Casey Darnell
The grandma pizza looked pretty but the pepperoni was disappointing. As with most giant square pizzas, the dough was chewy and borderline undercooked in the middle of the pizza. What really bothered me was the sloppy monstrosity they called a calzone. I assume we got the large size though I didn’t ask for that. The cheese inside was room temperature and the sausage and green pepper mixture was tasteless.
… moreThomas B
Holy cow. My new favorite. Stopped in for a slice and was more than pleased. The BBQ pizza was amazing, and they had their own soda brand. Black Cherry and a fresh slice. Friendly staff and very clean restaurant. I’ll be back for sure
… moreerin sherrod
I saw the good reviews so I ordered on Doordash so I ordered the baked panzarotti. The dough is good, but everything else was just okay. My biggest gripe was that the box came cut open as shown in the pictures. The panzarotti was cold and left room for food safety concerns. Who cuts a pizza box open especially for delivery. I got a refund from Doordash and I called the restaurant which there was no apology, just “I’ve never seen that before”. I don’t think I’ll be ordering again.
… moreSamantha Orta
The absolute best pizza place ever. If you haven’t been here yet you HAVE TO GO, you will NOT be disappointed. The atmosphere is amazing and everyone is so friendly. But there is one person out of everyone that really stands out and his name is Aaron. Ask for him! He’s the best! My most favorite item besides the grandmas pizza is the milkshakes. His creation of these milkshakes compares like no other. Rich, Creamy, Smooth, flows right through the straw and into your mouth tasting like absolute perfection. I have genuinely never had such an amazing milkshake and it’s only because of this man that they even have them. My family and I come every Friday after work and let me tell you it will be a tradition that I will continue on.
… moreElizabeth Boehmke
Grandmom Slice: Oh wow!” Old school pizza
Light crispy thin crust. Sweet sauce that isn’t over powering. Great amount of cheese.
Mozzarella sticks: stringy homemade sauce
Chicken Ranch Bacon: wasn’t what we expected. Light on ranch. Chicken and bacon under cheese. Good amount of meat. Little heavy on tomato for us.
Young gentlemen that helped us was very friendly and polite. He gave us slices of Grandmom pizza to try when we said we came because of the reviews.
Said they have a 3 mile delivery radius.
Most likely will come back and try more of their pizzas.
… moreRoc Lab
I absolutely love cafe Antonio’s I always get my food hot good and flavorful thank you and very much appreciated always good ppl good drivers good pizza good good good love your pizza
… moreOlivia Harvey
Stumbled upon this place while my two-year-old wandered in, and I’m so glad we did! The owner was incredibly kind—he gave my little one a free cookie and even offered my husband and me a slice of pizza on the house. Not only was the pizza absolutely delicious, but my husband and I both agreed this is going to be our new go-to pizza spot. The owner is super sweet, the atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the cookies are phenomenal. Excellent pizza, amazing service, and a true neighborhood gem. 10/10—highly recommend!
… moreSharon Gray
food was great! Ordered a salad and they forgot the dressing. Someone came back with dressing! That’s what I call good customer service! Definitely order again
… moreErma Baker
Had my worries about the other dishes, as I usually do when it comes to pizza places in South Jersey. But I must say Cafe Antonio’s delivered and then some! Every appetizer was delightful and had me almost forgetting about the pie that was to come. And then that grandma pie… the sauce, the cheese, even the dough, every ingredient shined! I have heard good things about their pizza but I was still very, very pleasantly surprised. I will be coming back.
… moreShiane Salabie
One word: OBSESSED! I love their pizza. I would highly recommend it. I come here often for good food and to chill. I usually get either pepperoni pizza or Margherita pizza. Sometimes half and half of those two types. They are both delicious. The crispy crust paired with the flavorful sauce and toppings is just to die for. Only thing I would say that may be a con is the parking is not the best due to its location. Street parking mostly. For atmosphere, what could probably be improved is maybe some light background in the music. It is VERY busy usually but there are a lot of takeout orders so dine in is usually available. Music would be nice for the dine in guests. The service is top notch. You will be greeted by friendly workers at the door eager to serve. 10/10 experience. Whenever you are in the area, stop by. You will not regret it.
… more