Alisa S.
Ordered 2 large pizzas and a salad for delivery. Food is good, but the pizzas were clearly dropped or fell off a car seat or something. Toppings were all messed up and one pie had pieces folded over on top of the pizza. We had to replace toppings amd cheese as best we could. For the nearly $90 we spent, expected much better quality contol/effort to delivery a quality pizza.
… moreJustin Crum
Imagine being in one of the richest parts of castle rock “ny style” pizza and then hiring the cheapest people in the world to run it. I ordered a 18 inches extra cheese pepperoni and a slice of cheese Sicilian. The pizza comes with cheese covering the The pepperoni which tells me it’s an old pizza that they just threw extra cheese on then I get the Sicilian slice and it’s got uncooked mozzarella on top of it with a horrible sauce. It’s cooked to the quality of a crouton hard inedible. This is an even close to New York style pizza, but it was gross and I will never go back here. Little Caesars does better that’s how sad it is.
… moreR M
Anthony’s offers New York style pizza. The pizza is not ready to go right then, there is a little wait, but not absurd. It wasn’t busy, but more people did come in while I was there. There is a TV on one side of the seating area. Looked clean inside. I liked the pizza crust, and I would eat the pizza again. The slice was large which is good since it has a thinner crust and cost around $5 for a slice.
… moreChristine H
I first ordered for delivery a vegetarian pi,za which was delivered having sausage and pepperoni on it and then contacted the store who had me come in and pick up a replacement. The replacement was so badly hurt the taste was horrible and this was there attempt to show a good product.
… moreCraig VanStone
I’ve been going to this Anthony’s once a month for 8 years, ordering the same thing every time. White pizza with pepperoni and garlic cheese bread, it was pricey but worth it. They changed things on the menu and the pizza wasn’t good and the cheese bread I paid $8 for is a wet bun. I called them to get this resolved they told me there’s nothing they will do for me, “it’s a corporate thing”. They have just lost a very loyal customer.
… moreKathleen Rubio
Wonderful service Great Pizza pasta chicken parm and Fettuccine Alfredo. They took real great care service was amazing Thank you from El Paso Tx Lady Pumas RSL west.
… moreConnie Kautz
Ordered a large pizza with pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms for take out. Each topping was $3.50 each!! Total charge $38 for a large pizza! Highway robbery especially since the pizza lacked those toppings. Hard to find any toppings! I’ve had way better pizza for way less dollars! Opt for Little Caesars in the same area.
… moreDavid Andrews
My large cheese pizza was great. Also another time. Went in an hour before close on a slow day. Got Two slices. And they were fresh. Impressive for it being slow and almost closed. Also the pizza is like the big thin new york style. Like a mom and pop style pizza (my favorite)
… moremarley green
Always a delicious experience, love the balsamic, glazed ribs, the oysters, raw, and the oysters with fried cheese. The lobster gnocchi is always very good and the meatballs are delicious. Thank you guys so much.
… moreKevin Spillane
Lucky to get one star. This wasn’t even fully cooked when it was taken out of the oven before being delivered.
If I wanted take and bake I would order from another place.
It’s a shame because a few years ago I gave this a high rating and praised it for being perfectly cooked like a NYC pizza from when I worked as a teenager.
The cook incomplete. The cheese is pure oily trash.
… more