore’s so I’m glad it’s now in Geneva. Got the super slice ($10) combo and a medium cheese to go. Great sauce and counter service. Only nitpick is no forks available at lunch time. But it was crowded so no real harm on restocking that. Glad to see this old Pizza Hut space being used. Will be a good place to bring family for pizza nights.
… moreJessica Brown
Is this a joke? How is this a half a pound? I’ve ordered this before from here and have gotten a lot more than this but this time and for $8! I don’t think so. And when I called all the girl could say was our stuff comes pre packaged! Right sure. The customer service I received tonight was just downright awful for the amount of money I spent! No way would anyone in thier right mind pay $8 for a handful of fried mushrooms. This is why I took my 5 star rating back as well as the rude customer service I was given tonight when I called to ask about it! This makes me not want to spend money here anymore
… moreGregory Bannish
Excellent service despite them being absolutely swamped. Salvie plate was delicious. Love the remodel of the old Pizza Hut!
… morealyssa Rasmussen
Got a slice to go and ended up fining a rubber band in the sauce. Will not be retuning there.
… morePaula Guenot
First time there got 2 big slices of pizza and bottle of soda and a cookie for 10 dollars pizza was delicious and cookie was too will be back there.again to try other things very good place was very clean and staff very nice!
… moreBrian McGuire
Visiting Rochester from California with my wife and daughter, I was finally cornered into trying the pizza place she’s been hyping up for years. Coming from the West Coast, I’ll admit I was a skeptic, but to her delight, I stand corrected. In an era where pizza quality is often hit-or-miss, this was a nostalgic home run. It felt like the pizza I grew up with: a perfect crust, spot on toppings-to-dough ratio and a sauce that wasn’t too sweet or thin, and more importantly, actually tasted like tomatoes.
Another non-negotiable for my wife was ordering a round of wings with blue cheese. I’ve never been a big wing person and always figured her obsession was just hometown nostalgia, but these could actually convert me.
As great as the pizza and wings were, the highlight of our visit wasn’t actually the food. We arrived with our one-year-old daughter, who was hungry and jet lagged. Not a good combination for a public setting. The staff couldn’t have been more understanding; they brought out a snack for her right away to keep the peace while we waited for our pizza. Seeing her go to town on a slice in each hand… and making a massive mess in the process… the employees met her chaos with nothing but warm smiles. We’ll definitely be back at least once more before we fly home, and it’s now a mandatory stop for all our future visits.
… moreAnother non-negotiable for my wife was ordering a round of wings with blue cheese. I’ve never been a big wing person and always figured her obsession was just hometown nostalgia, but these could actually convert me.
As great as the pizza and wings were, the highlight of our visit wasn’t actually the food. We arrived with our one-year-old daughter, who was hungry and jet lagged. Not a good combination for a public setting. The staff couldn’t have been more understanding; they brought out a snack for her right away to keep the peace while we waited for our pizza. Seeing her go to town on a slice in each hand… and making a massive mess in the process… the employees met her chaos with nothing but warm smiles. We’ll definitely be back at least once more before we fly home, and it’s now a mandatory stop for all our future visits.
Brad Steinruck
Ordered our food at 1pm to pick up at 615 pm. Got there at 620 and waited for 30 more mins for my food. Ordered medium pizza with peppers and pepperoni with 10 wings. 42.36 . Service is slow and prices are outrageous,but the food is good.
… morestephanie k
Pizza was brought to the table quickly. Service was friendly. Pizza was delicious. Bright atmosphere. Clean bathrooms
… moreMaddison Green
Service was amazing, Staff are so friendly and welcoming! Super busy so was expecting a long wait time, but food was delicious, hot, and on time. I highly suggest checking this location out!
… moreGarrett Proctor
Called to order pick up, the female who answered was absolutely terrible. Had to explain myself several times and alls I ordered was a large pizza. Was told 25-30 minutes, I walked in it had been 27 minutes and they hadn’t even put the pizza in yet. Ten employees working and not one knew what was going on.
… more