Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Carol City, FL, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Carol City pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Carol City or stop by 19625 NW 57TH AVE for carryout to order the best pizza in Carol City, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 19625 NW 57th Ave, Carol City, FL 33055
Phone: (305) 624-7272
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Johns Nw 57th Ave – Carol City
Call us for pizza delivery in Carol City or stop by 19625 NW 57TH AVE for carryout to order the best pizza in Carol City, along with breadsticks, wings, and …
Pizza in Carol City, FL | Papa Johns Nw 57th Ave
For pizza delivery in Carol City, call us at (305) 624-7272 to order, or stop by 19625 NW 57TH AVE in Carol City, FL for carryout.
papa johns stores in carol city, fl
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Carol City, Florida to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Last Updates
Reviews
Yassandra Casado
Whenever Dubison is working, you know you’re in good hands! His customer service is top notch, and he treats everyone so well. I’ve never had a problem when he’s on shift. He’s an amazing manager!
… moreC. H. T.
Did an online order for pickup 12.2 and the order was ready when I arrived. I however had to wait for the manager to help make pizza before I could get my order. While waiting I just happened to look over at the manager only to see him using his hands with NO gloves to make the pizza. Then when I finally got my order and checked it he said he accidentally made one of my pizza extra large. Of course I didn’t mind that because I didn’t pay anything extra but felt sick at the thought that he might have also made mine without gloves. I sent a feedback to headquarters the same day and requested to be contacted via email but no response yet.
… moreLe Tour Guy
This store is one of the cleanest chain stores I’ve ever been to. The fact that they care that much about cleanliness, invites you to order and eat your food without worries. The staff is helpful and the General manager makes himself available to assist and/or address any concerns you may have. If you’re a chicken wings lover, be sure to ask for Dubi wings. They are carefully seasoned and prepared based on preference.
… moreTeneille Phillips
I ordered 2 pizzas and an order of the calzone bites. I have ordered the calzone bites before so I know they shouldn’t have cheese or sauce inside. They should have meat and veggies . Well what I got had only cheese and sauce inside. I called the store and got someone names Doby (not sure the spelling) he was very rude. He told me it was impossible for it to be wrong because he made it. I told him mistakes happen but he still told me it couldn’t be possible that it’s wrong!! I felt like he was calling me a liar. He told me to bring it back and he would replace it. But after his rude words, I didn’t want anything else from him. The customer service from this location is a disgrace. I posted pics so everyone can see there is cheese and sauce in these things , maybe he will learn not to call his customers liars and be a little more humble and polite.
… moreAmy Tenorio
Absolutely amazing service and workers! They were absolutely SLAMMED today (08/29/25) but they were able to stay cool,calm, and collected while being sweet and good with their service. Even though there were people coming in screaming and being terrible they were cordial and did everything they had to. I’m sure that due to being slammed they missed a small thing in my order, but they righted it IMMEDIATELY and were so amazing, sweet, and understanding. Loved their attitude and their work ethic. I hope that the manager/franchise owner recognizes who is working for and under them and compensate them accordingly. 10/10 recommended spot.
… moreAnny T
Got wings and pizza and the wings were horrible. Tasted old and spoiled. Thought it was maybe because I wasn’t in the mood for it but stored it and the next day, it tasted the same- horrible. Idk if it’s the buffalo sauce that’s not good or what. Definitely won’t be ordering back from there.
… moreKendra
If I could put zero stars I would. My pizza was dropped by the driver and left on my porch without notice. Dubi (manager) was rude and unhelpful. Will be filing a complaint with better business bureau.
… moreElif Denizer
My son get a free large Pizza for student of the Month, I did my order online it was supposed to be ready in 19 minutes I arrived there in 25 it wasn’t ready and the lady has bad attitude the bredstick burned in the end I need to wait 20 more minutes
… moreWilberto Reyes-villanustre
i am leaving a review to bring it to this establishments attention how i was watching the manager Dubie i believe they told me his name was, handling and stretching the dough with rings on and a apple watch which the dough was getting on and that is absolutely disgusting. I am a jeweler and clean jewelry all the time and the amount of grime and bacteria that rings collect is astonishing. Please take those things off if you are prepping food for customers.
… moreNancy Descoteaux
I ordered for delivery. Almost an hour went by I looked and it says delivered. Still didn’t get my pizza. It is now way over an 1:15 hr still no pizza. I called without asking my order number they told it’s on its way! Waited on the phone for 5 min. To be told just that without verification. I don’t want to eat at 8pm…I ordered around diner time to have it for diner! And paying almost $40 for a pizza and rolls to have to put it in the microwave is BS!! I will never order there again!! Done with Papa John’s
… more