Leah Rutberg
Great place with lots of unique flavors (the cannoli cream cheese is amazing). Service is friendly, though sometimes a bit slow, which matters if you order ahead and expect a quick pickup.
Recently I’ve noticed a gummy texture in the center of some bagels — maybe moisture/heat inside the shop? I have to rip out that part before I eat it. It doesn’t happen at every location. Also, many flavored bagels only have seasoning on one side, so the bottom can taste plain.
Still, tasty and worth a visit — just a couple consistency fixes would make it perfect. ✨
… moreAngela Bell-Deems
Delicious! My bagel was hot, super fresh and so mouth watering. I got the Asiago/everything bagel with chive & onion cream cheese. That combination was a delicious flavor explosion! The manager (I think) was super friendly and explained to me how they boil the bagels fresh daily there. They were cooking them as I watched. This was more of a to go spot with a walk up register and mostly kitchen atmosphere. But, totally worth stopping in for. Or pre ordering a fresh bag to go.
… moreFlbeachygirl
Busy location but staff do their best to keep the line moving with a smile. Bagels toast perfectly – crispy outside and soft inside definitely try a flavored cream cheese. Ask staff for combination recommendations.
… moreIsaac Parker
I was in and out more or less, but I owe to myself and my fellow bagel fans to at least say a few words about the Jeff’s Bagel Run around the corner from me. Really like the blink and you’ll miss it spot… honestly have driven by it so many times and didn’t know it was there. The manager and crew are on point and beyond awesome. I’m talking free samples and customer service that is top-tier.
Might just be my favorite Jeff’s Bagel Run spot, even moreso than the Winter Park location. Keep up the great work.
… moreCharlie Bernard
Jeff’s Bagel Run is hands down the best spot for fresh bagels! Every time I visit, everything is always incredibly fresh and delicious. The variety is great, and you can tell they really care about quality. On top of that, the service is friendly and efficient—always a welcoming experience. Highly recommend if you want a tasty bagel with excellent customer service!
… moreMike 5.56
Always looking for a good bagel spot, they have clearly very good bagels here, spread was a little pricey and would have been 5 stars but they do their salt bagels wrong. See images for example. Left good right wrong
… moreLionel Harmon
Drive by store many times never stopped on Edgewater drive . When I did meet Jeff’s team. Smart outgoing knows the bagel and coffee game. Service 5 star protein coffee just helped me get to morning class downtown it’s my regular stop . People product and service is what makes my experience there stand out did I mention first visit bagel was free
… morezsanett Olah
We love coming here. The bagels are soft so fresh. The cream cheese is delicious. I had the Honey Pistachio latte and it’s sooo good. I love the customer service here everyone is so nice.
… moreDaeja Augustave
I stopped by Jeff’s Bagel Run in Lake Mary today and had such a great experience! Dani and Sandra were super friendly and helpful at the register. They made ordering super easy and gave me so many samples of the spreads to make my decision easier. Connor made my bagels perfectly (seriously, they were fresh and delicious), and Lily absolutely nailed my surprise coffee. The whole team was upbeat and welcoming, which made the place feel extra inviting. Definitely my new favorite breakfast spot in Lake Mary!
… moreAmy Saperstein
This is my favorite bagel place (and I live in Tampa!) Bagels are always soft, fresh, and delicious. My first time here, the bagels had just come out of the oven and were hot and steamy. The flavored cream cheeses are the best – definitely get the cinnamon sugar bagel with the banana pudding cream cheese. So good! I’ve also had the Asiago bagel which I loved too. The staff are very friendly and welcoming. Give this place a try, you won’t regret it!
… more