Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 24458 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key, FL 33042
Phone: (305) 744-9718
Website: http://www.asliceofparadisemenu.com/?utm_source=gbp
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
A Slice of Paradise – Summerland Key, FL – 24458 Overseas Hwy …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for A Slice of Paradise in Summerland Key, FL. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
A Slice of Paradise (Summerland Key, FL) (@slicelifefl) – Facebook
A Slice of Paradise (Summerland Key, FL). 1445 likes · 90 were here. Serving delicious pizza, subs, wings, pastas and desserts since 2004. Locally owned…
A Slice of Paradise – View Menu & Order Online – 24458 Overseas …
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Summerland Key, FL! A Slice of Paradise is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Last Updates
Reviews
Justek A
It was a great service , we had a take out. The lady who we ordered from was very nice. This is the first time for me to try the pizza in this place and my husband had it years ago.Medium buffalo chicken pizza was exceptional, and belive me I am so picky about my pizza. My husband’s pizza with sausage and mushrooms was excellent. If you dine in you can eat inside or outdoors with a great canal view and in the shade, you know how important it is for us locals, to have a shady spot.I would definitely go back . Highly recommended.
… moreKathleen McQuinn
Called in for delivery for the first time today since moving to Cudjoe and could not have been more pleased. Reading the reviews made me hesitant, but we really wanted to embrace our local spot. We’re stoked we tried them today because they delivered a 5-Star experience! Phone call was quick, professional and efficient. Prices are fantastic (especially considering it’s privately owned in the Keys), delivery arrived in 36 minutes (quoted 45), their driver (no it’s not a delivery service, he’s their employee) was super kind and also brought our requested peppers and cheese. Opened the boxes and they were hot and perfect! This is definitely our new GO-TO!!! Highly recommend!!! Pro Tip: ASK if you need peppers, cheese, silverware, napkins, etc. Pay with card over the phone or have exact cash change, with tip 😉
… moreSam
Well… not my best purchase. This place is not what it used to be. Half of the boneless wings were the size of popcorn chicken with sauce thrown on half of them. “Large” pizza was a medium at best and didn’t taste great either. It’s nice that Summerland has a place like this, but I wish they cared more about quality.
… moreSabre Mendoza
Absolutely AWFUL food delivered last night. Alfredo pasta was congealed, disgusting mess, about 3 cups of noodles and a couple of tablespoons of sauce congealed in the middle with tasteless chicken, dry and obviously from a can. The pizza was the 4 cheese pizza that also came as a congealed sloppy mess with the cheese separating from the crust, cheese also tasted foul. Food went right in the trash can. We have tried multiple times over the years to give this place a chance when another local says, well they changed this or that and I did not like them either, but it’s different now. ABSOLUTELY NO MORE CHANCES HERE. No wonder the place is for sale!!!!
… moreRich Greeves
*DO NOT USE IF YOU WANT HOT ACCURATE ORDERS*
With over 5 million views of my review photos you’d think they would have taken this more seriously!
The quality of the food was good, the accuracy however leaves a lot to be desired. We ordered 2 thin crust pizzas, as you can see.epic fail number 1 – they weren’t both thin crust. Epic fail 2, we ordered a full thin crust pepperoni with roasted red peppers and mushroom on one side, you will notice pepperoni on one side only and no sign of mushrooms or peppers.
Then to make matters worse the food didn’t turn up. We are in a secure vacation park, we gave very clear instructions including the lot number. There were 4 people in the house, no TV or music on and all of the lights on.
When I called the store as the order didn’t arrive, they told us the driver knocked and no one answered and the lights were off, utterly ridiculous.
We then met the driver at the gate and had inaccurate cold food for dinner.
What did we get as compensation $10, seriously this should have been fully refunded, but no $10 os the sum total for this appalling failure of service.
*DO NOT USE IF YOU WANT HOT ACCURATE ORDERS*
… moreWith over 5 million views of my review photos you’d think they would have taken this more seriously!
The quality of the food was good, the accuracy however leaves a lot to be desired. We ordered 2 thin crust pizzas, as you can see.epic fail number 1 – they weren’t both thin crust. Epic fail 2, we ordered a full thin crust pepperoni with roasted red peppers and mushroom on one side, you will notice pepperoni on one side only and no sign of mushrooms or peppers.
Then to make matters worse the food didn’t turn up. We are in a secure vacation park, we gave very clear instructions including the lot number. There were 4 people in the house, no TV or music on and all of the lights on.
When I called the store as the order didn’t arrive, they told us the driver knocked and no one answered and the lights were off, utterly ridiculous.
We then met the driver at the gate and had inaccurate cold food for dinner.
What did we get as compensation $10, seriously this should have been fully refunded, but no $10 os the sum total for this appalling failure of service.
*DO NOT USE IF YOU WANT HOT ACCURATE ORDERS*
Charity Charity
Pizza was good, and the staff were friendly, but they didn’t really have it together, on the phone, or when we got there. Other than that, it’s good food and a cute set up right on the water with lights.
… moreNonrevkcin
4.2/5 Stars
The staff are extremely friendly and get the order correct. The pizza it’s self wasn’t my favorite. We ordered 3 pizzas and all of them had almost no sauce at all. The underside of the pizza and crust was very crunchy. Not my favorite kind of crust personally but I know some people prefer that.
… moreThe staff are extremely friendly and get the order correct. The pizza it’s self wasn’t my favorite. We ordered 3 pizzas and all of them had almost no sauce at all. The underside of the pizza and crust was very crunchy. Not my favorite kind of crust personally but I know some people prefer that.
Shan Lee
Veggie pizza take out today was amaaaaazing… I’ve had all the pizza in Key West where I live and I loved this even better! The girl at the counter was so sweet and the man that brought us the pizza was nice also .. thank you ♥️
… moreMichelle Hitchcock-Wallace
Picnic tables outside had ants all over, no in̈side seating. Looks nice with lights overhead Picnic tables but needs cleaning and maintenance around area.orinigally planed to dine in but no inside seats so we ordered then planing to sit outside but then had our order to go. Our pizza was not as ordered so another was made so we had only our cheesy bread and waited again. Probably will not use again while vacationing in area.
… moreBob Strempek
It felt like pizza night, everyone needs a pizza night.
From Cudjoe there’s a few choices just north, Summerland, Big Pine or No Name. We went Summerland naturally, pick up, gotta get it home warm.
Slice of Paradise. The call was made, they sounded busy but quick to get back to the phone. That’s nice, hate holding for a simple order.
We went hand tossed cheese and thin crust cheese. 20 minutes. Price seemed reasonable. Nice.
Got there and was surprised at the back seating area. Very nice, water view, canal. Under the trees, ambiance lighting and picnic tables. I’d imagine it’s nicely shaded.
Pizza was ready, zoom, home. The reveal, looks good and cheesy. Both of em. The difference in crust was obvious.
I went hand tossed, the wife thin. Very good, both of them. Nice cheese taste, some mozzarella pull too. The crust, yup, no flop. No flop! I took one bite and knew, good.
… moreFrom Cudjoe there’s a few choices just north, Summerland, Big Pine or No Name. We went Summerland naturally, pick up, gotta get it home warm.
Slice of Paradise. The call was made, they sounded busy but quick to get back to the phone. That’s nice, hate holding for a simple order.
We went hand tossed cheese and thin crust cheese. 20 minutes. Price seemed reasonable. Nice.
Got there and was surprised at the back seating area. Very nice, water view, canal. Under the trees, ambiance lighting and picnic tables. I’d imagine it’s nicely shaded.
Pizza was ready, zoom, home. The reveal, looks good and cheesy. Both of em. The difference in crust was obvious.
I went hand tossed, the wife thin. Very good, both of them. Nice cheese taste, some mozzarella pull too. The crust, yup, no flop. No flop! I took one bite and knew, good.